SEEING VISUAL CULTURE
Aanchal Kasargod

Associations and Prejudices regarding Visibility

Color and Culture

Power and Hardship of Invisibility and the Unseen

Privilege and Power of Being Invisible

Hardships of Invisibility: Being Overlooked and Misrepresented

Vision and Control

In Michel Foucault's "Panopticism", Foucault details a structure implemented to observe prisoners. In this structure, the overseer can see all, but the prisoners cannot see the overseer or whether or not they are being watched. This creates a complete control for the figure with vision, while the prisoner's control is completely relinquished with their vision. (Foucault, "Panopticism").

Emotion in Society

Emotion in Film/Culture

Sepia and Multicolor

Green and Red

Yellow and Blue

White

Black

Paul LaFarge "Colors/Black": In this article, LaFarge describes black as the color of freedom and refusal. He is indicating that black is the color of non-compliance and non complacency, and that this void, this lack of, and this invisibility caused by black is freeing

Sexton also mentions black as a "constitutive social, political, and aesthetic power.” This further highlights the cultural associations and responsibilities placed on the color black (Sexton, "All Black Everything").

In Jared Sexton's "All Black Everything", Sexton associates black with meaning, a different idea than LaFarge and yet, another cultural association with color. He sees black as a paradox, agreeing with LaFarge in the sense that it can be a color of freedom, but seeing negative aspects of this lack and invisibility, this not doing, which he calls "the negative condition of possibility"

In Jared Sexton's article, he quotes Ad Reinhardt, another prominent artist in the conversation of the color black. He says "connotations of black in our culture where our whole system is imposed on us in terms of darkness, lightness, blackness, whiteness. Goodness and badness are associated with black. " -->This furthers the notion that there are many cultural associations with black.

Associations

Prejudices

Uncertainty and Unsettledness

Race

Blindness and Inability

Claudia Rankine speaks on the politics of visibility, and how certain people are invisible or hyper-visible to others based on prejudice.

In the film "Three Colors Blue," the interactions between blue and yellow hold great significance, particularly in the opening car crash scene. In this scene, there are constant exchanges of blue and yellow light, ending with the boy's yellow skateboard cast aside with happy, lighthearted joy and childhood to allow an overwhelming blue to take over. In this film blue represents the loss, pain, and suffering of Julie, and her desire to internalize her daughter as a means of coping with grief. (Kieslowski, "Three Colors Blue").

Multicolor

Sepia

In "The Wizard of Oz", the red-green contrast is stark. The red of Dorothy's slippers and within her character as a whole is deeply desired by the wicked witch, helping red represent a sense of unfettered desire and danger. The witch, completely enveloped in green, is always in constant desire of Dorothy's red. It is important to note the fact that red is a primary color, while green is secondary, showing the red-green contrast as the witch's jealously and desire to become primary, when she is stuck in the secondary. All of this emotion and plot is conveyed merely through the interaction of color in film, depicting how color plays a large role in emotion.

Often, blindness is associated with a loss: loss of control and ability. However, this is not the case. While sight is lost, other senses are heightened, allowing those suffering from blindness to be completely capable. According to John Hull, blindness is "a prerequisite for full development, the heightening of his other senses" (Sacks, The Mind's Eye"

John Hull considers his loss of visual imagery "a dark, paradoxical gift" (Sacks, The Minds Eye"

Georgia Kleege highlights the issues with the "Hypothetical Blind Man", which represents a sighted person's misunderstandings and prejudices about the blind. Kleege claims, the Hypothetical is a "prop for theories of consciousness" (Kleege, Blindness and Visual Culture"

Kleege hopes that the prejudiced view of "blindness as synonym for ignorance, inattention, or prejudice" will end (Kleege, Blindness and Visual Culture").

