Debates in contemporary society

Section A

Crime and Deviance - The social
distribution of offending and victimisation

Who is committing crime ?

Who is not committing crime ?

Social class

Gender

Ethnicity

Social class

Gender

Ethnicity

Sociology exam structures

Paper 3 Section A

10 Mark question (PEEL)

3 paragraphs

20 Mark question (PEEL)

Three paragraphs for
Three Paragraphs against

40 Mark question (PEEL)

4 paragraphs for
4 paragraphs against
Fourth point is a critical conclusion

Paper 3 Section B

Globalisation

9 Mark question (PEEPEEL)

2 paragraphs using a source in each

10 Mark question (PEEL)

2 paragraphs for
2 paragraphs against with reference to
a source at least once in the question

16 Mark question (PEEL)

Two paragraphs for
Three paragraphs against

Define Globalisation

Cochrane and Pain - Suggest it is the emergence of a global economic and cultural system which is incorporating the people of the world into a single global society.

Cohen and Kennedy - Suggest it is a series of transformations of the world, including changes in concept of time and space, interdependent economies, increasing cultural interaction and increasingly shared problems.

Giddens - Argues it is defined as the intensification of worldwide social relations which link distant localities in such a way that local happenings are shaped by events occurring many miles away and vice versa.

Developments in digital communication

Digital Revolution - Digital technology has meant data and information can now be stored and accessed all around the globe through international programming systems (Apple). This digital revolution is the idea that there are NEW platforms and changes to old ones to modernise them

Global Village - Giddens argued that we now live within our own global villages. This is the idea that digital communication has allowed us to keep in contact with friends, family, businesses and others via the internet and social media. He argued that we now use increasing amounts of communication which do not face to face and as time and distance shrink, the world is becoming a smaller place.

Networked Global Society

Media Convergence (Boyle) - Boyle argues this is the way that information can be combined and delivered into one format (joined together). For example, a website can include videos, text and images can all be stored and accessed on one website.

Social Media

Visual Communities (Carter) - Carter is looking at a social network with CyberCity- a place where people can connect online and form and maintain relationships. These can be used socially but also for businesses to find a workforce, advertise or advertise (LinkedIn is an example of this).

Digital social networks (Putnam - social capital) - Bowling Alone- warns that our social capital (the very fabric of our connections with each other) has declined, making our lives and communities less rich, less diverse and more impoverished. Putnam argues that social capital in the USA is in decline; political and civic participation is in decline, as is church and union membership

Marxism - Digital Communication

Cornford and Robbins - Argue that digital communication is simply a way for capitalism to control people more subtly through their use of social media under the guise of protecting from terrorism. For example, it is often unclear if or how much the company owning the software program such as Facebook are collecting information on the individual’s choices and decisions

The Snowden Report - In 2013 the US National Security Agency (NSA) specialist Edward Snowden revealed widespread misuse of surveillance of digital forms of communication. He provided evidence that the US and British Government has been accessing personal and private communications claiming it was in the interests of ‘national security. But the intelligence agencies dismiss such claims, arguing their programmes are necessary and legal. Surveillance, they say, is essential to meet their overriding aim of protecting the public from terrorist attacks.

2 Criticisms of Marxism

Arab Spring

Everyday Sexism

Feminism - Digital Communication

Positive - Nacamara

Negative:

CEOP - In 2012-13 the Child Exploitation and Online Protection Centre

The centre for social justice

Postmodernism - Digital Communication

Why we post - Miller

Foucault - Surveillance Society

2 Criticisms of Postmodernism

Positive and Negative impacts of digital communications on identities

Locke and Pascoe - Benefits of digital communication on identity

Haraway - We are all Cyborgs now (can be used as positive and negative (Paris Brown)

Age

OFCOM survey of generational digital divide

Boyle - Generational Divide

Palmer - Toxic Parenting

Postman - Loss of class - the digital underclass

Berry - Older users of the internet

Class

Mertens and D'Haenens - The digital underclass

Sinner and Prochanzka - Educational inequalities

Gender

Li and Kirkup - Men in computer games; pressure of one line perfection (Survey by girl guides association)

Positive and negative impact of digital
communication on relationships

Feld - (Positive and negative of on-line relationships)

Hinton and Hjorth- 2013 (form relationships across the globe)

Dodge and Kitchin - 2001 (websites to reconnect local communities)

Clayton - (The twitter affect)

Shaw and Grant - (The positive effects of the internet)

Turkle - (Connected but alone)

Putnam - (Bowling alone)

