The Good Life
Materialism
Both
Idealism
Within many of these literary works, the character's path to the Good Life is often controlled by their desires and its outcomes. As a result, their desires may stem from properties of idealism: attributing idealistic standards to objects or goals, where reality stems from their perceptions, or the projection of the mind onto reality.
Sophocles, Antigone
In defiance to the laws of Creon, Antigone embodies a sense of heroic idealism by opposing the laws of the state in favor for higher powers and her personal moral beliefs. Her idealistic morals conflict with Creon's as she sacrifices her life in order to fight for her brother's burial. This demonstration of family loyalty and ideal moral laws show that her inner desires stem from her own projection of idealistic standards. Looking at the division between Antigone and Ismene in the play, her insistence on taking full responsibility for her defiance also connects to the heroic idealism as she fights for her brother's burial while understanding the consequences of these actions.
Often in opposition to idealism, materialism is the metaphysical view of objects on reality rather than the mind. In many of these texts, the characters' drive for their desires is influenced from materialistic views or the objects of their life influence these desires. The concept of objects that project reality allows for the ultimate goal of pleasure and fulfillment of egotistic desires in these literary works.
Ursula Le Guin, The Dispossessed
In the anarchist society of Anarres, their fundamental principles on collectivism and solidarity are present within their inhabitants such as Shevek. His voyage to Urras in order to further his physics theory in instantaneous communication across planets stems from his idealistic view that his work should be used for the greater of good of the universe rather for selfish and individual gain (Urras physicist's goal for prestige and advantage over other planets). Shevek's idealism are implemented into reality as he decides to pursue the journey to Urras. Even with the constraints of a capitalistic society such as Urras and his realizations of the shortcomings between the two worlds, Shevek is able to form his own potentials through the manifestation of his desires into reality as a result of his initial ideas.
Color Key:
- Indigo/Pink/Red: Key concepts connected to main nodes
- Yellow: connections to format of text/film
- Orange: connections to other texts/films through similar themes
Jamaica Kinkaid, A Small Place
Bong Joon Ho, Parasite
As a book about the effects of colonialism and capitalism on a small island, the implications of materialism are present throughout the text. The financial situations of multiple families as they struggle through poverty demonstrate the materialistic desires that these individuals have in order to survive in their environment. In order for their small island to thrive, Kincaid focuses on the conflicts of self-accounting and sovereignty of Antiguans in opposition of the corruption within their government. Therefore, their reality has become a consequence of the decades of colonialism and destruction by foreigners on their land.
Stephanie Black, Life and Debt
As a film adaptation to the book, A Small Place, the effects of materialism are seen once again through the eyes of the tourist. The films emphasis on the destructive tourism on Antigua thematizes the beauty and ugliness of its industry. The materialistic goals of pleasure and money through tourism destroy those of its inhabitants where they are forced to live under a corrupt government or their inability to sustain themselves because of globalization.
Second-person point of view:
- emphasis on reader's perspective takes on an aggressive and direct method to portray the destruction of their island from colonialism
- promotes guilt in the reader through the realities of its inhabitants
Filmed through the perspective of the tourist:
- situating the audience as the tourist on vacation shows how many people disregard the reality of Jamaica (torn-down schools, buildings, financial and government corruption)
Interviews of families:
- personal accounts of natives bring more guilt to the audience (as the tourists)
- more in-depth understandings of their financial situation and the lack of hope for their government
The Kim family's struggle with poverty becomes the motivation for their materialistic desires in pursuing the exploitation of the Park family's wealth. Their reality living in a rundown and semi-underground home reflects a family that is living in a state of desperation to survive in a capitalistic society. Fighting for a more financially stable life, the Kim family projects the material objects within the world of the rich in order to fulfill their idealistic life as part of the upper class. The family's reality derived by the poverty that they struggle under embeds the materialism present throughout their society and within their household.
Descriptions of Tourists:
- highlights the physical and moral ugliness of tourism through the exploitation of poorer poeple for thier materialistic pleasures
- emphasis on beauty through the tourist's eyes shows their ignorance of the ugliness behind their actions
Cinematography:
- the perspective of each family through the film emphasizes the social differences between the Park and Kim family
- shots of the Park residence reveal the ginormous space in which the house sits on and its placement on an upper level of the city
shots of the Lee residence as a semi-basement where the visible spaces are of passerby's feets shows the lower level (lower status) of the Lee family
the difference in money and comfort between the family is emphasized through Bong Joon Ho's cinematography
"Effects of Capitalism"
- As a result of the extreme social and wealth disparities in Korean society, the effects of capitalism forms a line between the rich and the poor (the Parks and the Kims)
- the crossing of the line by the Kims through their manipulation of the Park family is a result of the Kim family's desires to gain material wealth and climb the social ladder in which they are trapped under
Lorraine Hansberry, A Raisin in the Sun
Mohsin Hamid, The Reluctant Fundamentalist
Gustave Flaubert, Madame Bovary
The intertwinement of both idealism and materialism in each of the family member's desires aligns with their reality and views of their world. Looking at the effects of poverty on the Younger family, the existence of materialistic desires is greatest in Walter as the only way out of their financial struggles is through material gain. As an ambitious and driven character, Walter's belief that only materialistic goods will bring about comfort and happiness in his family stems from the physical objects of his upbringing and experiences in poverty. Here, the fulfillment of his desires are only accomplished through the material possessions.
"Did you dream of yachts on Lake Michigan, Brother?"