"Country of the Blind" details a story in which the blind are fully capable and adapted to their society, and a sighted man brings his prejudiced view that sightedness is happiness. This is refuted, as the members of the COB say "that, in order to cure him complete, all that we need to do is a simple and easy surgical operation--namely, to remove these irritant bodies.” Here, the cure is actually blindness. (H.G. Wells, "Country of the Blind").

Lack of Vision and Control

Zoltan Torey spoke with Oliver Sacks about taking back control of his visual imagery, despite blindness. Sacks writes that he "took control of it the moment the bandages were taken off... never allowed involuntary imagery" (Sacks, The Mind's Eye

In the "Country of the Blind", it is the blind who are in control. Nunez, the sighted man, is fully controlled by the COB, so much so that he refers to sight as a word that "means nothing. Less than nothing!" (H.G. Wells, "Country of the Blind").

Exclusivity in White

In one instance, Rankine being called the wrong name was referred to as "our mistake" in the apology note. Rankine reflects "apparently your own invisibility is the real problem causing her confusion" (Rankine, Citizen).

In another instance, Rankine discussses the racist language as a means to render her "hypervisible" and to "exploit all the ways that you are present" (Rankine, Citizen). Once again, constructs of visibility are driven by prejudice

Rankine details her experiences being overlooked. In one instance, her being "unseen to the two men" in a conference room subjected her to racist remarks. (Rankine, "Citizen").

In "The Invisible Man", Ralph Ellison explains how is rendered invisible by his race, so much so that he can live rent free. He writes "without light, I am not only invisible but formless as well" (Ellison, "Invisible Man").

Ellison also details how, although invisible, he is still held responsible. He asks "how can he be responsible and to whom when they refuse to see him?" (Ellison, "Invisible Man").

Power of the Unseen

Trinh Minh-Ha explains how oftentimes, the close association between the visible and invisible is overlooked. One cannot exist without the other. She explains that "an absence is received as a much-anticipated presence" (Minh-Ha, "Image and the Void").

Trinh Minh-Ha also discusses the "empty chair" and the ways in which it represents "a sign of absence or loss." In this case, the emptiness, lack, the unseen is a powerful symbol. (Minh-ha, "Image and the Void").

White as a dichotomy: Light and Shadow

Lawrence Weschler details the "white light of LA", writing "here in LA, the same kind of diffuse light - no shadows" (Weschler, LA glows). Here, this whiteness of light and the lack of interruption of shadows holds cultural significance. While Weschler details his love for LA in association with this whiteness, Joan Didion portrays a sort of chaos associated with LA (Didion, Los Angeles Notebook"). Coupled together, LA's white light provides a cultural dichotomy for the color white: both vibrance and catastrophe

"I feel most colored when thrown against a sharp white background" (Rankine, "Citizen").

Aggressive White

Hans Blumenburg writes that "light is intrusive" (Blumenburg, "Light as a Metaphor for Truth"). Much of light today is described in terms of white light. This intrusiveness can be linked to the color white in general, contributing to the offensive, stark quality of white.

Knowledge and Vision

In Plato's Allegory of the Cave, everyone living in the cave is turned away from the light, getting any knowledge from the shadow. Once a man turns, he is exposed to all the light and the knowledge of the outside world. However, once he returns to the cave, he has no knowledge inside the cave and is blinded by the actual sunlight. This poses the question of knowledge and vision. Although he saw the light and had new vision of the outside world, he didn't really gain knowledge. Plato highlights how vision is not directly linked to knowledge (Plato, "The Allegory of the Cave"

In Christopher Turner and Victor I. Stoichita's interview regarding shadows and Plato's Allegory of the Cave, they say in particular that "the shadow is a historically made up mark of bad/evil" (Turner and Stoichita, "A Short History of the Shadow") With this in mind, it is often thought that vision uninterrupted by shadows is knowledge. However, in the context of the Allegory, Turner and Stoichita question this societal norm and refute this longstanding misconception.

