EVI - Jan Mocks

Government

Rebellions

Foreign Policy

Society

Religion

Death and succession

The Devyse

Lady Jane Gray: The Nine Days Queen

click to edit

Northumberland

Somerset

Western Rebellion

Kett's Rebellion

Accession and character

  • What was the significance of the dry stamp at the beginning of E's reign? The reform faction could legalise any doc at the end of H8's reign that they chose using the fry stamp. This included an altered will. This left the succession as H had approved as of the 1544 Succession Act, but also added provisions that strengthened the power of the Regency Council.
  • What was the regency council? The Regency Council was est by H to rule on E's behalf until he came of age, Formed of 16 men, was mainly dominated by members of the reform group. Paget, Seymour, Denny.
  • What were H8's plans for the council? How and why did these change? Henry intended for the gov to be formed out of a committee. Conservative members were expelled from council/executed (ex. Duke of Norfolk - narrowly escaped, and Earl of Surrey Dec 1546). Bishop Gardiner removed. BUT plans too ambitious and unusual: E's uncle, Earl of Hertford, ended up being elected Lord Protector 3 days after H's death.
    In the REGENCY COUNCIL:
    REFORM - Cranmer, Seymour, Denny.
    CONSERV - Wriothesley, Paulet, Tunstall.

Who was EVI?
Born to H8 and Jane Seymour Oct 1537, the only legit son of H. Became king at 9. Reign of a 'minor'. Hugh Latimer (Protestant), quoted Ecclesiastes in 1549, 'Woe to thee, O lan, where the king is a child'.
Other Child monarchs had not seen success.
How do we know so much about him?
Main source = his Chronicle. Started age 12, completed daily until after 15th. Able young monarch, well informed on gov business. Produced for scrutiny of E's professors, but after May 1551, used for own initiative.
What was the upbringing of E6?
Many personal servants: 3 physicians, 6 surgeons, 2 apothecaries, French cook, stone engraver, organ maker, 3 court painters, French tutor, 5 scholars, 5 musicians and 4 principle gentlemen. 3 gentlemen and 5 grooms always present. Hardly ever alone. Walls and floors washed 3x daily.

Profile//Timeline:

  • 1506, born
  • 1536, Henry married Jane Seymour, rise to power begins.
  • March 1537, becomes member of Privy Council and Earl of Hertford after birth of E6 in Oct
  • 1540s, experience of diplomacy in battlefields in Scotland and France.
  • 31 Jan 1536, Privy Council elect Somerset as Protector.
  • Feb 1547, Edward and executors sign doc giving S sovereign authority until E is 18
  • 16 Feb 1547, becomes Duke of Somserset.
  • Oct 1549, dismissed and imprisoned - April 1550, released and returned to Privy Council.
  • Jan 1552, trialled and executed.

SOMERSET - Edward's involvement:

  • Within days of H's death, Somerset had ignored intentions that country should be ruled by council; had made himself Lord Protector.
  • Strict with Edward; reduced servants, kept him under close control of brother-in-law (Michael Stanhope).
  • Ruled through dry-stamp and proclamations, based at new, expensive residence, Somerset House. Autocratic rule, alienated members of court.
  • E was 12 at time of uncle's fall from power, complained about lack of pocket money from Somerset. Virtually no direct involvement in politics - much of his time was taken up by education.
  • E's influence considerable. Autumn 1549, Somerset losing grip on power, retreated to Windsor, taking E with him. E fell ill, complained of surroundings.
  • E's turn away from supporting uncle was crucial for his downfall. Condemned him by saying S had threatened to create riots in streets if overthrown. S' denial worthless, couldn't argue w/ King.

Struc/style of gov:

  • Granted quasi-royal powers by Letters Patent in March 1547.
  • Authority not granted by parliament, so he was more independent of them.
  • Used more proclamations than any other Tudor (over 70 in less than 3 years, 77 in total), meaning that he was creating them w/out using parliament.
  • Obtained sole custody of the dry stamp, which had been left under control of 4 councillors, and he tried to insist that the King's true signature was not valid without his own counter signature.
  • Used household servants as gov officials - Thomas Smith, Michael Stanhope, William Cecil, Sir John Thynne and William Grey.
  • Methods aroused intense opposition and at downfall 19 of council accused him of 'malice and evil'.
  • Style of gov and policy failures weakened his support. Most important enemy was Earl of Warwick (Became Duke of Northumberland).
  • Regime suffered factional rivalries. First victim was his brother, Thomas Seymour. Thomas had been left out of Regency Council, had married Katherine Parr. Plotted with Southampton against S. Charged with treason, executed March 1549. Southampton denounced Seymour, achieved readmission to Council.
  • Warwick was Lord Chamberlain, promoted to Duke of Northumberland, and appointed his own hardman Sir John Gated as Vice-Chamberlain of household to ensure control over court. Though his supporters were conservs (ex. Southampton), who hoped for regency led by Mary, Warwick led a second coup directed at conservs. Assumed that this was his plan to increase his power, more likely he feared he would be ejected by them.
  • 1550, after Warwick's coup, Somerset released and allowed to rejoin Privy Council, but in 1551, Somerset was accused of plotting against the gov and was executed in Jan 1552.

