Externalities, Merit and Demerit Goods

Externality
The cost or benefit a third party receives from an economic transaction

Negative Externalities

  • Caused by de-merit goods that are overprovided in a free market. There is a lack of consumer information about the long-term effects. E.g, smoking has the externality of lung disease

Positive Externalities

  • Caused by merit goods that are under provided in a free market. This is because consumers lack the knowledge of the benefits of consuming the good.

Costs and Benefits

Private Cost - MPC
The private costs of production, for example, costs of raw materials
External Costs -
The costs on a third party, e.g pollution from production
Social Costs - MSC
Private costs + Social Costs

Private Benefit - MPB
The private benefits from consumption of a good
External Benefit -
The benefit on a third party, e.g healthier lives from vaccine programs
Social Benefit - MSB
Private Benefit + External Benefit

Social Optimum - MSB=MSC

Government Intervention -

Maximum Prices (below equilibrium)

  • Limits the price of merit goods
  • Risk of black market

Buffer Stocks

  • The government buys excess supply to maintain price when excess is produced and sells it when not enough is produced

Minimum Prices (above equilibrium)

  • Increases Wages
  • Make de-merit goods more expensive to reduce consumption

Externality Diagrams

Negative Production Externality
NPE
Blue = Over Production

Positive Production Externality
PPE
Yellow = Under Production

Negative Consumption Externality
PCE
Purple = Over Consumption

Positive Consumption Externality
PCE
Purple = Under Consumption

Nudges

  • The government tries to influence demand directly, e.g cigarettes behind closed covers

Tax

  • Used to discourage de-merit goods using price mechanism
  • If demand is inelastic such as addiction, no change in demand

Subsidy

  • Using price mechanism to encourage the production of merit goods
  • Risk of opportunity cost to government