According to Turner and Stoichita, shadows are often described as "a mark of bad/evil" (Turner and Stoichita, "A Short History of the Shadow"). This further highlights shadows as an interruption, perhaps to white.

In Hans Christian Anderson's "The Shadow", the learned man's shadow begins as just that: a shadow. However, over the course of the story, he becomes his own person. Eventually, the learned man is killed and suppressed by his shadow. This narrative furthers the depiction of the shadow as something inhibitory, bad, or evil. This can be applied to discussions of light and its white qualities, and the way that shadows can serve as an interruption to the vibrant quality of white, bringing it to chaos.

In the sepia toned film, "Persona", the black and white qualities of the film contribute to making the movie slightly incomprehensible and open to interpretation. The decision to make this film black and white was very deliberate. It adds to the emotion of the boy's dream, for example, making it more chaotic and difficult to understand, conveying the emotions likely felt in the dream itself. Seeing as the entire movie is about a mix-up, this black and white quality, the intentional choice for a lack of color contribute to this overall plot-line, conveying more emotion than any other color could. In this film, sepia tones are doing the work of color.

KEY:


YELLOW LINES: CROSS SUBJECT CONNECTIONS


GREEN LINES: INTER-SUBJECT, CROSS-CATEGORICAL CONNECTIONS


Unfortunately, the use of dotted lines was a paid feature, so I chose light colors to represent connections. I hope this is okay!!

In David Batchelor's "Whitescapes", he characterizes white as an "accusatory white", calling the fully white house "a strategic emptiness, but it was also accusatory" (Batchelor, "Whitescapes"). Batchelor also claimed that inside the all white space, nothing looked settled. This further highlights this aggressive, uncomfortable quality of white that has been understood and associated with by society

Le Corbussier highlights the exclusivity of white by examining its societal associations as "moral", "clean", and "healthy", with the Law of Ripolin signifying the Law of Whitening. However, this overt association between white and purity creates a kind of exclusion: it excludes any other color from the possibility of representing those "moral" characteristics. One important question in particular posed by this article is "what do we think against a background of white?" (Corbussier, "A Coat of Whitewash: The Law of Ripolin").

White's more traditional associations

In "The Whiteness of a Whale", Herman Melville highlights some of the more traditional societal associations with white. To some, it can be a sacred happiness or justice, while to others it can be a symbol of religion or honor, and on the other hand it can be negatively associated with terror, horror, and a ghastly ellusiveness. (Melville, "The Whiteness of a Whale").

Screen Shot 2021-12-08 at 10.09.46 PM

Screen Shot 2021-12-08 at 10.09.52 PM

Screen Shot 2021-12-08 at 10.09.59 PM

In each of these white paintings and artworks, that narrative of a pristine, unapproachable, uncomfortable, and aggressive white is maintained. This is especially true in "White Paintings" by Robert Rauschenberg (first three) which are intended to have perfectly smooth surfaces unmarred by handling. (Rauschenberg, "White Paintings) & (Klein, "Untitled White Monochrome").

In the film "Blonde Venus", viewers are forced to see white. Whiteness of the hair on Helen Caburay and the sparking whiteness of her costume. Here, white is linked to shine, glow, and celebrity. However, with Caburay's constant imitation, it almost seems as if this overt showing of a shining white is made as a statement to dismantle the idea of "white purity" or "white shine"

In Syreeta McFadden's "Teaching the camera to see my skin", McFadden highlights Kodak's history of drawing out and misrepresenting black bodies on film, and how she combats this through the use of greyscale. (McFadden, "Teaching the camera how to see my skin").

Franz Fanon in "The Fact of Blackness" describes his feelings of being hyper-visible and "caught in a man's gaze." He describes what it means to be alienated on the basis of a visible trait (skin color) and the prejudiced views of differences. (Fanon, "The Fact of Blackness"

Screen Shot 2021-12-08 at 10.59.15 PM

Screen Shot 2021-12-08 at 10.59.30 PM

Screen Shot 2021-12-08 at 10.59.47 PM

Dawoud Bey's "Night Coming Tenderly" images encapsulate a knowledge that comes from darkness. Each of his photographs are darkened heavily, and the camera keeps the light out, rather than inviting it in. (Bey, "Night Coming Tenderly".