Use of Privy Council:

  • By-passed Privy Council.
  • Council convened at Somerset House, and group of household servants were nicknamed 'The New Council'.
  • Members of actual PC increasingly resented Somerset; within a few weeks, one had been arrested (Earl of Southampton). No guarantee of wider public acceptance of S' protectorate, so there were fears about breakdown of law and order.
  • Even before 1549, misgivings about S had been growing. His arrogant and dictatorial manner created enemies, especially Southampton, who resented his earlier imprisonment.

Use of Parliament:

  • Practice of frequent parliaments established under H8 in 1530s, continued under E6.
  • 2 Parliaments in 6 years, and 1551 was only year without session. Used to establish religious laws, not establish/destroy Protectorate or to pass Act of Succession.

SOMERSET

SOMERSET: Problems:

  • Growing concerns about poverty due to social injustice and because it was seen as a threat to order.
  • Particular anger felt over enclosure.
  • Enclosure blamed for many economic problems, but a commission would raise expectations among people that action would be taken against enclosure.
  • Fear of poor increasing, so clamping down on vagrants would show Gov to be acting against poor who were not looking to work.

SOMERSET: Methods:

  • S tried to implement social reforms following the bad effects on peasants of land enclosures and prices in H8's reign, earned him the name of 'Good Duke'. Established court of requests at oen London house in order to hear cases of poor people. Refused to allow torture or burning.
  • Inflation and population were rising but employment opportunities were not. In addition, poor harvest in 1548. England was experiencing increase in vagrancy with potential increases in crime.
  • S badly handled rebellion of 1549. S feeble response to rebellions gave Warwick opportunity to strike.
  • Number of poor increasing and gov feared for disorder that large numbers of poor created. 1547, S introduced Vagrancy Act. Any able-bodied person who was out of work for more than 3 days, should be branded with V and sold into slavery for 2 years. Further offences = a life of slavery. Children of vagrants could be taken away and made to work as apprentices. None of these provisions put into effect; it was a knee jerk reaction to the concerns of the wealthy. Act did not show S in humanitarian light, many authorities refused to enforce it. Did take a step towards poor relief provision which later evolved. Ordered local officials to provide housing and collections for all 'idle, impotent, maimed and aged persons' who were not vagabonds. Nicknamed 'Slavery Act'.
  • 1548, three proclamations issued banning playing football, spreading rumours and unlawful meetings. Anyone found guilty was made a slave.
  • Somerset influenced by Churchmen and intellectuals ex. John Hales. All men against 'enclosure' as it was seen as the crux of economic problems, especially where it involved a decline in 'tillage' (land used to grow crops). May 1548 - Hales heads commission into enclosure. June 48 - a series of proclamations introduced agaisnt enclosure for grazing. Followed by March 1549 5% tax on personal property passed, as well as a sheep tax against stiff opposition. All above alienated gentry and nobility, led to KETTS and WESTERN REBELLIONS in 1549.

Problems:

  • S bound by H's wish for E to marry MQoS, and by need to retain support of nobility.
  • Periodic invasions of Scotland had failed to achieve overall objectives and war expensive.
  • S had been leader of successful attacks in 1540s, had plan to save money on invasions by garrisoning Scottish lowlands.
  • Pursuing war would require a lot of money to be raised, ending it would be unpopular.

Solutions:

  • Failed to secure marriage alliance between England and Scotland. Deteriorating relations with France in 1549 led to threat of war and French southern invasion, when S at weakest due to rebellions. S' strategy against Scottish in FP was to defeat them in battle, build and garrison forts in borders and south of Scotland, and for them into submission. Began well - Battle of Pinkie 1547 - but strategy began to unravel - forts difficult and expensive to garrison, and Somerset underestimated amount of cooperation between Scotland and France.
  • 1547, S inherited ruinous FP from H. Tried to unite England and Scotland through marriage. Scotland was S' main priority, where H8 had seen France as priority, and Scotland being sideshow.
  • S failed to block Firth of the Forth (Scottish bridge) properly, and Drench relieved Edinburgh, gaining control of MQoS, who was taken to France in Aug 1548 to marry the Dauphin. Disastrous consequences for S.
  • S mainly concerned with Scottish war and therefore continued to spend vast amounts of money. 1547-1549: S spent £580,393 on Scottish wars and continued to finance fortifications at Boulogne in France, captured by H8 in 1544. Debasement continued, no attempt made to reform gov finance.

