20th Century American Postmodernism & Modernism

"The Left Hand of Darkness" Ursula K. Le Guin

Historiography & Context

Agency: of characters and readers

Race

American Culture

Material Culture

Philosophies & Dogmas

The Harlem Renaissance

Anthropology & Sociology

Invisibility & visibility

Autonomy: of characters

Solipsism

Affect

Bildungsroman

Post Secularism

Dualism & Monism

Transcendentalism

click to edit

Form

Irony & Parody

Aestheticism

Epistemology and Ontology: Organization and structure of the text.

Lyricism: In poetry, naming and symbolism

Color Key Grey: Connections between texts and concepts. Green/Blue: Connections between concepts.

"Seize the Day" Saul Bellows

"Invisible Man" Ralph Ellison

"Lolita" Vladimir Nabokov

"The Crying of Lot 49" Thomas Pynchon

"Mumbo Jumbo" Ishmael Reed

Existentialism

click to edit

AMERICAN CULTURE: American Culture is portrayed as a distinct blend of African and Indigenous beliefs with western hierarchies and religion. This is clear in Mother Yoruba being compared to the virgin Mary in ch. 39. Black culture is seen by whites as a contagious disease, whereas practitioners of voodoo view it as a national movement.

ANTHROPOLOGY: Racial history and culture are viewed through an African lense, rather than a white one.

TRANSCENDENTALISM: Loas represent the divine aspects of elemental forces, showing divinity and significance in everything.

MATERIAL CULTURE: The text is filled with advertisements, photos and snippets of news which emphasize the African experience in America.

EPISTEMOLOGY AND ONTOLOGY: The organization of the different POV's provides meaning for the text. The view of history presented by Papa Labas also grounds the text in an Ancient Egyptian past.

THE HARLEM RENAISSANCE: The text takes place during the renaissance and features prominent figures such as Sufi Abdul Hamid, Woodrow Wilson Jefferson (Richard Wright) and others. Reed comments on the problematic elements of the Harlem renaissance here by pointing to the white patrons which many black writers were influenced by at the time. He also highlights the interesting and diverse people who participated in the renaissance through figures like Abdul Hamid

IRONY & PARODY: Western society has demonstrably been influenced by the African magical tradition, yet seeks to destroy it. Conspiracy theories which were previously used in an anti-semitic context are subverted and parodied in order to show black agency in history.

RACE: Black agency in history is the core theme of this novel

click to edit

TRANSCENDENTALISM: The Handdara find meaning in both light and darkness. Everything has a divine property.

BILDUNGSROMAN: The protagonist realizes the meaning inherent in Winter as a place of dualism and monism.

POST SECULARISM: Prominent religions with clear benefits to society are presented, yet Le Guin does not write of a theocracy and neither religion has a real world hierarchy. Yomesh is simply a god head to the Yomeshta. Anyone can be part of the Handdara.

ANTHROPOLOGY: Le Guin criticizes 19th and early 20th century anthropology through the protagonist Genly. It is perhaps impossible to fully understand another culture without being raised within it.

LYRICISM: "Light is the left hand of darkness and darkness the right hand of light. Two are one, life and death, lying together like lovers in kemmer, like hands joined together, like the end and the way" (233). The individual and the collective are emphasized through the lyricism of the text, reflecting the overarching paradox within the text.

RACE: Genly Ai's people and the Hainish empire introduce racial thinking and any kind of evolutionary or racial commentary, reflecting a western imperialist view of the world. The Gethen's themselves simply view Genly as a pervert among them, distinct yet alike to them.

EPISTOMOLOGY & ONTOLOGY: Meaning is found in the text primarily through Genly Ai's organization of the different journal entries (povs) and myths within the novel.

MATERIAL CULTURE: Le Guin's worldbuilding necessitates a building of culture through material items, such as the unique technology, food, and weapons of Gethen.

click to edit

MATERIAL CULTURE: The prominent feature of racist paraphernalia in this novel showcases the racism inherent of American Culture: "A grinning doll of orange-and-black tissue paper with thin flat carboard disks forming its head and feet and which some mysterious mechanism was causing to move up and down in a loose-jointed, shoulder-shaking, infuriatingly sensuous motion, a dance that was completely detached from the black, mask-like face"(431).

RACE: The entire text is a commentary on the ways in which African Americans work through and subvert the preestablished hierarchies of society.

