Please enable JavaScript.

Coggle requires JavaScript to display documents.

Compare the ways in which your two chosen texts present human weakness. …

- - - - vs Victor, who, despite having a loving family deprives the monster of one, triggering his violence, and still sees self as superlative - You may easily perceive, Captain Walton, that I have suffered great and unparalleled misfortunes
        
        That something not even human, alive for just a few days can experience the depth of empathy and attachment that the monster can for the cottagers - "What did their tears imply? Did they really express pain?", question marks showing desire to understand and empathise vs victor's
        "I had selected his features as beautiful. Beautiful! Great God!" declarative exclcamatorys, illustrating his inability and lack of desire to understand the creature, and judges him on his looks.
        He might have spoken, but I did not hear; one hand was stretched out, seemingly to detain me, but I escaped and rushed downstairs. - action for connection misinterpreted as fear
      - "I am poor and an exile, but it will afford me true pleasure to be in any way serviceable to a human creature." - Those considered less than human (???) themselves are able to emphasise
        
        Context: tabula rasa and wether human nature is learned or intrinsic// interesting that something not even human is able to do what human's cannot, revealing flaw
    - - dehumanising treatment of the handmaids: Atwood's use of real world examples, specifically nazi germany - removal of names in favor of a designated signifier, forced into easily identifyable clothing, state sanctioned rape . Dehumanising
      - And yet are continually expected to be selfless and put the needs of the regime above their own
        
        "try to put yourself in their place", and show empathy for the wives, who are hostile to them // re: the violence of attacks with knitting kneedles, and "they can only strike us with their hands" or whatever
        
        Offred is able to sympathise with the commander despite his own hand in her misfortune "if must be just fine, it must be hell, it must be very silent", and pitying presentation of "like you mean it", as "that is a reconstruction too" she chooses to present it in this way
        
        However, the commander is unable to emphathise with the handmaid's plight, or even of women - "There was nothing for them any more" - vs "so they feel now? ...yes they do"(ambuguity if they is refering to everyone or to him), Better never means better for everyone, only for him and thats all that matters
        
        His actions that could compromise her "you could get me transferred. to the colonies, you know that" // complete lack of understanding of her situation "butter... thats very clever"
  - - - description increases in violence, comment and counterpoint on the idea that society is civilising
        
        ROusseau: His early work argued that the development of civilisation had actually led to a decrease in happiness, and that humans should live instead in a state that was as close to nature as possible.
        -the monster who is so connected with nature that it bring him calm "gentle light stole over the heavens and gave me a sensation of pleasure.", he is corrupted by exposure to human society
    - - "Ordinary, said Aunt Lydia, is what you are used to. This may not seem ordinary to you now, but after a time it will. It will become ordinary." the inevitability of adapting to society// feeling that she is empty in accordance with the teachings of gilead "I am not a ship without a cargo, a chalice without wine an oven ... minus the bun"
      - Post Modern ambiguity "This is the heartland, and I'm leading a truely pampered life, may the lord make us truely greatful, said aunt lydia"