- Beneatha's ridicule of Walter's greed in taking the money to fund her education and his money to only lose it all at the end demonstrates the capitalist goals of Walter throughout the novel to obtain the inheritance money from Mama
- Walter's constant need to get material wealth ultimately costs him everything because of his poor decisions
In opposition to Walter's materialistic view of life, Beneatha represents how idealism can fulfill and motivate desire. Beneatha's goal to become a doctor in order to help society as a whole demonstrates the social idealism that plays a part in her life decisions. Her drive to help those in Africa and devote her life to the less fortunate opposes those of her brother's desires that come off as selfish and individualistic. Similarly, Mama's desires to improve her family's situation also comes from her familial values. Her idealism is grounded in her beliefs of the power of family and love rather than materialistic gain. In the play, Mama is consistently urging her son to become a better role model for Travis rather than focusing exclusively on material gain.
Changez's experience as an immigrant is stimulated by the opportunities and social status that he can gain by going to the United States. His attendance at Princeton, his job at Underwood Samson, his relationship with Erica, and his attempt to assimilate demonstrates his materialistic desires. The promise of wealth, respect, and prestige fuels Changez's motivation to stay in America during times of heightened racism towards Arab Americans and Asian Americans. Despite these experiences, the objects within Changez's world (i.e. money and a luxurious life) reflects the reality that he has set for himself by attending an Ivy League and admiration for the United States.
As Changez experiences the material comfort of his career and hard work, the aftermath of 9/11 opens the ugly history of the United States as its citizens begin to experience the xenophobic sentiments and racism of the public and government. The presence of idealism within The Reluctant Fundamentalist is evident within the mindset in which Changez views these occurrences. Despite the existence of soft racism that he experiences prior to 9/11, his idealistic views of the United States driven by his exceptional education and occupation allow him to continue loving his new country despite its downfalls. Therefore, his idealized view of the United States is what initially blinds Changez before the surge of racism that accompanies 9/11.
Flaubert constantly critiques the Romanticism within Emma's character, yet demonstrates this through a perspective that coincides with materialism. Throughout Emma's chase for a romantic illusion, her desires are often a result of the material objects in her real world. Her husband, her village, or her wealth contributes to dissatisfaction with life and becomes the reason why she is constantly bored with the present moment. Therefore, materialism can also be analyzed within Emma's life especially towards the end when monetary obsession becomes the consequences of her desires. Her obsession with money and living luxuriously through the decor of her home to the dresses she wears reveals the material goals that drive Emma into depression.
Emma Bovary is a representation of the consequences of Romanticism as her disillusionment of reality leads to her downfall. Her constant dissatisfaction with her life, her husband, or her environment is reflected in her desires to escape into her romantic illusions. These idealistic visions of what her perfect world looks like influences her reality affecting her physically. She is constantly fighting against illnesses that arise from constantly chasing these unrealistic goals. Her longing to have a romantic relationship while married to another man or to move off to Paris despite her financial situation reflects the idealism of Emma's mind. Emma lives through her imagination of the world and through an idealistic lens to find a life that allows her to experience the materialistic and romantic definitions of a good life.
"Even if I die in the act, that death will be a glory"
- usage of death as a glorified act that allows her to actualize her heroic idealism
- death is sacred to the gods which she emphasizes as a higher power throughout the play
Her sense of morality through her words such as her acknowledgment of Zeus shows that Antigone does not see Creon as a king that she can respect. Also, there is the existence of a higher power in which their laws are absolute compared to mortals.
"Moral Right and Civil Disobedience"
- Similar to Shevek, Antigone's moral rights lead her to go against the state power in order to fulfill her own moral responsibilities (family responsibilities vs. social responsibility)
"Family Values"
- her idealistic actions to go against Creon and to bury her brother was an act of family responsibility
"Moral Right and Civil Disobedience" -
- Shevek goes against the PDC and the popular opinion of the Anarresti that was becoming the shortcoming of its anarchist society to pursue his physics theory that would allow the planets to progress in technology and communication
- his belief that his hard work should be shared without the interference of his mentor or other Anarresti leads him to leave his home planet for Urras
"His hands were empty, as they had always
been"
- Shevek's return to Anarres with empty hands demonstrates his realization of the failure of utopias in Urras and Anarres
- despite the reality of the anarchist society, his return symbolizes the rejection of material desire on Urras and the preservation of his moral beliefs in which he started his journey on
"Effects of Capitalism"
- the exploitation of Antigua's people by larger countries results in the financial difficulties of its inhabitants as they fight for their role in the cyclone of globalization
- For a small island, the effects of capitalism on the families that are trying to survive destroy their reliability on the government or other countries to save their economy
"Effects of Capitalism"
- On Urras, the effects of material possession and individualistic values are seen as influences on Shevek's progress even though he continues to pursue his theory once he realizes the reality of Urras as a utopia
"Effects of Capitalism"
- The American dream is chased consistently throughout Changez's experience in America as he desires the wealth, social status, and comfort of material goods
- his success at a highly prestigious school and career at a well-known company asserts his success in obtaining this idealistic American dream
"Effects of Capitalism"
- The years that the Younger family live in poverty fuel each individual member's desire to spend their new inheritance money in a way that will make the family survive
- For Walter, the need to own a business in order to gain money in a capitalist society leads him to become obsessed with money to invest into a liquor store in order to solve their financial problems
"Family Values"
- Despite Walter's insistence on material gain for the family's happiness, Mama's idealistic values that the growth of family responsibility by Walter will help them through their financial situation
Free Indirect Discourse:
- Emma's perspective is still conserved through Flaubert's writing
- focuses on the instances in which she projects her imagination into her reality (i.e. her romantic desires to go to Paris after attending a dance)
- the idealism in Emma's constant chase for unachievable desires are embedded within the way she views the world through the novel's text
Similar to Walter Lee in The Raisin in the Sun, Emma's obsession with money and living a more luxurious life leads to the same consequences that both Walter Lee and Emma suffer from. The loss of money as they struggle with more financial issues causes the isolation and depression that both characters experience at the end.