Society/culture
Society & Culture 1894-1917
Society & Culture 1855-1894
Society & Culture 1941-1964
Society & Culture 1917-1941
LIVING CONDITION DEVELOPMENTS - CS
Conditions for peasant farmers did not improve substantially and there was still widespread rural poverty despite Stolypin's reforms.
- Although the Kulak class prospered, life became harsher for the poorer peasants.
- Many had to leave their farms and look for seasonal farming work or industrial employment. Minority migrated to Siberia.
- The Mir remained the centre of the rural life of which a large proportion lived.
- Living Standards were generally poor, however there was some variation.
- Despite healthcare provided by the Zemstvo, the Mortality rates remained high and there were few doctors.
- The literacy rate remained low, around a 60% literacy rate.
Social divisions
The Nobility
Around a third of nobles land was transferred to the urban middle class or peasants between 1861 and 1905, with varying effects:
- Negative change - some nobles struggled to meet debt. Some nobles unable to adapt to modern business.
- Little change - Taxes were not redistributed, so their life remained largely unchanged. Nobles retained Political influence.
- Positive changes - some did well out of land distribution, consolidating the best for them self. Some prospered by turning to industrial enterprise.
The middle class
- Due to demand for professional workers, an emerging middle layer in society increased in influence.
- Members expressed their views through the zemstva and the town and state duma.
- Social mobility began to occur as nobles sons chose to join the business, or peasants sons rose to middle class manager of factory positions.
Workers and Peasantry
- Population growth and economic development most affected the workers and peasantry.
- In the countryside; traditional attitudes, pre-1914 had been traditional grievances. But by 1914 political activism was taking effect.
- In urban areas, peasants lost their former identity. They instead associated with those whom they lived and worked, sharing grievances and becoming targets for political agitators. This discontented class provided the impetus for the overthrow in 1917
Cultural Changes
- New opportunities for women, for education or for independence through employment.
- Improvements in education had reduced illiteracy(secondary and higher education remained elitist).
- Books and publications increased; many writers started addressing the issues of Russia.
- Censorship was relaxed from 1905, producing the 'silver age' of culture.
However, the orthodox church continued to influence both government and community. There was an outpouring of patriotism and support for the Tsar when war broke out. 1914, all classes rallied to defend the Russian Motherland.
LIVING CONDITION DEVELOPMENTS - T
- Between 1867 to 1917, Russia's Urban population quadrupled from 7 to 28 million, peasants arrived to seek work in new factories.
- By 1914, 3/4 of the population of St Petersburg were peasants by birth, half the cities population arrived in the previous 20 years.
- Conditions in the towns were grim. Workers often lived in barrack-like buildings supplied by the owners, dangerously overcrowded and unsanitary.
- Rent was high and some workers were homeless and wages varied.
Between 1885 and 1912 a series of decrees attempted to improve conditions:
- Reducing work hours
- Enforcing the use of contracts
- Banning the employment of children under 12
- Provided sickness and accident insurance
- Increasing educational provision
Political discontent spread easily through towns and cities. Strike activity was rare before the events of 1905. It escalated again in 1912 and 1914 where there were 3000 stoppages. Government repression was violent.
BACKGROUND CONTEXT
Russia was a starkly divided nation between the privileged Land-owning elite and the serf majority.
- Non-Productive class - Consisted of clergy, nobility, civil and military officials, army and naval officers.
- Productive class - Serfs, Urban artisans (E.g leather-maker), Merchants and manufacturers.
- Middle class - striking feature was the absence of a middle class, there were a small number of professionals (doctors) of whom formed an educated 'intelligentsia', these were often sons of nobles.
Classes
Taxes
- Taxes provided 25% of ordinary government income which grew to 30% by 1855
- Peasants were hit hard by taxation and with urban workers and tradesmen provided 90% of imperial income. Nobility and Clergy were exempt from the payment of any direct monetary tax.
Social divisions
Industrialisation - more focused on money, capital and wages.
- Although society was still strongly divided before 1895, a new middle and working class began to emerge.
The middle class
- Growing class, result from industrial expansion and education.
