Please enable JavaScript.
Coggle requires JavaScript to display documents.
E1N8: Getting Ready for Peer Feedback - Coggle Diagram
E1N8: Getting Ready for Peer Feedback
"How to Write Meaningful Peer Response Praise"
Praise is extremely important in peer reviews, affirms what someone is doing is good so they keep on doing it
actually put work into it, or it won't even have mattered in the first place
ask questions about the other persons writing!
dont only comment on easy fixes
How to give good praise
"what about writing we like? Why do we like
it? What does it mean to “like” an opening sentence, an image, an insight?"
"Meaningful praise, then, is feedback that recognizes something that is working for you as a reader, that gives you an opportunity to have a dialogue with the author, and that expresses some sort of appreciation for the work the writer has done, or for the writer herself."
"Shitty First Drafts"
putting many small ideas together that are incoherent at first, review two times and put together a beautiful piece
do not worry how the start it, just work hard to put it together in the end
can take several months or years to go through peer review
"Peer Review in 3 Minutes"
research article
a research article reports a scholars research findings , written intended for an audience of other researchers
must pass peer and editorial review
PEER REVIEW
draft submitted for application as scholarly journal,
step 1. the journals editor will decide if it is a good fit for their journal
step 2. if approved, send to peer review. then, judges quality and significance of findings, usually if approved instructed to make revisions
high rejection rate for publication