The Philosophical Roots of Education (Chapter 6)

Axiology

Metaphysics

Epistemology

Important to education bc the disciplines, experiences and skills in the curriculum reflect what our society believes is real

Metaphysicians believe that when we think carefully, we divide the world into meaningful categories

Teacher may have assumptions of students from the backgrounds they grow up in etc. Teacher must know these, so they don’t let it influence their expectations of students and let them create self fulfilling prophecies

Asks questions about abstract concepts

The branch of philosophy that seeks to understand what is real. How we categorize knowledge

Language categorizes the world in ways that suit our needs, and in doing so we shape reality

Tradition says knowledge is justified true belief. Some philosophers don’t believe this, and believe more that knowledge is simply what people believe, disregarding concerns over justification and truth

Epistemologists are divided on how both justification and truth are to be discerned -this has implication for what should be included in curriculum

The branch of philosophy that addresses what knowledge is and how we acquire it

If knowledge viewed as justified true beliefs accumulated by society, school then transmit that accumulated knowledge through lectures and demonstrations so students may acquire it

If knowledge is viewed as what people believe and understand, then educators help learners engage in exercises that will help them clarify beliefs and construct understanding

Older ethical Theories

These ethical theories may influence teachers' philosophies

Modern Ethical Theories

Aesthetically conscious teacher helps students appreciate beauty in various aspects of the curriculum and everyday life (like poetry, fine arts, and natural world)


Branch of philosophy concerned with aesthetics (also about way of looking at the world) and ethics (principles and norms that govern human conduct); that is, how we define what is beautiful and what is morally good and valuable.

Consequentialism

Deonotology

Seeks the most useful consequence, the greatest good for the greatest amount of people

Happiness is greatest good, so therefore we should do what will produce as much happiness s possible

Think lying morally wrong bc it general has bad outcomes

Also called utilitarianism, consequentialist

Ethical theory that claims humans have an obligation to do what duty requires, regardless of the consequences

Virtue Ethics

Suggests that ethical behaviour originates from the character of individuals rather than consequences or any rule

More interested in what the lying or truth telling says about the individual

Aristotle and Plato

Claims students may be made into having good behaviour and in process develop a moral character

Critics say more about compliance then behaviour when teaching in this way

Essentialism

Perennialism

Conservatism

Existentialism

Realism

Idealism

Idealists believe students need to be freed from such relativistic beliefs and discover enduring truths

Says classic literature, art, and music are sources of universal truths/ knowledge and should form core of curriculum

From Plato, who believed that there is an ideal world of perfect ideas; that is, ideas that express truths that are universal

Truths brought to awareness through teaching strategies that uses questions to stimulate the learner’s ability to reason

Teachers don’t give knowledge to students instead they help to draw out or birth knowledge while fostering students’ ability to reason

Teachers want to foster students’ abilities to reason and think critically

Mathematics also high in priority for idealists

In elementary curriculum important that kids learn basic literacy and numeracy to prepare them for later studies

Realist school transmit bodies of knowledge and scientific inquire skills to students

Also believe that information needs to come from experts so teacher must study with subject area experts to master the concepts and teacher must not be distracted by social issues

Until children an behave rationally, teachers must require obedience to foster moral habits and develop character

• Elementary curriculum should provide basic skills in reading, writing, math, basic research skills necessary for later advanced subject matter study in high school

Key principle of realist ethical education is virtue ethics: to foster habituation in the virtues for young children until they are able to use reason to help them act virtuously

Realists believe education helps learners develop abstract concepts this happens at a young age

Traced to Aristotle, who believed that reality could be perceived with one’s senses, and one could abstract concepts from those experiences

Pragmatism

Ignores metaphysical questions about reality, these questions are regarded as a distraction from human beings’ responsibility to make choice about real life issues
Emphasizes personal responsibility for one’s choices and living an authentic life

Existentialist educators sometimes critique schools for mirroring the efficiency values of the industrial revolution

Teachers must be careful the students’ individuality is not sacrificed to the group

Existentialists rely on the learners to determine what is meaningful to them as individuals

Prizes art and humanities bc these subjects invite personal learning meaning making
Science is a necessary body of knowledge that can inform students about their context, but it does not help them make themselves

Opposed to standardized tests that set specific skills and content necessary bc these tests put more emphasis on the things being tested at expense of fine arts and other opportunities that are more likely to foster students’ creative expression

For existentialists education should be an important part of one’s journey, helping students determine who they are

American philosophy, most influential to education in the US and Canada

Gain understanding through experience

Believes that knowledge is constructed by individuals and groups to solve problems they encounter.