IRONY: The many instances of irony in "Invisible Man" mark moments in which the narrator's awareness grows and in which their identity changes. Paul de Man's metaphor surrounding irony in his commentary on Baudelaire's theory of irony illustrates these moments well: irony can be described as a man tripping, realizing he is tripping in the moment, and laughing at himself as he trips. This is particularly clear in scenes such as the narrator's last encounter with Dr. Bledsoe as well as the Brotherhood's betrayal of the narrator.

AMERICAN CULTURE: This text features a distinct snap shot of New York as a place where African American culture has taken roots, while still remembering its past in slavery. The narrator arrives to other black characters both criticizing and hailing him for his southern identity. It is also a place where a myriad of political thought and action is taking place, as well as violence, in the case of the Brother Hood and Ras the Exhorter.

LYRICISM: Like Bellow's novel, the lyricism present in Ellison's "Invisible Man" attempts to show the relationship between the individual and the collective, playing on the main theme of invisibility and visibility. This is done through Louis Armstrong's lyrics. Of this, Ellison said "The delicate balance struck between strong individual personality and the group during those early jam sessions - was a marvel of social organization" ("Living" 229). By engaging in music, characters are able to connect to a collective consciousness, but can also be appreciated as spires and individual entities within this collective consciousness.

THE HARLEM RENAISSANCE: This text is in some ways a response to the work of Harlem Renaissance writer Richard Wright, specifically the text "Native Son" which, though groundbreaking, situated its main character in a white frame of reality and stereotypes, thus eliminating the act of self determination. Ellison's narrator, speaking in the first person rather than third, wills his existence into being. He does not attempt to raise himself to a white standard of existence.

BILDUNGSROMAN: Through the ironic realizations of the narrators life, from his years in highschool to his time after the riots of New York, Ellison writes a Bildungsroman about a black man's revelation of his invisibility and visibility, and the states of being which exist in between. This novel is, to some degree, a coming of age text which features a large amount of rebirth paradoxes and moments of profound transformation bordering on the religious. The narrators ultimate revelation is that he may use his invisibility for the benefit of others, rather than himself.

SOCIOLOGY: Ellison responds to sociologists of the 19th and early 20th century, such as R.E. Park and E.W. Buress who attempt to identify commonalities in African and other racial identities. "The Ne**o is, by natural disposition, neither an intellectual nor an idealist, like the Jew; nor a brooding introspective, like the East Indian; nor a pioneer and frontiersman, like the Anglo-Saxon (136)." Ellison writes a character which subverts imposed identities in order to counter and criticize this line of thinking.

EXISTENTIALISM: The narrator is constantly attempting to make his own way throughout his life, through his own volition and decisions, which is why each ironic revelation he experiences is one in which he acknowledges the influence others have tried to exert on him. He attempts to exist on his own terms in a chaotic world.

AUTONOMY: The narrator's self determination and distinct will to subvert control are key concepts in the novel. The first person voice of the novel affirms this.

INVISIBILITY & VISIBILITY: The narrator of "Invisible Man" encounters individuals throughout the novel who are able to exist in states of either full, or semi-invisibility. Reinhart and other hipsters are primary examples. Embodying the existentialist element of the novel, fully invisible characters are able to use and subvert existing societal hierarchies to their own ends, or the benefit of others.

click to edit

AESTHETICISM: Some critics have hailed "Lolita" as a work of art, and that it should be appreciated as art, separate from collective ideals of morality. This is one side of the Affect vs. Aesthetics debate among critics.

IRONY: Humbert's characterization as someone with high vocabulary and his effort to convince the reader of his innocence using it, leads to the ultimate irony of the novel: Humbert Humbert cannot help but confirm his guilt through his obsessive descriptions of the objects of his desire.

SOLIPSISM: Due to Humbert's limited point of view, his stream of consciousness is the only which is featured. No other characters, specifically Deloris (Lolita), have a true voice in the novel, aside from McFate who simply furthers the solipsistic overtones.

AMERICAN CULTURE: "Lolita" is in many ways a travel novel, and it showcases Humbert's view of a 1950s United States. Humbert describes tourist traps, consumerism and vanity in pop culture as he drives through America, the irony being that as he despises these things, Deloris exemplifies each of these traits.

AFFECT: Humbert Humbert expresses extreme and problematic affect throughout the narrative in his description of his surroundings, most especially Lolita. His narrative deals with problematic attitudes towards human trafficking, sexual assault, pedophilia etc. This has led many critics to discuss whether its existence is justified, due to the extreme nature of the content and the question of whether this extreme nature is necessary to the message of the text. This gets into the debate of Affect vs. Aesthetics and whether a text exists as a work of art outside societal influence or if there is a limit to what can be considered art.

