Please enable JavaScript.
Coggle requires JavaScript to display documents.
Chapter 5 A tale of Two Schools: Indiana Institution and Evansville Day…
Chapter 5
A tale of Two Schools: Indiana Institution and Evansville Day School
And the Darkness Fell
March 6, 1879
democrat controlled state legislature
bill created new board of trustees at Indiana Institution
Morton
powerful influence
Reublican
died in 1877
economic difficulties began affect economy
William Glenn
new superintendent of Indiana Institution
member of democratic patry and no experience with either educational administration or need of deaf students
1857
institutions shortened academic year due to state financial difficulties.
closure affected enrollment
1886-1887
alumni reunion place at indiana institution
lef organization known as Indiana Association of the Deaf.
resolution called for state have one state institution for deaf students
resolution too little and too late.
MacIntire
taught in Ohio Institution, supreintendent of Tenesse.
Indiana Instituion hire MacIntire in 1852
close friend of Oliver Morton
vulnerable to shift political
The Evansville Day School
before civil war
instruction of deaf student exclusive in residential school
government fund help build dorms and expenses of facilities
mark shift toward day schools after civil war.
Charles Kerney
member of Class 1979 at Indiana Institution, founder
more trouble for Indiana Institution, alumni founded
40 years existence of Indiana Institution, all deaf go here.
born Kentucky in 1857
unexplained hearing loss at early age
did not know own name until age 15 when enter Kentucky Institution
lost both parents before grad from Indiana Institution (1879)
graduate from Gallaudet College
work as file clerk in Dept of Commerce in Washington
late 1800s, school established
fit larger national trend in US
sign langauge
state school primary communication tool
oral method - stress speech training and speech reading
used for children not completely lost hearing from England , Germany
Oral instructions
require small class and parent involvement in speech training.
state institutions distant from majority of parents, deprive parents opp to receive training in oral methods use in home
Sept. 2, 1886
alumni reunion, new day school for deaf students
announced in Evansville public schools
first time another deaf school existed in indiana
State of Maine
spread of day schools
before 1876, all deaf children sent to ASD but they not offer speech training classes.
women setup class in Portland Maine to teach deaf children speak , began Portland Day School (oralist)
Day Schools
not all were oral
several start by deaf people
1875, Philip Emery propose Chicago School Board
graduate of Indiana Institution
establish classes for deaf students in Chicago neighborhoods, obtain state funding by 1879
William French
alumnus of Indiana Institution
founded Eastern Iowa day school in Dubuque (1888)
Robert MacGregor
founder of Cincinnati day school (1892)
first president of NAD
Evansville day school
2 major motivations
politically appointed superintendents
overcrowding of Indian Institution
Evansville
Charles Kerney
used opp to speech, convert day school to state institution.
challenge Indiana Institutions monopoly of state fund education for deaf children
4 factors attempt to receive government support
state institutions proliferated across indiand after 1865.
indiana institution in Indianapolis crowded
private day school convert to state institutions or start recieve state support
unmet needs of all states deaf children ages 5-20, 1/3 were enrolled
arrival of EDS
effect on Indiana Institution
Orson Archibald
deaf and instructor, prepared bill, 3 weeks, unsucessful
Evansville Day School
open 1886 with 28 pupils
Dec 30, 1886, exhibition of skit and recitations to 1,200 in Evans Hall
legislative session of 1887
chaotic, unproductive
Lieutenant Govenor Robert S Robertson
general election of 1886, Democratic controlled Senatte repudiated him
two house operated mutual, refuse cooperate.
little business transacted and few laws enacted.
connections with deaf ed
support Kerney efforts
Nov 26, 1887
newspaper important to deaf community
Indiana institution force publish own weekly on controversies
plagiarism
spoiled food
1880s
now courthouse
local group Men's Association 5-story for meeting and office
Evans Hall - city founder General Evan hold 2,000 people
3 deaf grandchildren, wealthy, extensive property in city.
end of 1891-1892
Evansville school board dismissed Kerney from his position
enrollment remained constant since 1886
beginning rapid growth, space for 60 children
growth didnt materialize years.
second largest city in 1880s
transportation hub on Ohio River with railroad connections
forest provide lumber for manufactures
farm ship grain to mills
tobacco from Kentucky to process into cigars
large German population of southern Indiana and Illinois business for breweries.