In Shawn Michelle Smith's examination if Dawoud Bey's "Night Coming Tenderly", she breaks down the meanings and significance behind Bey's images. She explains how the purpose of these paintings was to "visualize black presence in the American physical and social landscape." She also highlights how Bey's paintings focus on the Underground Railroad and the African American freedom struggle. Smith helps dissect how the darkness in this painting represents knowledge (Smith, "Photography, Darkness, and the Underground Railroad: Dawoud Bey’s Night Coming Tenderly, Black,” American Quarterly Vol 73 (1), 2021, 25-52."

In the film, "Blonde Venus", Helen Caburay's character imitates the imitation that the film industry creates by erasing black bodies from film in which they are there. In the older filming tradition, certain people had to fac the hardship of being rendered invisible.

Screen Shot 2021-12-08 at 11.37.03 PM

In "Mother of George", Adenike's emotional journey is detailed through color -- primarily blue and yellow/orange. There are numerous instances throughout the movie where a cool blue is contrasted with a warm golden orange. In opening scenes, the celebratory wedding is a warm gold, while the advice about conception afterward is a stark blue (almost as a foreshadowing to the troubles to come). Moving through the film, each scene in which the couple is trying to conceive is cast in a blue light, while the celebration of pregnancy is in gold. In this film, blue is acting as a sort of segue to the emotions of alienation and trauma, while gold is more of a celebration. The contrast in the film does the work of creating a sort of emotional unsettledness, much like the emotions in the film.

Maria Popova highlights the close emotional relationship between yellow and blue as she writes: "As yellow is always accompanied with light, so it may be said that blue still brings a principle of darkness with it" (Popova, 19th Century Insight Into the Psychology of Color and Emotion").

David Batchelor's "Chromophobia" quite literally represents a fear of color. In this context, white,the absence of color, takes on a new meaning. Often, white is thought of as "pure" or "virtuous" while color is considered "corruptive" . With this in mind, "Chromophobia" highlights white's removal of differences with things that don't belong represented by color. This belief of white as a kind of purging catalyst for things that seemingly don't belong further highlights white's quality of exclusivity. (Batchelor, "Chromophobia").

In "The Wizard of Oz", color is used deliberately as a symbol of fantasy. According to Stanley Cavell, the film allows "color to create a world... a world of an immediate future" (Cavell, "The World as a Whole: Color"). This helps us see the work that color does in conveying emotion and selling a fantasy in film.

In "The Wizard of Oz", the transition from sepia to color marks a large transition in plot. As Dorothy steps from a postlapsarian world to the prelapsarian fantasy, she movies from sepia to color. (Fleming & Cukor, "The Wizard of Oz").

Stanley Cavell discusses the work that sepia does in "The Wizard of Oz" and in film in general, writing about the "inherent drama of black and white" (Cavell, "The World as a Whole: Color").

Richard Dyer in "White" discusses how white has become invisible and a normal, both on screen and in real life. He explains how, in order to achieve a more successful society, we must make whiteness visible on screen and dismantle it as a power position. In this context, the invisibility of white is a privilege.

The structure of the Panopticon designed by Michel Foucault highlights the way that visibility can be associated with uncertainty and a feeling of discomfort. The prisoners are completely visible to the overseer, and yet completely uncertain whether they are being watched. Their behavior is adjusted by way of this unsettledness. (Foucault, "Panopticism").

The idea of the Panopticon presents the privilege of being invisible. The overseer is invisible to all the prisoners, but this emptiness creates control. The empty space is more powerful than an existence. (Foucault, "Panopticism"

Monty Python's 1971 work "How not to be seen" includes a very interesting statement about the power of being invisible by depicting people violently shot upon being identified. This is a symbol of the vulnerability caused by visibility and the benefits to invisibility. (Monty Python, "How not to be seen").