Bauman - Social networks as the new opium of the masses

Digital communication on conflict and change

Change

Conflict

Sri Lanka Terrorism

Revenge Porn

Arab Spring

BlueForSudan

Women2Drive

Upskirting

The impact of digital communication on cultural homogenisation

The effects of cultural homogenisation:

-Capitalist ideology

-Patriarchal ideology

-Consumerism

-Secularisation

-Individualism

The impact of digital communication on cultural defence / globalisation

Know at least one case study of globalisation

Sociology exam structures

Paper 3 Section A

10 Mark question (PEEL)

3 paragraphs

20 Mark question (PEEL)

Three paragraphs for
Three Paragraphs against

40 Mark question (PEEL)

4 paragraphs for
4 paragraphs against
Fourth point is a critical conclusion

Paper 3 Section B

Globalisation

9 Mark question (PEEPEEL)

2 paragraphs using a source in each

10 Mark question (PEEL)

2 paragraphs for
2 paragraphs against with reference to
a source at least once in the question

16 Mark question (PEEL)

Two paragraphs for
Three paragraphs against

Define concepts of crime and deviance and explain crime and deviance are socially constructed

Define crime and deviance

Social construction - Relativity of crime and deviance

Plummer - Public v Private deviance; societal v Situational crime and defence

Measuring crime statistics

Definition of official statistics and examples

At least 4 strengths (link to theory: Positivism, realism, functionalism

At least 4 weaknesses (Link to theory: interpretivism, interactionism, Marxism)

Measuring crime - Victim Surveys

Definition and examples

At least 3 strengths

At least 3 weaknesses

Different types if victim surveys

Quantitative

Qualitative

Measuring Crime - Self report studies

Definition and examples

At least 3 strengths

At least 3 weaknesses

Patterns of crime - Global context

Global organised crime - definition
and example

Green crime - definition; examples;
link to Marxism

Evaluate functionalist and New Right theories of crime and deviance

Durkheim - Crime is inevitable and functional

Merton - Strain theory

Functionalist subcultural theories

-Cohen - Status Frustration
-Miller - Focal concerns
-Cloward and Ohlin - illegitimate opportunity structures
-Murray - Underclass

Matza - To criticise

New Right theory - Murray; Hirschi (control theory), Clarke (rational choice)

Interactionist theory of
crime and deviance

Becker - Labelling process

Jock Young - Hippies in Notting Hill

Lemert - Primary/ secondary deviance and stuttering)

Cicourel - Negation of justice

Moral Panics and the media


Cohen - Mods and Rockers
Fawbert - Hoodies

Evaluate realist theories or
crime and deviance

Left Realist
Lea and Young - 3 causes of crime

Right Realist
Clarke - Rational choice theory
Wilson and Kelling - Broken windows

Evaluate Marxist theories of
crime and deviance

Law making
-Chambliss
-Snider
-Kolko and Graham
-Box

Law breaking
-Chambliss
-Snider
-Corporation Crime

Law enforcing
-Gordon
-Reiman
-Chambliss
Box

Neo-Marxist Theory - Subcultural theory
-Clarke - Skinheads
-Hebdidge - Punks
Resistance and Rebellion

Theories - Why the working
class commit crime

Interactionism

Functionalism (New Right)

Realism

Neo-Marxism

Marxist

Feminism

Relationship between gender and crime

Why females commit less crime than males
Oakley/McRobbie - Gender role socialisation
Heidensohn - Control theory
Lees - Fear of labelling

Explain why female crime is increasing
Adler - Liberation theory
Jackson - Ladette culture
Carlen - Women in poverty and crime

The statistics are socially constructed
Pollak -
Chivalry theory -
Gelsthorpe and Louck -
Self report studies -

Women may be treated harshly by the CJS
Smart - Chivalry theory
Farrington - Walklate

How masculinity is linked to crime
Messerschmidt -
Winlow -

Explain the relationship between ethnicity and crime

I can explain why ethic minority groups are more likely to commit crime than the white majority
Patterson - Host-immigration model (functionalist)
Gunter, Pitts - Culture and identity explanations
Lea and Young - Left realist
Sewell -Triple Quandary

Explain that statistics are socially constructed: Black people do not actually commit more crimes than white people
Gilroy - Cultures of resistance
Hall - Mugging moral panic
McPherson - Institutional racism
Holdaway - Canteen culture
Waddington (Criticism) -

How crime can be reduced

Left Realist Views
Social and community crime prevention-(reducing inequality; perry pre-school project)
Restorative justice and reintegrative shaming- (link to interactionism - avoid the label).

Right Realist Views
Situational crime prevention
Environmental crime prevention
Retributive justice
Prisons work (Punitive punishment)

Cohen -
Merton -
Cloward and Ohlin -
Patterson -