The Struggle Continues
Late 1890
weakness of EDS was obivious
9 pupil enrolled, 4 residents city, 5 country.
before 1897-1898 school year start. approve measure convert basement to classroom
after Lange resignation, schoolboard closed facility
Lange
not please with Gillet's visit
Gillet report he was pleasant.
complained Gilet wanted him to introduce articulation and speech training.
continues Kerneys attempt to convert EDS in state institution.
resigned in Sept 1901
Silent Hoosier
attendance problems in EDS
Philip Gillet former superintendent of Illinois Institution of the Deaf, now president of oralist rganization "American Association to promote teaching of speech to the deaf
duty travel among schools to observe speech training.
Enrollments
dropped from 22 in 1891 to 8 in 1892.
Kerney requested Deaf Mute School of this city be closed and pupils be sent to State Institution
9 pupils, 3 present when Gillet present
Dec 12, 1896
school board passed resolution in favor of state leg
1897 pamphlet deaf children found to have 1 or 2 years of schooling from Indianapolis school
2 years were inadequate
Aug. 8, 1892
hired Paul Lange, young deaf man $70 / mth
June 1892
school board offer Kerney $100 / mth
removal caused public outcry
school had no teacher
A New School
deaf school campus open 1911
significant departure from old institution Kerney criticized
located on 80 acre propert in indianapolis
each building had 2 floors, large windows, fresh air, dorm and dining room separated from main building.
any deaf child can attend Indianapolis school
name change Indiana State School for the Deaf.
"State" emphasize deaf school was for whole state. no longer regarded as asylum or institution.
deaf institution
physical facilities and location inadequate
suffer overcrowd
complaints of obsolete bathing facilities, inadequate heating and insufficient lavatories.
health and safety issues, required new campus
time
expansion of state educational services
economy booming
US Corp built new town Gary, large steel mills
Natural Gas discovered
new towns created
coal mines doubled from 3-6 million tons from 1890-1900 increased by 18 million tons by 1910
farms, property doubled in 10 years 1900-1910
Long Term Consequences
persoanlities
shifted, more bureaucratic and less interested in educational challenge and social improvement
Thoma MacIntire
superintendent from 1852-1879
advocate educational innovations,
ordained Presbyterian minister but welcome Catholic Masses
Civil service
reform of 1890s, better employees
superintendents continued political appointees
annual reports
during 1890s change in institutioanl personalities
budget issues and defensive positions
educational innovations
poverty and wealth
school never exploited opportunity to enhance well being
lost solicit funds for library
1886
annual report of Indiana Institution mentioned 3,350 volumes worth $4,909.98
previous slow growth of school library.
political
partisan play increase role in school governance in 19th century
Richard O Johnson, attorny, board of trustees, knew some sign
deaf educators
major role in establish early day schools
widely accepted hearing oralists active
use sign language
state residential institution observe school move through entire spectrum of deaf ed
Indiana Institution
old transform to Indiana State School for the Deaf
Charles Kerney deaf, no more EDS
Forgotten
Introduction
Indiana Institution and Evansville day school start when MacIntire removed in 1879
2 schools demonstrate influence of politics and personal rivalries in deaf education
controversies over oralism, manualism, and residential institutions and day schools were at peak
1844 Legislation
create Indiana Institution gave governor full authority to appoint school board of trustees.
elected first superintendent James S Brown (hearing) and former teacher in Ohio Institution for the Deaf.
resign in 1852 to establish institution for deaf students in Louisiana.
his successor Thomas MacIntire, served 27 years.
William Willard
deaf man
founded private school ; Indiana Institution for the Ed of the deaf and Dumb (1843)
next year, state took over, ensure school future but also problem caused
1880s
Evansville day school challenge Indiana Institution of deaf education.
Indianapolis school powerful and politically well connected. not always been
1850, state legislature appropriated funds to acquire 70 acres of land east of Indianapolis to build campus.
Evansville, Indiana
public school system, relate to state-operated residential school in Indianapolis.