Please enable JavaScript.

Coggle requires JavaScript to display documents.

Judicial Review - Coggle Diagram

- - - - Substantive Ultra Vires
        
        Unconstitutionality of Parent Act/ Subsidiary Legislation
        
        Parent Act Ultra Vires Federal Constitution
        
        Case : Johnson Tan Han Seng v Public Prosecutor (1977) 2 MLJ 66
        
        Subsidiary Legislation Ultra Vires Federal Constitution
        
        Case : Teh Cheng Poh v Public Prosecutor (1979) 1 MLJ 50
        
        Subsidiary Legislation Ultra Vires Parent act
        
        Case : Ghazali v Public Prosecutor (1964) MLJ 156
        
        Extended (implied) Ultra Vires
        
        Retrospective Effect
        
        Case : Kerajaan Malaysia v Wong Pot Heng (1997) 1 MLJ 437
        
        Exclusion/ Ouster Clause
        
        Case : Chester v Bateson (1920) 1 KB 829
        
        Financial Levi
        
        Case : AG v Wilts United Dairies (1922) KB 897
        
        Unreasonableness
        
        Case : Arlidge v Islington Corporation (1909) 2 KB 127
      - Procedural Ultra Vires
        
        Non compliance with express procedures
- - - - Express Ultra Vires
        
        Case : Fadzil bin Mohammed Noor v Universiti Teknologi Malaysia (1981) 2 MLJ 196
      - Extended Ultra Vires
    - - Mala Fide
        
        Case : Sadanandan v State of Kerala AIR.1996 S.C 25
      - Relevant & Irrelevant Consideration
        
        Case : Tan Gek Neo Jessi v. Minister for Finance (1991), 1 S.L.R.(R.) 1, H.C. (Singapore)
      - Unreasonableness
        
        Omron Electronic Sales & Services Sdn Bhd v Phoon Wai Kit & Anor (2010)
      - Unfairness
        
        Case : Congreve v Secretary of State for Home Affairs (1976) 1 ALL ER 697
      - Improper Purpose
        
        Case : Sydney Municipal Council v Campbell (1925) A.C. 338
      - Vague Purpose
        
        Case : Yew Lean Finance Development (M) Sdn Bhd v Director of Lands and Mines, Penang (1977) 2 MLJ 45
      - Delay
        
        Pemungut Hasil Tanah, Daerah Barat Daya, Penang v Kam Gin Paik (1986) 1 MLJ 362
      - Misdirection of Fact & Law
        
        United Hokkien Cemeteries, Penang v Majlis Bandaran, Pulau Pinang (1979) MLJ 121
    - - Action Under Dictation
        
        Case : P.Patto v Chief Police of Perak (1986) 2 MLJ 204
      - Acting Mechanically
        
        Case : Simms Motor Unit v Minister of Labour (1946) 2 ALL ER 201