- Include bankers, doctors, teachers and administrators.
- Enterprises included building railways and starting factories.
- Lower middle class could become managers or work shop owners.
The urban working class
- Around 2% of the population by the 1890s:
- Some peasants worked in towns and returned to farming at peak times
- Others became urban workers or worked for migrant groups building railways.
- Growing class 1 in 3 inhabitants in St Petersburg by 1864 were peasant born.
- Suffered poor working and living conditions.
The peasantry
- The richer peasants - Kulaks:
- Did well out of emancipation
- Bought up land and employed labour
- Might buy grain from poorer peasants in autumn and sell back for profit in spring
- Poorer peasants:
- Suffered more after emancipation
- became landless labourers, often in debt
- experienced poor living standards
- poor health and low life expectancy
- poor health and low life expectancy
The landed elite (former serf-owners)
- Small but diverse group, mostly of noble status
- Personal land holdings decreased since emancipation
- Employed in:
- Professional activities (e.g University professors)
- business, commerce, transport or industry
- Zemstva and/or provincial governorships
- Often retained much of their previous wealth and status
INFLUENCE OF THE CHURCH
The church possessed strict censorship controls and the church courts judged moral and social crimes
- 1862 - an Ecclesiastical commission was established to look into the church's organisation and practice.
- 1868 - reforms were introduced to improve the education of priests.
- The church was given more power over primary education under Delyanov as minister of education.
- Russification promoted orthodoxy throughout the empire. It became illegal to convert from orthodoxy.
There was evidence that the orthodox church was losing control over peoples lives. It was becoming less relevant in industrialising towns, and countryside superstition was becoming more powerful than priest influence.
Class issues
The classless society
Following Marxist theory, the Bolshevik revolution campaigned against the 'class' enemies of the proletariat (the burzhui).
POLICIES FOR MARXIST FUFILLMENT:
- Class titles were abolished.
- 'Former people' (nobles and bourgeoise) were forced into menial tasks; their homes were turned into communal worker housing (Komunalki).
- During the civil war, rations were allocated according to class (workers and soldiers received the most).
- Following some relaxation of the policy under the NEP, Stalin continued class-based attacks.
The communist goal was to create a 'socialist man' with a sense of social responsibility and a willingness to serve the state.
The proletariat
'Proletarianism was an important step in creating the 'socialist man'. Despite this working life was harsh.
After the short 'workers control' period of 1917-18, discipline in factories was restored.
HARSHER POLICIES:
After 1918, workers could not level their jobs and could be imprisoned or shot for missing targets.
Unions became a means of controlling workers.
- 'Living and working conditions remained grim throughout the NEP, and worsened because of collectivisation and the drive towards industrialisation.
OPPURTUNITIES POST 1931 (INDUSTRIALISATION):
- Propaganda campaigns such as the stahanovite movement (named after a miner whose inflated achievements were hailed as an example to others) increased 'socialist competition'.
- Education improved, the purges created vacancies at higher levels, and social mobility increased.
REALITY:
- Living conditions still remained poor. Wages remained low.
- Market prices were high.
- From 1940, the prospect of war led to firmer discipline, and an end to many of the benefits of the 1930s.
Women
LENINS POLICIES
Before revolution, peasant women had been mainly expected to look after households and children. They had no legal rights or privileges. In November 1917, the new government outlawed sex discrimination:
- Women given the right to own property.
- Removed church influence, facilitated divorce and legalised abortion.
- Gave women the right to work.
- Gave girls the same education rights as boys.
STALINS POLICIES
In the 1930s Stalin revived traditional ideas:
- Family was portrayed as all-important and women are encouraged to give up paid employment when married.
- Marriage was encouraged; divorce and abortion were attacked, adultery became a criminal offence and contraception was banned.
- Financial incentives offered for bigger families.
However, the numbers of women in work or education grew (in industry or collective farms), helped by an increase in state nurseries and in child-clinics. The divorce rate remained high, abortion continued and although the majority of people married, the population growth-rate fell.
Young People
Education
Education was seen as essential to build a socialist society.
LENIN:
- Free education was provided at all levels in co-educational schools.
