Please enable JavaScript.
Coggle requires JavaScript to display documents.
BALANCE OF RIGHTS AND DUTY, abbreviations used - Coggle Diagram
BALANCE OF RIGHTS AND DUTY
about
F.R
claims individual essen. to his or her existence and development
eccno.
social
cltrl rghts
Duties
duties towa individuals, society, nation, or humanity as part of society and its norms
ex Rita(natural order) - vedas princi. Dharma and karma
F.r
part 3rd
duties
part 4a
both are indispensable, duties have taken backstage in present India in comparison to rights
Right to Life’ or ‘Freedom of Speech and Expression’, both remain focus quite
duties, except few like “corporate social responsibility-others talk little
Benefits of Perceiving Rights and Duties Together
Complementing Nature
each right corresponding obligatio resp rights otrs
Media - right freedom speech, becomes duty to respect others’ privacy as well.
Immunize Individual Liberties
Rule of Law - state respo, duties ensure at least majority popu. inclined uphold law w/o exter. enforce.
Ensure Peace and Harmony
Duties with rights help admin. constru. engage. with people. helps building mechan promote culture peace & harmony n
ex
one abides Constitu & respects institutio. earnestly (first fundamental duty), peace harmony incre.
conscious decision abjure violence preserving vibrancy & pluralistic nature society
discour acts of violence
all forms of discriminatio
Help State in Performing its Duty
W/o people’s supp. State can’t ensure all rights
meet the educational nutritional State support parents or individuals who work on field or help in resource availability by paying taxes
Avoid Narrow Egoism
Common humanity genuine respect others’ right requ people overcome selfish avoid human rights violations
Issues in Perceiving Rights and Duties Together
Difference of Nature
Cert rgts acqui H.B birth, but duties -capable indivi perform
Rights are precursors to Duties
W/o basic dignity fulfill. rgts, indivi can’t perf. duties.
W/o fulfil. Rgt edu/n, dts resp others rgt, social justice, gender equality etc.diffic. expect
Different legal status
Justiciability key featu. rgts. rgts enfor writ . dts non-enforce. guide aid interpret cons legal issues (AIIMS Students Union v. AIIMS, 1983)
Prov pote leeway State responsibilities
Prote Rule of law human rgts state respo - enjoys special powers under laws
non-fulfill dts can't given reason non-enforc rights.
Risks ofsubordination
Equal focus - subordi collective will
Vague and Subjective Nature
Another issue vague nature dts , clash with certain religious principles.
E.g., noble ideals freedom stru cover wide diversity , confli. interpretations w/ other princi
way forward
preserve human rgts dignity, mini. balance alongside independent application
State acce. primary respons. promo. protection human rgts irres fulfillt duties citi
Meeting mini. core rights each citi
Inde. Hmn rgts Institu monito State institutions
Deepi. roots demo
minimizing risks of subordination of rights
maximi. possi fulfil dts
Creating a basic charter for people
culti. constitutional morality
abbreviations used
rgt
right
dts
duties
con/tn
constitution