LOCALISATION 22
intro
d
e
a
c
s
localisation of function is the theory that different areas of the brain are responsible for different behaviours, processes or activities
the hippocampus and the frontal and occipital lobe
hippocampus is responsible for converting stm to ltm and the frontal lobe is responsible for movement, the occipital lobe regulates vision
balanced review / detailed account
maguire (2000), bremner (2003), draganski (2004)
draganski (2004)
aim
rm
p
f
linking
ct
to investigate whether the structure of an adult human brain alters in response to environmental demands as a result of learning a new motor skill
field experiment
done in the everyday environment of the participants, the experimenter still manipulates the iv but in a real life setting
24 volunteers (21 female, 3 male), control mri scan, taught a 60 secs juggling routine for 3 months (new motor skill), 2nd mri to identify differences, 3 months not juggling and 3rd mri
increase in two regions (frontal and occipital lobe) after 2nd mri, 2 areas shrunk again after 3rd mri
draganski demonstrates the frontal lobe and that it is responsible for motor skills. for example, after 3 months of learning to juggle, the mri showed an increased size of the frontal lobe which then decreased when the participants stopped juggling for another 3 months. this is important because while learning the motor skill, the frontal lobe was consistently in use, causing it to increase in size. when participants stopped juggling, the lobe is no longer used, resulting in volume of the area decreasing, highlighting its true function (motor skills). therefore ...
strength
weakness
ethics; volunteers
they know what they're getting themselves into, etc
low repeatability
mris are expensive
bremner (2003)
aim
rm
p
f
linking
ct
to investigate the effect of ptsd on hippocampus volume and matter
case study
studying one person or a group of people for a reason unique to them
33 women, 3 groups; early childhood sexual abuse and ptsd (10), abuse without ptsd (12), no abuse or ptsd (11). mri to measure volume of hippocampus, pet scan to measure level of functioning during verbal declarative memory test
abused women with ptsd had 16% smaller hippocampus volume compared to women with abuse and no ptsd, showed lack of activity when doing memory task
bremner demonstrates the effect of ptsd on hippocampus volume. for example, the hippocampus of women with abuse and ptsd had a 19% smaller hippocampus than the women with no abuse or ptsd. this is important because the difference in hippocampus size displays the lack of need for the hippocampus, which is responsible for converting stm into ltm. as the women have ptsd, they would be actively trying to suppress their memories, meaning the hippocampus would be less active, explaining the difference in volume and lower results on the verbal declarative memory test. therefore, areas of the brain are localised with specific function.
strength
weakness
internal validity
control groups, increases reliability that IV is sole influence on DV
gender bias
reduces generalisability across a target pop, important to use men too
maguire (2000)
aim
rm
p
f
linking
ct
to investigate the effect of navigational memory on the size of the hippocampus on london taxi drivers
quasi experiment
a naturally occurring iv, a difference between people that already exists, researcher examines the effect of this variable on the dv
two groups: london taxi drivers (experimental) and non-taxi drivers (control) that had mris to examine the structure of the brain, pixel counting was used to measure the size of the brain, providing quantitative data
london taxi drivers have a larger posterior hippocampus and non-taxi drivers have a larger anterior hippocampus
maguire demonstrates that the posterior hippocampus and its function is to store navigational memory. For example, the london taxi drivers had a larger posterior hippocampus in comparison to the non taxi drivers group from the mri and pixel counting technique performed. This is because london taxi drivers undertake 'the Knowledge' requiring extensive memory of the roads of london. this caused the posterior hippocampus to increase in size due to increase of function. therefore, areas of the brain are localised with a specific function.
strength
weakness
low researcher bias
quantitative data was used
low generalisability
london, other places don't require the knowledge, low cross-cultural validity