In this same context, Hito Steyerl's "How not to be seen" movie details lessons on how not to be seen including "making something invisible to a camera," "how to be invisible in plain sight, and "more important things want to remain invisible" (Steyerl, "How not to be seen"). Here, invisibility is made to be a kind of superpower, and something that is so advantageous and desirable that lessons are needed to achieve it.

In the film "All Light Everywhere," uncertainty and unsettledness plays a large role. There is uncertainty of the filmmaker's place in the film, uncertainty among characters regarding body cameras, unsettledness regarding surveillance, etc. In one quote from the movie, an unsettledness in being surveilled is highlighted, but an indifferent, routine unsettledness. The quote reads "These kids don’t care about no cameras. They know they’re being watched. They’re just trying to survive" (Anthony, "All Light Everywhere").

Screen Shot 2021-12-09 at 4.18.19 AM

Vito Acconci, "Following Piece" In this piece, a man follows subjects while they remain in public spaces. In this situation, the man is unseen by the subjects while in complete control of his sight on them. He is the "invisible photographer" with all the privilege of seeing without the burden of being seen. This connects well to the "power of being invisible" node.

Screen Shot 2021-12-09 at 4.18.25 AM

Sophie Calle "Suite Vénitienne" In this piece, the photographer was following a random man she met, Henry B, claiming she does not know why she is following him. In this work, the photographer consistently doubts herself, causing pause to wonder: who is really in control, the photographer or the subject?

Screen Shot 2021-12-09 at 11.12.43 AM

Lorna Simpson in her “Darkening” artwork explores the role of blue, and its interactions with black as she makes statements about power and representation in regards to race, primarily inspiring her work off of Matthew Henson’s North Pole expedition and late acknowledgment/lack representation. To her, blue is a color of suffering, much like in the film "Mother of George". Much like Robin Coste Lewis’s work, Simpson looks to create gaps and contradictions in her work, seeking spaces to find blackness and highlight the various ways power and representation are at play.

wizard-of-oz-1

Yves Klein in "The Evolution of Art Towards the Immaterial" describes white as "absolute" and "a white beyond all whiteness" while noting color as "tainted, humiliated, and conquered" and "trapped in the lines." Here, once again that exclusive quality is highlighted in the color white. He describes the color blue as profound and beyond dimensions, highlighting its differences from other colors that are merely psychological expanses. Klein claims blue represents the intangible and the abstract.

click to edit

Carol Mavor's analysis of "Three Colors Blue" specifically examines Julie's consumption of the blue lollipop, and what this blue means to her. She writes "Julie's eating of the lollipop is an eating of Anna in order to bury he rwithin herself" (Mavor, "Blue Mythologies: Reflections on a Color"). This helps understand the emotional work that blue is doing in this film.

Three-Colours-Blue-007

Derek Jarman's film "Blue" and his accompanying text "Into the Blue" details blue's role in Jarman's experience living with AIDS. In the film, the only visual is the color blue. Coupled with Jarman's explanations of his associations with Blue, calling it a "fathomless blue of bliss" and "darkness made visible", Jarman shows the emotion behind blue for him in his film, a color he could still see after battling AIDS. (Jarman, "Blue" & "Into the Blue").