- New secondary schools combined with general education with vocational training.
- Traditional learning was combined with physical work..
- Textbooks and exams were largely abolished.
- Some freedom, creativity and individualism were permitted.
- Physical punishment was banned.
STALIN:
- Education for all was abandonned; some single-sex schools were reintroduced.
- Although 'Practical work' was encouraged for the less able students, the focus was on teaching inudstrial skills.
- Collective farms or town enterprises were responsible for many schools.
- Universities were controlled by the veshenka, the economic planning agency.
- A rigid curriculum was enforced.
- Nationalism was promoted and military training introduced.
- Teachers were set high targets and closely supervised.
By 1941 there were marked educational improvements including a high rise in literacy.
Youth organisations
- In 1918 a young communist league was formed for youngsters aged 14-21 years.
- A junior section (the pioneers) followed in 1922.
- In 1926 the organisation was renamed the 'Komsomol' and the age-range was extended to between 10-28 years.
CONTINUED & GREW WITH STALIN:.
- It taught communist values through clubs, community centres and camps and had its own newspaper.
- It was closely linked to the communist Party
- directly affiliated in 1939.
- Members took an oath to live, study and fight for the fatherland;
- they wore a uniform
- helped carry out party campaigns
- assisted the red army and police.
Religion
MARX SAW AS A MEANS TO PROTECT UPPER CLASS
1917-18 (Lenin)
- Freedom of worship.
- Church lands seized.
- Schools transferred to the state.
- Civil marriage and registration were established.
Church and state were seperated.
civil war
- Many Priests starved (deprived of rations).
- Muslim property confiscated, Sharia courts abolished.
From 1921 (Stalin)
- Teaching of religion in schools banned.
- Church property transferred to the state.
- Church officials forced to agree to keep out of politics.
- Churches ransacked.
- Christian festivals replaced with secular celebrations.
Stalin, 1929-41
- Worship restrictions.
- New six-day week had no sunday.
- Muslim practices restricted.
- 1936 constitution criminalised religious propaganda (although priests regained the right to vote).
- By 1641, around 65,000 churches and mosques had been converted into other buildings.
- However, religious belief remained strong.
National Minorities
Self-determination
- Lenin's nationality decree of 1917 fulfilled the Bolshevik promise of self-determination.
- However, when this led to separatist movements, the Bolsheviks disagreed as to whether or not to impose integration on the nationalities.
- Stalin brutally suppressed movements towards independance in Georgia in 1922.
Anti-Semitism
- The communists abolished anti-semetic laws in 1917, encouraged national languages, and granted representation within the party to major nationalities.
- In 1926, Jews were given a 'National Homeland' in the far east provences.
Single soviet identity
- In the 1930s Stalin's aims of creating a single 'Soviet identity' involved greater centralisation and less tolerance.
- Leaders of the republics had to follow the path set out by Moscow.
- Non-Russians were deported within the Soviet Union and anti-semetic behaviours revived.
- From 1938, learning Russian was compulsary in schools, and Russian was the only language in the Red army.
Stalinist state
The Stalinist state remained officially opposed to racial discrimination. Most campaigns were politically rather than racially motivated.
Propaganda
LENIN
- used propaganda to convert people to Socialism. Strong visual messages were a powerful way of appealing to illiterate peasants.
STALIN
- exploited his own propaganda machine to gain support for collectivisation and industrialisation. The socialist message was reinforced by images of happy, productive workers, while heroes were praised as role models.
- propaganda also reinforced his own position, portraying him as a mighty, all-knowing leader, and a natural successor to Marx, Engels and Lenin. Stalin encouraged a cult status for Lenin after his death, and developed his own 'cult personality'.
Cultural change
LENIN
- Greater freedom immediately after the revolution allowed culture to thrive. Freedom of expression was encouraged and the 1920s became the 'silver age' of Russian literature, poetry and music.
STALIN
The Stalinist era reversed these developments. The visual and performing arts were seen as valuable only if they supported the creation of the 'socialist man'. Creativity was replaced with conformity.
