Theme D - Religion, Peace and Conflict

L1: The Nature of War

War

Militarism, alliances, imperialism, nationalism

Conflict, corruption

Impacts of war

Instability - social, environmental, political, economic

Death, injury, chaos, destruction

Weapons, propaganda

Driven by beliefs as well as material ambitions e.g. land disputes

Is War ever necessary?

For

Fighting for a good purpose e.g. against discrimination, most social causes/environmental

E.g. the American civil war, north against south, north trying to end slavery - they eventually won

Helping allies

E.g. America after bombing Hiroshima and Nagasaki helped to rebuild Japan but to gain them as an ally for the Cold War.

E.g. Indian Independence movement

Way of proving your duty to your country

Way of strong expression of beliefs

Against

Takes a very long time and is a constant back and forth interaction

Causes huge instability during and in the aftermath of the war

Propaganda encourages fake news

Promotes glorified perspective of war

Causes permanent mental and physical damage - soldiers PTSD

Innocent people die

Hits those most disadvantaged in society

Social divide

L2: Causes of War

Greed

Advancing ones empire, gain more land

Conflict - fuelling increase in power + resources

Examples

Colonisation of India by British Empire

Colonisation of Africa

US vs Iraq War

Muslim Empire

People justified it by saying it was “civilising the people” + “teaching them appropriate ways of living through Christianity”

Wanted to introduce teachings of Christianity to other people

However by doing this they are disregarding another culture + religion by claiming their own is better - elitist

Self defense

People may fight against those who have attacked them/may perform a pre-emptive strike
someone declares war against a country which has not yet threatened them directly, but which they believe will threaten them

Examples

2003 invasion of Iraq (government believed Iraq had WMDs that could be used against them)

UK’s part in WW1 (Hitler= threat to public safety)

Muhammad led Muslim soldiers into battle to protect people

Hindus of the Kshatriya warrior class - duty to fight and protect others if no other course of action was available

Hindus believe if someone becomes violent, ahimsa no longer applies to them - self defence is acceptable

Jesus did not justify violence in any circumstances - pacifist

Retaliation

Revenge for a previous attack

Considered to show countries that they cannot attack another for a bad reason - will suffer consequences

Discourages future attacks

Examples

Conflict in Iraq - retaliation attacks on the World Trade Centre

Some Christians may feel that it is acceptable, only if it teaches not to fight against others - preventing loss of life.

However most believe retaliation is wrong - Jesus thought that you should not take revenge

“Turn the other cheek”

L3+L4: Religion as a reason for War

Holy war criteria:

Has a religious goal

Authorised by a religious leaders

A spiritual reward for those who take part

Christianity and War

New Testament - Jesus supports pacifist approach

Old Testament - Many accounts of battles fought under God’s protection

“Let us bring the ark of the Lord’s covenant from Shiloh, so that he may go with us and save us from the hand of our enemies” -1 Samuel 4:3

“Do not repay anyone evil for evil” Romans 12:17-45

“Live at peace with everyone” Romans 12:17-45

“Turn the other cheek” Matthew 5:38-45

Islam and War

Greater Jihad

personal battle that every Muslim has with themselves

personal struggle/strive to live properly, overcome obstacles, temptation and to live the life of a good Muslim

Lesser Jihad

outward struggle/ striving

on occasion it may be necessary to fight against evil in the world - taking military action to bring about a just society = lesser jihad

Muslims have rules about how wars should be conducted

The Qur'an and teachings of Muhammad tell Muslims that if all criteria of a lesser jihad are fulfilled then it is their religious duty to fight

any Muslim killed whilst fighting in a lesser Jihad is a martyr and will go straight to paradise