NORTHUMBERLAND

Problems:

  • S' policy of establishing garrisons proved a costly failure. Aristocracy still looked to warfare as a means of achieving status and prestige.
  • Holding on to Boulogne was an important part of maintaining H8's legacy.
  • Pursuing wars could be costly simply to raise. Ending wars would ease financial hardship.

Solutions:
N's policy of reducing spending was done as follows:

  • Drastic cuts in military and household expenditure ordered.
  • Boulogne returned to France for £133,333 and garrisons withdrawn from Scotland.
  • Expenditure on navy and forts continued.
  • Commissions established to inquire into state of finances and Winchester enforced stricter methods of accounting.
  • An emergency household fund - a privy coffer - was established.
    N needed to cut back spending but also had to ensure that he was rewarding his supporters. Spending was cut back but it was not realistic for the King to 'live of his own' in the 16th cent.

NORTHUMBERLAND: Problems:

  • Widespread and dangerous rebellions in the summer of 1549 had raised great fears among the ruling elites. N played a central role in crushing Kett's.
  • S' anti-enclosure policy had been seen as a cause of the rebellions in 1549. Expectations were raised among the people that action would be taken against enclosure.
  • S' anti-vagrant policy had been too harsh, but the problem of large numbers of poor and the belied that this led to disorder remained.
  • Harvest of 1549 had been poor, but harvest of 1550 worse.

NORTHUMBERLAND: Solutions:

  • N decided to repeal Vagrancy Act, but its provisions for care of the elderly and disabled were kept.
  • By 1551, N's gov had taken measures to control stocks of grain which were in crisis due to harvest failures.
  • N did introduce new Treason Laws in 1550 and used Lord Lieutenants and retainers of trusted nobles to keep order.
  • N did not continue S' anti-enclosure measures. Commissioners were withdrawn and unpopular sheep tax was repealed in 1550. Existing enclosure leg simply reinforced.
  • In terms of supporters, N was two faced when it came to religion. Posed as Catholic for coup, but became radical Protestant after. Announced conversion on scaffold at own death.

Relationship with King:

  • When it came to E's succession, it's believed that N changed the succession so that he could retain grip on power by marrying son Guildford Dudley to LJG, E's successor.
  • Also careful to cultivate close relationship with E, pursued policies which would guarantee this - ex. extreme Protestantism.

Style of Gov:

  • Directed to his personal political objectives. His role in S' downfall and subsequent elevation seemed to be motivated by his survival instinct. Once in power, he ensured his position by staffing household with his men who could then access E. EG. John Gates as Vice-Chamberlain (commanded King's guard, held dry stamp, reported to N all comings and goings of the King), William Cecil as deputy.

Use of Privy Council:

  • Extended use of PC. Understood that survival depended on control of Council. Made himself Lord President, so that he could fix agendas and meetings and bar councillors. Also assumed King's power to create new councillors. N's reform of PC marked 'revival' of gov by council.
  • Did mastermind coup in 1549, gave him control of the PC. Purged people who had helped him in coup. Ordered S' arrest and manufactures ev in trial of Dec 1551 that led to S' execution. Though, did make effort to reconcile: by mid 1550, S returned to court, good restored, daughter married to N's son. S, however, continued to plot, leading to N's willingness to execute him.
  • Gave priority to reorganisation of PC and Gov fiances to ensure secure position. Also careful to cultivate a close relationship with King and pursued policies that would guarantee this.

Use of Parliament:

  • Continued frequent use of Parliament. 2 Parliaments in every year for 6 years. 1551 only year w/out session. Parliament used to pass religious laws, not used to est or destroy Protectorate, or to pass Acts of Succession.

Gov plans under N were 3 fold: end debasement, reduce expenditure, end royal debt.

Finance

NORTHUMBERLAND

SOMERSET

  • S most pressing need was for money. In 1547, shut down the chantries and commissioners confiscated gold and silver plate. Melted down and made into coins. However, more coins in circulation = more inflation.

Northumberland's policy of ending debasement was done as follows.

  • Proclamations were issued to reduce value of coinage in 1550, but no action was taken until April 1551. Even then, N did not call in debased coinage and replace it with accurate coins (done in 1560). N was only telling people to lower prices and trust coinages without concrete reason to do so.
  • Collapse of Antwerp market 1551-52 caused further economic problems , esp. for cloth trade.

The issue of Royal debt under N was tackled as follows.

  • Debts were at worst in 1550, standing at £300,000 and were reduced by 1553 to £180,000.
  • Crown and chantry lands were sold, though no longer then contributed to crown income.
  • Parliamentary taxes, debasement and clawing back of debts were also necessary to help reduce what money the Ceown owed.
  • Sire Thomas Gresham was authorised to pay off royal debts on the Antwerp market. He showed energy and ingenuity, crossing the Channel 40 times in a few months and manipulating the exchange so as to improve the worth of sterling. He was so successful that he paid off all of the Gov's Antwerp debts in 2 years and renegotiated the loans at 12% interest, whereas the Emperor was borrowing at 16%.