From 1932, writers musicians, artists and film-makers had to belong to unions, which controlled their output. Writer and other artists were expected to depict 'social realism' - namely and uplifting vision of soviet life in the socialist future. Literature and Art were to illustrate the inevitable 'march to communism' and glorify the working man.
SOCIETY BY 1941
Social weaknesses
Quality of Life did not improve significantly under Stalin:
- Living standards remained low.
- Freedom of movement was restricted.
- Censorship and propaganda dominated.
- Mass organisations manipulated the people.
Social Strengths
- Communist control in the countryside had been strengthened: Peasants were living and working in the Kolkhozes, supervised by Party officials and NKVD units stationed at each MTS.
- Urbanisation had created a far stronger proletariat.
- Socialist values were promoted through education, propaganda the leadership cult, public celebrations, arts, culture and show trials.
SOCIAL CONDITION BY 1964
- Living standards began to rise rapidly and consumers began to benefit from industrialisation.
- Generated a mood of optimism with a seemingly 'better society' being built in the USSR.
- Still massive unsolved problems in Society.
Impact of war on Society
DIFFERENT SECTS
The panic of invasion helped reunite society, as men rushed to military service. Stalin referred to the 'Great patriotic war' to strengthen spirit.
Churches
Persecution was temporarily halted.
The churches were used to boost morale and encourage patriotism.
Soldiers and workers
All sections of society were recruited and centrally deployed for war work.
Working hours increased.
Discipline (in both factories and army) was tightened.
Propaganda and culture
Intense propaganda was used to promote unity.
Posters and the press encouraged heroism and self-sacrifice
Artists and musicians enjoyed more freedom, to encourage an atmosphere of national reconciliation.
Partisans
Many soviet citizens and soldiers left behind the German lines formed partisan groups, using sabotage against the enemy.
They risked terrible Nazi reprisals, as did innocent civilians caught behind German lines.
Women and family
The importance of family was emphasised.
Women's burdens increased - they were essential wartime workers but also expected to raise large families.
Women worked in industry, on farms or in the armed forces, but received little reward.
Living condtions
Food shortages led to the death of millions.
Many had to flee the German advance or relocate to factories in the east.
Housing and fuel shortages were acute.
Health problems increased.
Many died in the Gulag.
Social change under Stalin, 1945-53
LITTLE CHANGE
- Standards of living for ordinary people did not improve.
- Peasants income remained low.
- In towns working and living conditions remained harsh.
- Workers could still be relocated.
- Party officials received higher rations.
- Women were expected to work as well as run the household and look after their children.
- Shortages of consumer goods.
Social change under Khrushchev, 1953-64
Khrushchev was committed to improving the living standards of the Soviet People. Through de-Stalinisation and economic reforms:
LARGE CHANGE
- Consumer goods were more readily available.
- Housing initiatives helped alleviate overcrowding.
- Taxation was lowered and pensions improved.
- Working hours were reduced and there was a move towards equal wages.
- Trade unions were given more responsibilities and greater influence in employment negotiations.
- Educational provision, medicine and welfare services and transport were improved.
HOWEVER:
- High-ranking Party officials retained privileges.
- Living standards were still significantly lower than in the western industrialised states.
The Quality of Life and Cultural change
Social life and Cultural change
After the repression and the fear of 'Zhandovschina'*, Khrushchev's de-Stalinisation policies brought greater personal freedom for soviet citizens:
POLICIES:
- Greater openness to Western influence Restrictions on Western contact reduced, reading of foreign literature permitted, some travel from USSR allowed.
- Brought discontent to rigidity of Soviet life especially amongst young people which led to increased hooliganism and protests.
- Rehabilitation of writers and Musicians who had been persecuted under Stalin - even if their work criticised the Stalinist regime.
HOWEVER:
- Artistic works still judged on their commitment to 'social responsibility' - any that challenged communism or Soviet State were outlawed.
The Churches
Khrushchev revived the old Socialist campaign against the Churches:
- Children forbidden from being taught religion - not allowed to be taught by parents or attend services, education was atheistic.
- Thousands of monasteries, convents, Orthodox Churches and seminaries were closed - many converted to museums or community centres promoting socialist values.