MATERIAL CULTURE: Magazines, film and new media represent a new youth which is self obsessed and connected to a pop culture which has never existed before.

AUTONOMY: The character Humbert Humbert denies autonomy to the other characters of the story through his solipsistic narrative, which includes no other points of view other than that of the psychiatrist McFate, who in turn denies these same characters. Deloris herself is denied all autonomy.

click to edit

IRONY: Tommy Wilhelm represents a "Suffering Joker" in "Seize the Day", tragic comedy through irony making up much of the subtext of the novel. Bellow uses the irony of Tommy's struggles in order to both introduce a comical element to the narrative as well as facilitate Tommy's spiritual experience. There is irony in his constant diversion of energy towards solving his problems only leading to their worsening. This forces him to succumb to the humbling experience of enlightenment.

BILDUNGSROMAN: "Seize the Day" is a novel about Tommy Wilhelm coming to terms with his life decisions and circumstances, and finding profound spiritual and metaphysical freedom in his acceptance of them. "The flowers and lights fused ecstatically in Wilhelm's blind, wet eyes: the heavy sea-like music came up to his ears. It poured into him where he had hidden himself in the center of a crowd by the great and happy oblivion of tears. he heard it and sank deeper than sorrow, through torn sobs and cries toward the consummation of his heart's ultimate need"(114).

AESTHETICISM: Although Bellow attempted to subvert the excessiveness of high modernism, his authorial voice is still present in "Seize the Day" through his vivid and detailed descriptions of the setting and commentaries on the human soul which are described in a voice distinctly different from Tommy's own voice.

AMERICAN CULTURE: "Seize the Day" gives us a view of New York from Tommy's perspective as a pluralistic community, but one in which there is a fair amount of alienation. Characters mostly seek money, social security and tend to wash their hands of other's problems, though they come from a range of different backgrounds.

LYRICISM: In addition to the aquatic metaphors sprinkled throughout the text which serve to illustrate the complex relationship between the individual and the self, poetry features in much of the novel, such as Tamkin's poem he writes of Tommy which illustrates the potential of the individual. Keats' "Ode to Sorrow" is also featured, in order to illustrate the profound sadness and defeat which Tommy feels for most of the narrative. "Come then, sorrow! I though to leave thee, and deceive thee, But now of all the world I love thee best" (86).

TRANSCENDENTALISM: The aquatic imagery of the novel evokes a sense that Tommy is a single drop in a unified ocean of consciousness, and his moments of revelation in the midst of deep hardship often feature descriptions of him drowning and suffocating. This indicates his absorption into the divine collective of humanity.

click to edit

BILDUNGSROMAN: The protagonist goes through a series of revelations, although their final state of being is ambiguous.

LYRICISM: Names indicate meaning, yet seem designed to tease any effort at meaning making.

INVISIBILITY & VISIBILITY: Society has complex and interconnected hierarchies that can be subverted and crossed.

EPISTOMOLOGY & ONTOLOGY: Meaning making is attempted through organization and provenance of texts and first hand accounts of the shadow Tristero organization.

AMERICAN CULTURE: The American culture showcased in Pynchon's "The Crying of Lot 49" is one which is full of distinct yet connected subcultures. Pynchon uses the symbol of the muted post-horn as a way of showing the connection between subcultures, while describing each one in distinct terms.

MATERIAL CULTURE: Signet rings, broaches, flags, chalk graffiti, and stamps. Each of these has a certain significance to Oedipa Maas as they are embossed with the symbol of the muted post horn. Pynchon shows the interconnectedness of culture through this symbol, while highlighting each of the subcultures who appropriate it through their material possessions.

AFFECT & Aestheticism: Society is both connected and meaningful and disconnected and chaotic. The text exists both as a tool for meaning making and an exercise in chaos.

POSTSECULARISM: Although there are not highly religious characters within the text, each moment in which Oedipa realizes another possibility for the mystery of the muted post horn, clear religious imagery is referenced: “Passerine spread his arms in a gesture that seemed to belong to the priesthood of some remote culture; perhaps to
a descending angel. The auctioneer cleared his throat. Oedipa settled back, to await the crying of lot 49 (183)." There is a new kind of spiritual awareness present in post-modernism, devoid of hierarchy and moral didacticism, which this text evokes. It promotes the religious while also eschewing any kind of theocracy

IRONY & PARODY: As opposed to other texts such as "Invisible Man", the protagonist Oedipa in "The Crying of Lot 49" does not have any distinct revelations about the irony of her search for truth. Instead Oedipa, as well as every subject of the novel, is parodied at every opportunity. Other targets include far right groups, corporations, beatniks etc. Pynchon spares no one in this text.