Holy war is not a term used in the Qur'an

justifications/conditions

the opponent must always have started the fighting

it must not be fought to gain territory

every other way of solving the problem must be tried before resorting to war

innocent people should not be killed

the war must stop as soon as the enemy asks for peace

chemical/biological warfare is forbidden

strengthening islam

self defence

protecting the freedom of Muslims to practise their faith

protecting Muslims against Oppression, which could include overthrowing a tyrannical ruler

punishing an enemy who breaks an oath

putting right a wrong

what lesser jihad is not

forcing people to convert to Islam

conquer other nations to colonise them

take territory for economic gain

settle disputes

demonstrate a leader's power

who is allowed to fight?

some muslim men, not boys, whose families can cope w/o them

soldiers on battlefield must fight - running away is wrong

if a town is attacked everyone must fight back - not women and children

if a leader declares war, Muslims have a duty to join an army +fight

Muhammad said one man from each 2 must fight so one can protect the town

Qur'an quotes

"there should be no compulsion in religion"

"Paradise is for those who curb their anger and forgive their fellow man"

"fight in the way of Allah against those who fight against you, but begin not hostilities"

"anyone who fights in God's way, whether killed or victorious, we shall give a great reward"

"therefore if they withdraw from you but fight you not, and (instead) send you (guarantees of) peace, then Allah hath opened no way for you (to war against them)"

L5: Religion as a cause of war evaluation

Francis Bacon: 5 causes for Holy war

to spread the faith

to retrieve countries that were once Christian, even though there are no Christians left there

to rescue Christians in countries that were once Christian from "the servitude of the infidels"

recover and purify consecrated places that are presently being "polluted and profaned"

avenge blasphemous acts, or cruelties and killings of Christians (no matter how long ago they were)

"religion is the cause of war and violence in the world"

for

against

"[religion] is one of the few things that's really strong enough to motivate people to do these terrible things" Richard Dawkins

prevents progress and restricts education access

"religion unfortunately provides a useful cover and a powerful motivator for the evil hearted" Woodcock

"without religion you have good people doing good things and evil people doing evil things. But for good people to do evil things, it takes religion" Stephen Weinberg

'religious wars' recently have been about territory and material rather than theology.

Roman Empire political aspirations of pope rather than quarrels of Protestants and catholics

not primary motives to war - afterthoughts/ pretexts/ self deluding rationalisations

e.g. Muslim+christian war in Middle East over past thousand years has been about imperial ambition rather than spiritual salvation

The encyclopaedia of wars, chronicles 1763 wars in history names just 123 as 'religious in nature' - a little under 7%

most common motivation: opposition to a gov, to economic, ideological, political or social systems of a state

all major religions have an element of 'treat others as you want to be treated' - non violence

western societies misunderstand eastern culture where often religion cannot be separated from politics. So, often 'religious conflict' is political.

state imposed atheism can cause wars

most secular countries in the world are not the most peaceful - North Korea

religion can do good e.g. islamic aid, Khalsa aid, pax christi

L6+7: Just War Theory

key words

jus ad bellum - when it is right to go to war

jus in bello - conduct during war

jus post bellum - conduct after war

some people believe that no matter how desirable peace is, in some situations, there Amy be very good reasons why war is necessary.

since medieval times, philosophers have worked on drawing up a set of rules to define when it is right to go to war

Why does the Just War Theory matter?

they consider the fairest way to be that the war should result in minimum destruction+suffering

rules of engagement are important for a civilised society

forces a country to stop and assess what it is about to do before engaging in a war

making a peaceful outcome to the dispute more likely

ensure war is fought with minimum suffering caused

USA and UK attacked Iraq in 2003 w/o waiting for official UN permission - unjustified?

criticisms

"a state has to maintain an impossibly high moral standard as any breach of the conditions lays the state open to the sort of challenge it itself is fighting against" Vardy

Just Cause

"one person's terrorist is another person's freedom fighter and deciding on justice is not easy" Vardy

"War is permissible only to confront a real and certain danger" Catholic Bishops of America 1983

war must be fought for a just cause. e.g. resisting aggression, self defence/ fighting to remove injustice

Just and competent authority

war can only be declared by a gov, ruler of UN, never by private citizen/incomplete gov

right intention

war must be fought to bring about good

can be fought to restore peace, prevent suffering+evil.