- Church service strictly regulated - Pilgrimages also banned.
- Excess religious devotion could lead to imprisonment - clergymen could be sent to labour camps.
Ethnic Minorities
Khrushchev did not encourage greater independence for the nationalities:
- Single common language - the party taught that ethnic distinctions would ultimately disappear and that a single common language would be adopted in the USSR.
- Restrictions on Jews maintained.
GENERAL POPULATION
The Russian people endured terrible wartime suffering. Nearly 30 million civilians and soldiers were killed and 25 million in the west lost their homes.
Despite this, War brought hope:
- The sense of collective endeavour revived hopes for change.
- Comradeship among soldiers helped spread new liberal thinking.
- Greater exposure to western influence led to hope for a more open post-war society.
Such hopes were not achieved. In reality, 1945-53 was among the most bleak of the Stalinist period.
Cultural - High Stalinism
New controls over intellectual life were introduced in the zhdanovchina (named after Zhdanov, who launched a cultural purge in 1946). Stressed conformity to socialist ideals and cult of Stalin. Westernisms condemned as decadent; all things Russian were promoted.
- Anti-soviet authors were condemned and publications banned (particularly those supportive of Western culture.
- Social-realism became the norm in literature, art, music and film.
- Only pro-soviet authors allowed to to visit USSR and few soviets allowed to travel west.
The impact of the Civil war on the national minorities; the 1922 constitution
- After the civil war the government ceased to support 'national self-determination'.
- Interdependence groups were denounced as counter-revolutionary.
- Georgia oppression - 1922, demands from Georgia were brutally crushed on Stalin's orders (Lenin condemned this).
- RSFSR replaced by USSR in December 1922 - union of soviet Socialist Republics. Officially a federation of republics on similar footing, states which made up union were under firm Moscow control.
RUSSIAFICATION
Russification under Alexander III
Alexander III and his ministers, especially Pobedonostev engaged in a policy of 'cultural russiafication'.
- Finland - Parliament was reorganised in order to weaken its political influence, Russian language was demanded, Russian coinage replaced local currency.
- Poland - Polish national banks closed in 1885, all subjects had to be taught in Russian in Universities, administration of Poland was changed to curb independance.
- Ukraine - Limitations on the Russian language in 1883.
- Military - Conscription area widened and national areas were dispersed to avoid national groupings.
- ORTHODOX CHURCH - adherence to the faith was encouraged. In the Baltic region, 37,000 Lutherans converted to orthodoxy for support measures.
- Asia - the All-Russian Orthodox Missionary society worked to convert people which involved Mass baptisms.
Results of Russification
- Resistance - June 1888 Police department estimated 332 cases of mass disturbance, this included 43 disturbances in 9/12 central provinces.
- Resentment - more educated and wealthy national minorities disliked the policy. Constantly petitioning the Tsar for more liberty, secret book publication continued.
- Misguided policy? - Intensified national feeling of non-Russians and drove some wealthier citizens to emigrate or opposition, which would have previously been loyal.
ETHNIC MINORITY ISSUES
- Russia was a multi-national Empire, inhabited by over 100 different ethnic groups.
- Slavs in Russia, Ukraine and Belorussia made up two thirds of the population. The remaining people were a mixture of cultures.
- Catholic poles, Muslims, Jews, Romanians & Georgians were just some.
- The diversity provided issues for autocracy particularly following a development of national identity where ethnic groups were provoked to assert nationality.
A II & ETHNIC MINORITIES
More concerned with control than racial superiority.
- 1863, the Polish rebellion broke out. More than 200,000 Poles had joined in creating an underground national government, which waged a guerilla warfare against the imperial empire - defeated in 1864 after fierce conflict.
- Did not engage in the systematic persecution of racial minorities and used concessions to maintain authority.
- E.g decrees from 1864-75 allowed Latvians and Estonians to revert to Lutheranism.
- Growing friction towards the end of his reign saw a growing intolerance of national differences.
- E.g Prohibition of Ukrainian language publications in 1876.
- 1883, non-orthodox churches were not allowed to build new places of worship, wear religious dress, or spread religious propaganda.