CHAPTER 19: THE GROWTH OF TRADE UNIONS AND THE LABOUR PARTY TO 1914
New Unionism for unskilled workers (1870s-1880s)
Early trade Union
‘New Model’ Unions for skilled workers (1850s-1860s)
The causes of the rise of the Labour party and the main stages of development until 1914
for centuries until 18th century and Indus Revo: local trade associations of labourers and workmen => skilled tradesmen combined together to protect their interest BUT considered as dangerous (fear of revolution, cf France: Rubinstein)
Consequences
After 1825 => trade depression => strikes vs drop in the wages BUT employers broke them by bringing workers from nearby areas (blacklegs = briseurs de grève) => the idea of a combination of local trade unions rose BUT failed bc of cash shortages and ø coordination of activities
Combination Act of 1800 => illegal for workers to combine to gain new rights.
Amending Act (1825) => trade unions = legal BUT illegal to obstruct or intimidate => almost impossible to hold a strike without breaking the law.
Robert Owen (1771-1858)
Tried to achieve this goal of combination => most remarkable industrialist and reformer of the 19th century (modest background, self-made industrialist)
A New View of Society in 1813
He proved that it was possible to continue to both make reasonable profit AND improve the conditions of living of the poor
Ricardo’s theory => value was only due to work => capitalist should not capture the profit => tried to set up a Co-operative movement in which the workers owned the means of production
People’s character depended on how good their living standards were => better coditions = peaceful society (tried this in his mills) (larger factories with more aeration, less working hours, local school, parks).
Unpopular with employers ( refused to take on workers belonging to Unions)/very popular with unionists
Founded the Grand National Consolidated Trades Union (GNCTU) in 1833
Every existing trade union was invited to join it => wished to create a collaboration btw traders, manufacturers and the gov
HWV, many issues
=> The Union collapsed in 1834.
Most important unions (builders) refused to join (afraid of losing their separate identities)
Problems of communication, disagreements between branches.
Employers were hostile => forced their employees to sign ‘the swearing document’ (promise not to join the GNCTU)
Whigs VS trade unionists => The Tolpuddle Martyrs from the Friendly Union of Agricultural workers were arrested and put into jail => fear of the workers.
1889 Docker's strike
Unskilled workers suffered most of the great depression => not represented by skilled workers unions => spread of the factory had created big concentrations of urban workers => New unionism registered its first successes.
B. Tillett, T. Mann and J. Burns formed the General Labourers’ Union => Claims = minimum wage (‘the Dockers’ tanner’) + right to work more hours (and not having to wait to be called and bribe the owners) BUT The docks owners refused to negotiate.
CQ: Five-week successful strike => WHY? Skilled workers helped them + peaceful (public opinion sympathized with them) + Cardinal Manning supported them and convinced the employers.
Enormous consequences: possible even for unskilled workers to get to their point IF they were organized enough => many workers joined New-Unionism
YET, problems => seamen and Dockers’ strikes to set up closed shops (= the employer agrees to hire union members only) failed BC OF depression => it was impossible to pressurize the employers (blacklegs) => 1890s: New unionism refocused on developing industries (gas, water, electricity).
What were the new things about New Unionism?
=> The Junta founded the Trade Union Congress (TUC) in 1868 => permanent organisation embodying New Model unionism.
Some secretaries of these unions (Applegrath or G. Odger) formed a small working class aristocracy nicknamed ‘the Junta’ => made the society believe that New model unions = respectable and trustworthy (same for the 1867 Royal Commission Report) => THUS picketing and negotiation became accepted (employers 😒)
However, difficulties arose in the mid-1860s
THUS skilled workers organized themselves => The 1st ‘New Model’ Union = 1851 Amalgamated Society of Engineers (W. Allan &W. Newton) => wanted better wages, less working hours) => wanted to remain respectable: strike was their last-resort weapon
After 1834 => hardship for trade unions => Trade depression = unemployment, low wages etc.
Hornby v Close: a union sued its treasurer for having embezzled money => funds of the union were NOT protected by the 1855 Friendly society Union Act BC ruled that unions ≠ friendly unions => changed thanks to Applegrath’s skills (1867 Report)
‘Sheffield outrages’: a member of the Unions was responsible of several scandalous actions of intimidation (explosions)
Progress
Disraeli’s Conspiracy and Protection of Property Act (1875) / Employers Workmen Act.
1871: Gladstone’s trade Union Act / Criminal Law Amendment Act
influence of New Unionism was not that significant before 1914 but in politics => The necessity to enter in parliament was understood after several issues:
Poorer + many socialists + tackled real problems (unemployment)
HWR old unionism (New Model) was not reactionary and old-fashioned => lot of common points
During the 1890s, as New Unionism survived, both unionisms kind of merged.
Taff Vale Case (1900) = Taff Vale Railway Company leaders sued the Amalgamated Society of Railway Servants for having picketed. => HoL ruled in favour of the company => ++money to pay => union in bankruptcy => unions kept joining the LRC => 1906, the Liberal gvt bill of Trade and Dispute Act ruled that it was illegal to sue a union only because it did picketing
1899 Lyons (workshop owner) v. Wilkins (society of Fancy Leather Workers) => Appeal court issued that picketing not allowed => threat for unions => The Labour Representation Committee (LRC) was founded in 1900 to send independent Labour candidates to the parliament in order to protect the poor’s right.
Osborne judgment (1906): the HoL ruled that the political levy (union members paying the MPs wages) was illegal =>cash shortages => 1911: was voted a 400£ annual salary for MPs (cf Chartism) => 1913: Trade Union Act authorized the political levy again
Before WWI, some unionists were influenced by the French syndicalism => different philosophy: direct action (not in Parliament) => Strike = common weapon that had to be used => got popular bc unionism disappointing in the early 1900s.
The Labour party = amalgamation of 3 socialist groups => all agreed on the necessity of representing the working class in the parliament.
=> Poverty had been worsened by the great depression.
=> American Economist Henry George’s Progress and Poverty (1881) = popular plea to improve working class conditions (by taxing landowners)
=> Gladstone disappointed the working class since he did not do social reforms (liberals lose pop)
3 socialist groups
Fabian society led by Sydney & Beatrice Webb, George B Shaw => Middle-class, pro-cooperative organisation of the economy
=> BUT non-violent (progress was inevitable)
=> YET, came to the idea of a Labour party BC of Conservatives and Liberals hostility to their cause.
Independent Labour Party created by James K. Hardie (Scottish miner)
=> Resented the Liberals bc did not pay attention to the working class
=> The final aim = collective ownership of the means of production (at first, more moderate, only abt improving conditions)
Social Democratic Federation (SDF): workers’ movement led by General Labour Unionists (Mann, Burns) & H.M. Hyndman. => violent revolution and the destruction of capitalism. => 1887: demonstration in Trafalgar Square = Bloody Sunday.
The Labour Party
Creation helped by growth of trade unions (after 1890s issues, they realized how vital political representation was) => 1900: The TUC, the 3 socialists groups, and other unions met at the Memorial Hall in London => foundation of the Labour Representation Committee to organize election campaigns => 1st secretary was James R MacDonald (future 1st Labour PM). The Labour party = name of the group of MPs from this committee at the assembly.
Not popular at 1st BUT electoral pact with the liberals in 1903 => way to prevent to give seats to the conservativ (helped them to get ~40 MPs!) => some successes: the Trade Disputes Act (1906) BUT action = little BC depended too much on the Liberals
=> In 1914, the Labour party was still too dependent on the Liberal party.