Please enable JavaScript.
Coggle requires JavaScript to display documents.
January Re-Sit - Coggle Diagram
January Re-Sit
AC4.3 Discuss how campaigns affect policy making
Individual campaigns
Ann Ming
Ann ming - double jeopardy law. Julie Hogg was killed by Billy Dunlop. In his first trial the jury was unable to reach a verdict and he was therefore acquired and protected by the double jeopardy law which means he cannot be tired on the same crime if they have already been tried for it. Billy Dunlop thinking he was protected by this law admitted to killing Julie. Julie's mother campaigned for the abolishment of this law. Dunlop became the first to be convicted of murder when the law was abolished
Pressure group campaigns
British Lung Foundation
This foundation aims to prevent lung disease and do so by campaigning for positive changes in the Uk's lung health. it raises awareness about lung disease, the danger that it causes and how your lungs look after smoking. Their latest campaign involved changing the laws of smoking with children in the cars. BLF secured 50,000 on a petition in 2001 and presented at number 10.As a results of the campaign, their efforts and supporting data there was a change in law which bans smoking in cars with children which came into place in 2015 under the Children and FAmilies Act 2014
Newspaper campaigns
Sarah's Law
Sarah's law. This was introduced when Sarah aged 8 was abducted and killed by Roy Whiting. Whiting was a known sex offender and wa son the Sex Offenders Register. Sarah's mum campaigned for the register to be accessible to the public for she stated if she known a sex offender was living in the area she would have never let her daughter out to play alone. She was assisted by a Sunday newspaper, News of the World who published pictures of 50 known sex offenders, however this had some backlash as people who looked like the published pictures were being attacked.
AC1.1 -Compare criminal behaviour and deviance
Deviance
Norms, moral codes and values
Norms
Rules and expectations by which a society guides the behavior of its members - keeps in check deviant behaviour
Values
Rules shared by most people - it is what people feel should happen
Moral codes
Morals or good ways of behaving
Informal sanctions against crime
Sanctions that can be imposed by most people (eg. telling off)
Parents grounding a child, frowning against behaviour, telling off
Forms of deviance
Admired behaviour, odd behaviour, bad behaviour
Odd
Deviant by being odd or different from what is considered the norm, e.g. living with an excessive number of cats
Bad
Deviant because it is bad, e.g. assaulting a pensioner
Admired
Deviant but considered good or admiral, e.g. saving a life while putting own at risk, as most people would not do so
Formal sanctions against crimes
Sanctions imposed by special authorities
Cautions, custodial and community sentences, fines
Criminal Behaviour
Legal Definition
Behaviour that breaks the law - include actus reus and mens rea
Formal sanctions against crime
Sanctions imposed by special authorities
Social Definition
Behavior that violates the norms of society or antisocial behavior
Variety of criminal acts
Fatal offences against a person, offences against property, sexual offences, drugs offences etc.
AC3.1 - Analyse different situations of crime
Fred West
Social Learning Theory
If the rumours about Fred's mother introducing him to sex is an early age are true this may account for the methods and brutality of his crimes later in life. There was a focus on rape and a sexual torture which suggest that he was heavily influenced by his mother who acted as a role model
Freud's Personality Theory
It could be argued that Fred's was unable to progress from the pleasure seeking id to the reality principle where the ego is dominant. He continued to need instant gratification from his sexual acts
Robert Napper
Bowlby's Attatchment Theory
Given the case study information about nappies life there are a number of theories that could be relevant to his criminality. For example we can consider Bowlby's theory of attachment which supports the proposition that a child needs a stable home environment to develop appropriately. However it may be argued that the separation experienced in childhood has led to individuals feeling no remorse for their victims or guilt for the crime that has been committed
Social Learning Theory
In addition the social learning theory as put forward by Bandura would suggest that Napper has learned from those around him. In particular he witnessed his father's violence towards his mother. in later life he inflicted brutal violence on women in both rapes and murders
AC4.1 - Assess the use of criminological theories in informing policy development
Criminological theories - Biological
Eugenics
'Well born', belief that humans must intervene to improve genetics, now = pseudoscience - no evidence to it
Why people want it ?
Strengthens certain characteristics within a group eg. aggression and fighting ability, take away inferior characteristics, completely eliminate a certain race
Will it work ?
Very unlikely that a widespread policy of eugenics will occur BUT - 2015 - due to moral and ethical reasons, a UK judge gave an order allowing a mother of six with learning disabilities to be sterilised
Crime control
Sterilisation laws would prevent incarcerated criminals from giving birth to 'criminal' offspring - prevent criminals being born from criminals
Policy development
Formal policy making
Informal policy making
AC1.2 - Explain the social construction of criminality
How laws change over time ?
Moral panics, miscarriages of justice, capital punishment
Capital Punishment
People realised they had more freedom - human rights. some of these were miscarriages of justice so the law was changed to prevent more from happening
Moral Panics
They made everyone fear certain crimes more as the media exaggerated them and people became irrationally fearful that sentences had to be more harsh/lenient
Miscarriage of justice
It meant that people were being sent to prison for crimes they did not commit - was unfair and so laws had to be changed to stop this from happening even more
AC2.3 - Describe sociological theories of criminality
Marxism
This theory is an ideology - capitalist society = unequal - based on exploitation of the working class (proletariat) by the ruling class (bourgeoisie). capitalism = criminogenic
AC3.2 -Weaknesses
Ignores non-class inequalities like gender and ethnicity, there have still been many prosecutions for white collar crime
AC3.2 Strengths
Shows the impact of law enforcement underpolicing white-collar crimes, reflects the power between social classes
Dog Eat Dog
In capitalism - you do get rich, but someone has to lose money for you to get money eg committing corporate crimes to generate profit
Consumer Advertisement
Capitalism pushes consumer goods at people through advertising. a lot of things that are advertised may cost too much. people want things under peer pressure- even with no money - therefore get these items through illegal means
AC2.1 - Describe biological theories of criminality
Lombroso
This theory states offenders are 'born criminals'. they have atavistic features. look different to non-criminals. primitive - evolutionary throwback. savages who cannot control their impulses (proof = tattoos)
AC3.2 - Weaknesses
Did not use a control group, failed to realise that not all criminals have atavistic features and not all people with atavistic features are criminals
AC3.2 - Strengths
First person to give criminology scientific credibility, set out the first criminal stereotypes, charles goring backed this theory with his own evidence
AC4.2 Explain how social changes affect policy development
Social changes
Social values, norms and mores
Norms
Rules and expectations by which a society guides the behavior of its members - keeps in check deviant behaviour
Social Values
Rules shared by most people - it is what people feel should happen
Mores
Morals or good ways of behaving. norms that a culture would think are serious to break eg murder or sexual offences against children
Public perception of crime
Laws often change due to changes in a society's culture - norms and values. eg - drink driving - never used to be seen as a v. bad thing. more accidents and advertisements against drink driving = changes in law
The media
The media often sensationalises and exaggerates things - leads to people thinking certain crimes are worse than they really are. can create moral panics and people ignoring other crimes that may be happening more than the reported ones in the media
Demographics
Change in people's attitudes = a change in the public perception of discrimination and race hate as a crime. taken more seriously, people are more likely to accept that these should be criminal offences
Cultural changes
Demographics
Due to immigration - there was a lot of racism. new laws were made to prevent this eg race relations act 1965
LGBT rights - wolfenden report 1967 - people became more accepting. the report said that sexual activity between men over 21 should be decriminalised
Secularisation
Religion is less important in people's lives than it once was. religions have generally opposed homosexuality - now, people do not let this govern them