Ethnicity & Differencial Attainment
Internal factors
External factors
Cultural deprivation: lack of correct norms and value for educational success
Material deprivation
Racism in society
Subcultures
Ethnocentric curriculum
Labelling
Employment & incom - Flaherty
ONS & Swann Report Data
Attitudes & values - Arnot, Lipton & Chua
Family structure - Moynihan & Murray
Discrimination - Mason :
‘Discrimination is a continuing and persistent feature of the expirience of British cistizens of minority ethnic origin’ - which can lead to social exclusion and worsen poverty experienced
Evans v Patel - Noon
Coping strategies - Mirza
Radicalised expectations - Gilborn, Youdell & Sewell
Subcultures and expectations- Sewell
Prioritised culture - Troyna & Williams
Ethnocentric views - Wright
Material deprivation : poverty and lack of economic necessities need for educational success.
Functionalist - material deprivation causes educational failure due to :
• substandard housing
• poor diets
• low income
More likely amounts ethnic minorities
Ethnic minority groups are more likely to underperform within the education system due to :
• Pakistani / Bangladeshi people - over 3x more likely then white peopel to be in the poorest fith of the population
• Unempliment is 3x higher for African / Bangladeshi / Pakistani people than white people
• 15% of ethnic minorities live in overcrowded households compared to 2% of white
• Pakistani people are 2x more likely to be unskilled or semi-skilled compared to whites
• Ethnic minorities are more like to be engaged in shift work
The ONS (2018) :
• Every ethnic group eligible for free school meals are less likely to pass maths and English GCSE
• Due to ethnic minority groups being more likely to be on FMS ( free school meals )they are more likely to underachieve.
Indian and white peopl usually have higher social class position than Bangladeshi and Pakistani people who often face higher poverty levels.
EVALUATION
- Chinese students still perform highly despite being working class suggesting that influence of parenting is more important than material wealth.
Genders within ethnic groups also influences performance
...example black girls have higher educational achievement then black boys
1.GILBORN & MIRZA - class doesn’t override the influence of ethnicity
...example middle class black children still do poorly at GCSE
Failure of many black children - lack of motivation / not socialised into maintstream culture :
•ambition
•competitiveness
•willingness to make sacrifices for long term goals
-> leads to subculture : ‘live for today’ - prevent desire and effort for succes
ARNOT(2004) : media encourages subcultures
...example ultra tough ghetto superstar reinforced throigh rap lyrics
LUPTON (2004) : Adult authority which is similar to how school operate has a knock on effect on a child behaviours in school and their friends achieving higher grades
...example Asian families
CHUA (2011) : Chinese parents = tiger parents - demand high attainment and don’t accept failure. Asian parents have positive attitudes towards education and are therefore more supportive
Failure to adequately socialise is due to dysfunctional family structure :
ONS - single parent households
•48% of black Caribbean
•36% of black African
•22% of white
•15% of Chinese
•10% of Indians
MOYNIHAN - many black families headed by a single mother :
•boys lack a role model
•struggle financially ( lack of meal breadwinner )
Cultural deprivation is a visions cycle where inadequately social ex children fault and school and become inadequate parents
EVALUATION
- DRIVER - Black Caribbean families are functional and do provide positive role models of strong independent women which is why black girls are more successful in the education system
- EVANS - white working class families underperform due to lack of family support - more single parent families would lead to more underachievement
EVALUTION
- Criticism of Lipton’s study - Pakistani families encourage parental respect which has not heightened this ethnic groups position in achievement tables due to still underperforming relative to other ethnic groups
- KEDDIE - cultural deprivation is a victim-blaming explanation. Ethnic minorities are culturally differnt not deprived and underachieve because schools are ethnocentric ( favour white people ). Solution is to provide multicultural education
•Asians are 50 times more likely to suffer from a racist attack them white people
•minorities are more likely to be given substandard accommodation then white people causing resentment to society’s responsible for this
NOON (1993) : sent matched letters of enquiry to the top 100 Uk companies signed by ‘Evans’ and ‘Patel’ in Which the ‘white’ candidate revived a more positive response
• 1/16 ethnic minority application were offended an interview
•1/9 white applications were offered an interview
This might leav ethnic minorities demotivated to achieve highly within the education system if they won’t have the same opportunities when they do
EVALUTION
- Equality opportunity policies in work and social life has been passed aswel as in the education system
- Victims are racism actively change this and work harder to break through society’s barriers