Robin Coste Lewis depicts a personal connection with blue. After a life-threatening fall, blue became her transition out of the darkness, much like it is as a color. She discusses the gaps in paintings, detailing how she tried not to fall through, much like Matthew Henson in the Arctic. She also learned to recover in a blue pool, able to fully experience her pain without repercussions (much like in "Three Colors Blue"). (Lewis, "Using Black to Paint Light: Walking Through a Matisse Exhibit Thinking about the Arctic and Matthew Henson")


Seph Rodney brings up an interesting and profound point in his discussion of Lorna Simpson's work. He notices the faces of women in the paintings and highlights how the paintings show the relationship between images of a Black woman’s body and language as it pulls her body into politics, saga, elegy, and poetry. He notices the words and newspaper clippings in the paintings as well. This analysis helps understand a potential association with blue in culture and film. (Rodney, " Lorna Simpson Searches for Meaning in the Arctic Ice").

mother_of_george_still_02

In Georgia Kleege's "Molyneaux Redux", she discusses the problem posed by William Molyneaux to John Lock which asked "What if a man who was born blind but had learned to recognize through touch certain geometrical forms such as a sphere and a cube, were to have his sight restored by an operation, would he then be able to recognize these forms through sight alone?" This question itself brings us to the subject of blindness and ability, as well as of knowledge and vision. While it does address the literal spacial ability of someone who is blind, is also provides deeper thought into whether sight ensures clarity and correct knowledge.

le vide

Like "the empty chair", Yves Klein's "Le Vide" capitalizes on the power of the unseen, making the empty gallery space the exhibit itself.

Like in "Blonde Venus", Hilaria Loyo's "Blinding Blondes" explores the culturally accepted ideal of blondeness and whiteness signifying stardom and brilliance. This work too calls into question the idea that white is normal, and also highlights this exclusivity exuding from the color white. For example, she writes that her article will "interrogate his view of whiteness as an unmarked category assuming the standard of 'normal'." (Loyo, "Blinding Blondes: Whiteness, Femininity, and Stardom").

Screen Shot 2021-12-09 at 12.16.59 PM

Carrie Mae Weems's "Colored People, Slow Fade to Black" is a depiction of African American adolescents in a filter of vibrant color. Weems's purpose was to both show variations on black skin tones and also to push the social and political bounds of color and expand its horizons. (Weems, "Colored People, Slow Fade to Black"

Screen Shot 2021-12-08 at 11.37.09 PM

Screen Shot 2021-12-08 at 11.37.16 PM

Screen Shot 2021-12-09 at 12.27.11 AM

General Notes on Color in Film

Lorraine Daston and Peter Galison go into depth about the subjectivity of color in their work "The Color of Subjectivity". However, one point in particular stands out: color is individualized, and sensations are incomparable. This means that multiple people can see the same color, but in different ways. This is an extremely important point when associating color with emotion, because similar colors can mean different emotions for different people. (Daston & Galison, "The Color of Subjectivity").

According to Walter Benjamin, Color through the eyes of a child takes on a kind of clarity and spirituality. For a child, a rainbow does not become a blur, but rather different nuances of color. A child's pure expression is in color. With this in mind, color's subjectiveness is highlighted. Color is something entirely different to children than it is to adults. After all "“Children are not ashamed because they do not reflect but only see” (Benjamin, "A Child's View of Color").

James Turrell also contributes to the conversation of subjectivity of color in his discussions about light. He specifically notes the sky, and how each person's perception of its color can change based on their environment. (Turrell, "You Who Look").

Joseph Albers work focused on highlighting the interaction and interdependence of color, and how each person's perception of it is different. He was greatly inspired by Goethe’s Farbenkreis and his color wheel which depicted different colors as different culturally accepted ideas, such as red signifying beauty, yellow goodness, and blue as common. (Albers,"Interaction of Color"

Maria Popova in "19th-Century Insight Into the Psychology of Color and Emotion" goes in depth about traditional associations between color and emotion. She discusses yellow as "agreeable and gladdening, and in its utmost power is serene and noble, it is, on the other hand, extremely liable to contamination" while a red-yellow is "warmth and gladness" She highlights blue and its relation to black as " cold, and thus, again, reminds us of shade. We have before spoken of its affinity with black" (Popova, "19th Century Insight Into the Psychology of Color and Emotion"). These associations with color and culture and different emotions provide context into the use of color we see in media and on screen.