TRANSCENDENTALISM: Oedipa's entire mission in "The Crying of Lot 49" is to find meaning in everything. Everything within the text is connected through the muted post-horn, yet distinct in its own position within the greater American society.

MONSIM & DUALISM: Each nation distinctly represents the individual and the collective together. Karhide is a nation of distinct hamlets and feudal towns, yet the Handdara religion accentuates a collective experience. Orgoreyn is a nation obsessed with collective experience, yet the primary religion of Yomeshta empathizes the messiah figure Yomesh.

AGENCY: Bellow was critical of both high modernism and naturalism and sought to combine the two by giving his characters an ambiguous yet distinct agency which was termed "comic humanism." "Seize the Day" sheds the excessiveness of modernism, while also lacking any kind of propaganda.

Alienation: of the protagonist

ALIENATION: Bellow engages with ideas of alienation envisioned by the sociologist David Reisman who argues that the individual's goals were first determined by family and clan in pre-industrial societies, then immediate family, then by peer groups and social cliques in the industrial societies of the 20th century. Tommy Wilhelm is a man who does not follow the advice of his father, and he is largely disconnected from his greater family, instead relying on the "reality instructor" Tamkin, whom he regards as a friend. Tommy is thus alienated through his family simply by his refusal to let them determine his goals.

EXISTENTIALISM: The central struggle of the novel is that Tommy must face the consequences of his life decisions. He has had the freedom to choose, but with this comes the need to face the outcome of his failure as an actor, as a father, and as a son.

Ellison and Reed both criticize and highlight aspects of the Harlem renaissance. Both of their texts prominently feature race, and deal with agency in story telling.

All three of these texts represent a character who is parodied or exhibits a degree of unaware irony. They also each feature prominent panoramic views of different parts of America and the consumerist, disconnected and alien aspects of that culture.

Each of these texts criticize a western, white understanding of history and anthropology in different ways. Each offers an alternative or created history in order to show different POV's which previous novels have ignored.

Le Guin imagines a fantastic future in order to convey her ideas whereas Reed imagines a semi-fantastic past in order to convey his. This is not to say the alternative timelines which Reed and Le Guin offer are not rooted in truth.

Ishmael Reed

Ralph Ellison

Vladimir Nabokov

Saul Bellow

Thomas Pynchon

Phillips-Ursula-K-LeGuin

Each of these texts present a narrator who speaks in the first person and does not present an alternative point of view or another voice. Each exerts complete control over what is said.

Pynchon and Le Guin both show a degree of meaning inherent in everything, although they differ in their conclusions regarding that meaning. Both of their texts also feature prominent symbols and symbolic or lyrical names: Genly Ai, Genghis Cohen, The Ekumen, Oedipa Maas. Pynchon seems to be attempting to confuse any attempt at meaning making, Le Guin is quite forthright in her's.

"Lolita" details the account of a man who has raped and groomed his step daughter attempting to defend his actions to a jury. It is written from the first person, and covers his entire life, except the last moments of his death.

"Invisible Man" is about a nameless black man who attempts to make meaning of his life through a series of trial by fire incidents. The narrator is constantly joining organizations, only to reject, or be rejected. In the end, he comes to terms with his existence and uses it for the good of others.

"Mumbo Jumbo" covers an alternative account of the Harlem Rennaisance written from an African American perspective with some magical realism. History is viewed as a continuation of Egyptian culture. Practitioners of Voodoo fight shadow wars against remnants of an ancient rival religion and of catholic knight orders, determined to stamp out black culture.

"The Left Hand of Darkness" Covers the story of an intergalactic diplomat sent to coerce the planet Gethen into joining his trade empire, The Ekumen. The inhabitants of Gethen, or Winter, are ambisexual, and their sexual drive is limited to about a week every month. Le Guin plays with Gender politics in the sci-fi epistemological novel.

In "The Crying of Lot 49" Oedipa Maas attempts to make sense of the elaborate conspiracy which she slowly uncovers: the existence of a vigilante shadow empire surrounding mail couriers. Nothing is as it seems as Pynchon plays with attempts at meaning making and parody.

Tommy Wilhelm comes to grips with the mess his life has become in Saul Bellow's "Seize the Day." Emotionally crippled and depressed, Tommy spends the entire novel trying not to drown in the unfortunate state of affairs he has created for himself. In the end, he shows the struggle of the human spirit, and showcases the connectedness which we all experience.