once the end has been achieved, fighting must stop

last resort

all peaceful attempts must be exhausted before violence

reasonable chance of success

no country can go to war if they stand no change of winning

prevents lives being lost unnecessarily

proportionality

only necessary force should be used to achieve the aim

e.g. unjustified to use nuclear weapons against small country over boundary dispute

prevents countries from taking the opportunity to completely annihilate one another

legitimate targets should be attacked only

hospitals, schools, homes, civilians not attacked

"the very fact that innocents may be killed in a conflict can infringe the rules of proportionality and discrimination"

"the only excuse for war is that we may live in peace, unharmed" Cicero

L9: Protest and Violence

Examples of Protests:

Anti-Lockdown Protest 2020

Hyde Park,, April 24th

protesting covid restrictions

bottles hurled at police, 8 officers injured, 5 people arrested

property damage

risk to public due to lack of masks/social distancing

Tottenham Riots 2012

march in response to police shooting of a local man turned to violence and looting

186 police officers, 16 members of public, 5 police dogs injured. 5 people killed

2815 homes and businesses damaged

over 3000 arrests

Soweto uprising 1976

students protesting law that stated they had to be taught in their oppressors' language

turned violent but was a turning point in helping apartheid end

some protests are for future generations to benefit from by helping an immediate issue

protest - an expression of disapproval, often in a public group

UK law

the right to protest is a fundamental democratic freedom

allowed so not deemed as wrong

police must be informed for safety

peaceful protest allowed, violent protest frowned upon. police in control

violence - actions that can threaten or harm others

Manchester United Protests 2021

fans protesting against owners of club

Sarah Everard's protests didn't get attention even when they were at the same time as they weren't violent

violent protests get more attention?

suffragettes vs suffragists

unnecessary? only football - there are bigger issues

big demographic of people supporting

islam and christianity

denominations of Christianity e.g. quakers - absolute pacifism

lesser jihad in islam

greater jihad - don't succumb to temptations

both think violent protest is acceptable in certain situations except some denominations of Christianity

L10+11: Terrorism

the unlawful use of violence, usually against innocent civilians, to achieve an ideological goal

key quotes

"the purpose of terrorism lies not just in the violent act itself. it is in producing terror. it sets out to inflame, to divide, to produce consequences which they then use to justify terror" Tony Blair

"Acts intended to cause death or serious bodily harm to civilians or non-combatants with the purpose of intimidating a population or compelling a government or an international organisation to do or abstain from doing an act" UN Security Council

Nelson Mandela

anti apartheid

used non violent tactics e.g. strikes + demonstrations to protest apartheid with the ANC

In 1952 Mandela helped escalate the struggle as a leader of the Defiance campaign, which encouraged black participants to actively violate laws

launched armed movements and ask for help from foreign governments

charged with sabotage, treason + violent conspiracy. admitted to many charges and eloquently defended militant activities during trial.

could technically be defined as a terrorist

Mandela was christian but never revealed much about that tying into his work

Suffragettes

technically terrorists

violent protests

smashed glass, acid in letterboxes, window smashing of gov buildings

more effective than pacifist suffragettes

freedom riders

not terrorists as non violent protest only, although it broke laws

protested segregated bus terminals by riding the buses

not religiously motivated

used strikes, boycott, sit-ins

convinced federal gov to enforce federal laws for the integration of interstate travel

L12: Weapons of Mass Destruction and Nuclear Weapons

Types of WMD

Nuclear weapons (Hiroshima+Nagasaki)

Chemical Weapons (Syria)

Biological Weapons (Salisbury poisoning)

Radiological weapons

Hiroshima+Nagasaki

First time nuclear weapon was used

90% of medical staff in both cities were either killed or disabled

radiation meant that pregnant women had difficulties with birth - deformities+cancer