Pragmatists believe that reality is what is observed or experienced and truth is what works

Share with existentialism a rejection of truth as traditionally understood

Curriculum is open ended, growing from students needs and interests.

•Pragmatist classrooms

Skill instruction integrated with a practical task

Things are not taught in isolation

click to edit

• Teacher with pragmatism orientation

They feel like knowledge is constructed by individuals and groups solve problems they encounter

Oppose idealist and realist view that there exists a body of knowledge to be transmitted to students

o Rely on scientific method and us it in other subjects then just science

Philosophies of Education

Education that goes back to the source

Draws from idealism (believe in knowledge is acquired by using reason to understand the archetypal forms and realism (believes one abstract concepts from observing the empirical world.

Believes great truths are universal and unchanging, so education transmit these truths, often through classic text

For Perennializes education should:

Foster rational powers and transmit these truths

Fine arts teach us about great human ideals

Bc human nature is unchanging education should be the same for everyone, should not differ according to history, intellectual capacity, socioeconomical background, or culture of the learners bc such variations may be undemocratic

Perennialist teachers should have strong morals with high disciplinary expectations of students

evident in today’s secondary English classes bc students will read the great classics in literature

See education as a way to replicate the culture and produce thoughtful citizens to sustain it

Education that goes back to the basics

Emphasizes basic skills and subjects, mastery of the content checked by standards, and preparing students to be productive citizens through classrooms that are orderly, disciplined, and efficient

about transmission of basic knowledge

teachers must be deliberate and efficient

Teacher should use tried and true methods and not true anything new, like note taking, worksheets, also teachers should enforce rules and have consequences

Teacher led classroom, low value on student voice

More support of standardized tests bc demonstrating one’s mastery of essential skills is a critical component of essentialist education

This idea is seen in TLC (traditional learning centers) programs within Calgary Board of Education

Conservative ideology associated with Christian fundamentalists in Canada and more so in the US

Conservatives that align with perennialists argue that schools should transmit the cultural heritage of western civilization

Endorses strict disciplinary standards like essentialism

Conservatives that align with essentialists emphasize developing skills that are critical to the economical growth of a nation. are okay with students repeating grades

Resists rapid change in education. It endorses basic skills instruction, rigorous academic standards, and strict disciplinary standards to transmit cultural heritage

Subset of essentialism that is having significant impact on education

More of a political ideology than an education philosophy

Social Reconstructionism

Progressivism

leaning should be active, collaborative, and build reflective skills

formative assessment and scaffolding to support learners are critical to building reflective capacity

should arise form children’s interests and not the teachers’ goals

students in these classrooms make choice about content and presentation of ideas, but also collaborate with others who have similar interests

wants to promote the development of the whole child-physically, cognitively, socially, and emotionally

Inquiry based learning is a current iteration of progressivism practised in many Canadian schools

child centered philosophy emphasising problem solving while capitalizing on students’ curiosity and creative self expression

Modern progressives argue mastering traditional subjects’ matter may well be less critical than developing the skills of program solving and the ability to collect and analyze info

People are worried that this ideal might undermined students’ abilities to think independently

Philosophy that has greater value in helping teachers think critically about educational issues than in actually guiding they decision making

Holds concept of truth lightly

This idea is good to help include and incorporate more indigenous knowledge and ways into our Canadian education system

When society experiences a cultural shift that promotes social change, education helps society to rebalance by integrating the new ideas with the old ideas

click to edit

Philosophy of education that maintains that teachers and schools ought to be change agents in creating a new and more equitable social order

Major Philosophical Systems

Branches of Philosophy