Mutually Assured Destruction

1962 - it meant stockpiling a huge nuclear arsenal - concept made by USA and USSR

in the event of a soviet attack, US would have enough nuclear firepower to survive a first wave of nuclear strikes and strike back

the response would be so massive that the enemy would suffer 'assured destruction'

nuclear deterrence (philosophy of mutually assured destruction) was established

Nuclear Weapons

Chemical Weapons

bomb/missile that uses nuclear energy to cause explosion

cannister containing poisonous substance

when canister detonated, poison contaminates large area causing severe reactions to any living thing

very indiscriminate - can be blown anywhere by wind

'poor man's bomb' low investment, can cause severe psychological+physical effects

syria + Vietnam war

Biological Weapons

cannister releases agent of harmful germ/virus

death caused through infectious disease

cannot choose who to kill (like chemical)

goes against rules of war, where only military targets are justified

pollute land for many years - WW1 Germany

Radiological Weapons

'dirty bombs' use of conventional explosives to create bombs but can disperse radioactive material

killing people +area is useless- contamination

L13:Pacifism

Christian views

sanctity of life - God gives life only God can take it away

"thou shall not kill" 10 commandments

"love thy neighbour" Jesus

doesn't go w/ just war theory - not proportional + innocents are attacked

most christians would push for destruction of WMDs

Christian campaign for nuclear disarament

Muslim views

'Take not life that God has made sacred" Qur'an

'Do not contribute to your own destruction with your own hands, but do good, for God loves those who do good" Qur'an

"Fight in God's cause against those who fight you, but do not overstep the limits" Qur'an

goes against idea of proportionality and not attacking civilians found in lesser jihad

different types

absolute pacifism - no engagement in military activity at all

relative/selective pacifism - no engagement in military activity in certain circumstances

nuclear pacifism - no use of nuclear weapons

"returning violence for violence multiplies violence" Martin Luther King

Pacifist Christian denominations

Moravians

Quakers

Pax Christi

Plymouth Brethen

members refuse to bear arms+fight

Conscientious objection

when a Christian's private morality supersedes their obligations to the state they make a conscientious objection

men in ww2 refusing to go to war+bear arms - called cowards

Dietrich Bonhoeffer

taught pacifism at first but then realised Hitler wasn't going to listen to peaceful protests

German Lutheran Pastor (christian)

"christians are, therefore, faced with a dilemma: when assaulted by evil, they must oppose it through direct action. They have no other option. Any failure to act is simply to condone evil.

Liberation theology

focuses on Christianity as a view of the poor/oppressed

we are looking after the poor/oppressed

we have a duty to stand up and act against injustice

Anglican Pacifist Fellowship - pacifist group in christianity

Muslim peace fellowship

L14: Victims of War

Who are Victims of War?

innocent people

displaced people

animals

soldiers+theirfamilies

environment

helping victims

casualties are unavoidable in war

in UK if a member of military is killed/injured there are financial systems to support the families

Help for Heroes

help wounded veterans overcome daily battles+thrive

charity, partially gov funded

rehabilitation e.g. training for jobs

why would religious groups help victims of war?

"treat others as you wish to be treated

agape- "love one another as I have loved you"

Good Samaritan - everyone is everyone's friend regardless of race, gender, age, political/religious beliefs

parable of sheep and goat

sewa - sikhism (selfless service)

Zakat - islam (providing for less fortunate)

"whoever saved a life, if would be as if they saved the life of all mankind" Prophet Muhammad

Organisations

Islamic relief

created in response to famine in Africa

helps all around the world

current projects e.g. hunger no more, clean water for life

Pax Christi

believe in power of prayer, reconciliation, forgiveness, justice+nonviolence

work within Church and wider society to bring about a culture of peace

work based on gospel, inspired by faith

international catholic movement for peace

Christian Aid

"everyone is equal in the sight of God"

started in 1945 to help refugees at the end of ww2 + to eradicate poverty

follow teachings of Jesus "love thy neighbour"

get people access to healthcare, education, get fair prices for their produce