N's policy of reducing spending was done as follows.

  • Drastic cuts in military and household expenditure were ordered.
  • Boulogne was returned to France for £133,333 and garrisons were withdrawn from Scotland.
  • Emphasis on navy and forts continued.
  • Commissions established to inquire into the state of finances and Winchester enforced stricter methods of accounting.
  • An emergency household fund - a privy coffer - was established. N needed to cut back but it was not realistic to expect the King to 'live of his own' in the 16th cent.
    N wanted to get crown finances back on course. William Paulet was Lord Treasurer in Feb 1550. He was talented, and also the Marquis of Winchester, He was tasked with reforming the finances. In addition, Sir Walter Mildmay produced a detailed analysis of the shortcomings in royal financial administration and plans were made for the streamlining of financial admin although most of these did not come to fruition until the reign of Mary I.

NORTHUMBERLAND:

  • Edward's involvement: - E gradually assumed a more significant role in Gov after 1549 due to: S' fall, the change in personnel at the top of Gov and E's growing maturity and interest in gov.
  • By Aug 1551, E was attending some meetings of the PC and by Nov 1552, he was attending them regularly and settling some agendas.
  • He took the lead in some business and had his own thought-out views on some of the most important matters of the day.
  • The council announces in Spring 1552, that E would reach his majority at age 16 rather than 18.
  • By mid-1552, E was learning his craft in practice rather than though lessons. He was developing practical skills. His entries on foreign events in his Chronicle shows that he was using sources beyond the normal flow of info available to the council.. Cultivating links with foreign ambassador, making independent use of secretaries, Cecil and Pertre.
  • N, learning from S' mistakes or just recognising the increasing power of the maturing King, was careful to ensure that E was consulted and involved much more in gov. Even N's title, the Lord President of the Council, demonstrated recognition of the diminished role in Parliament.
  • N was still in overall control, and placed limits on what aspects of gov that E could be involved in - for example, FP.
  • N manipulated where he could, placing his own men around the King and by packing the Privy Council with his own supporters. But, as with S, he was circumscribed by E's views.
  • May be that N's pursuit of Protestantism was motivated by E's commitment to it.
  • Final and potentially most serious act to which E was party was the attempt made to change the succession in favour of LJG.

Humanism

What was English religious doctrine like during the reign of EVI?

  • H8 had lurched from Roman Catholicism, to moderate Protestantism and then national Catholicism and had left an inconsistent patchwork of religious belief.
    • E6's reign witnessed a decisive shift towards Protestantism.
  • Historians have found the roots of this decisive shift to be firmly planted in the beliefs and actions of a number of key individuals of E's reign - Somerset, Northumberland and Cranmer, as well as E later on in the reign.
  • Much debate had been made about the significance of the young monarch in contributing towards this shift - he certainly was a committed Protestant and was displaying the cool and determined political skills demonstrated by his grandfather.

Evidence about Edward VI's religious beliefs:

  • At his coronation, Cranmer compared Edward with the biblical child king Josiah - an analogy for the perfectmodel for Protestant reformers as he had become King aged 8 after a father hwo had worshipped idols - Josiah embarked on iconoclasm.
  • Easter 1547: the Compline was sung in English at the Chapel Royal to show Edward's support of Protestantism.
  • April 1550, the Spanish ambassador reported that all those around the King were advanced Protestants and that the King delighted in supporting their beliefs.
  • Miles Coverdale, translator of the vernacular Great Bible became Bishop of Exeter in 1551 and was chaplain to the King.
  • Of the 22 known royal preachers, 20 were reforming bishops or evangelical preachers
  • Only %5 of Edward's Chronicle is devoted to the subject of religion. His main religious concern in not doctrine but the control and structure of the episcopacy (gov of Church and bishops).
  • Edward liked long, complicated sermons and scribbled Greek notes as he listened.
  • Many of the people close to the King were Protestants, including Catherine Parr, Archbishop Cranmer, his tutor Sit Richard Coxe and two of his advisers: Sir William Cecil and John Hales.
    Edward was held in very high esteem by the leading reformers. Martin Bucer, for example, described him as 'godly to marvel'.

What religious changes took place under EVI?

  • Religious change during E's reign followed beither pre-planned nor a natural course of development. Followed a stop-start approach as gov struggled to appease radicals and conservs.
  • Reformation could not be achieved overnight, so E's reign can be seen as phased:
    • End of H8's reign
    • Removal of Catholicism
    • Unofficial Protestantism

SOMERSET:

  • S advanced Protestant, but gov problems of maintaining uniformity and order led him to pursue wavering path towards religious change.
  • Under protectorship, catholic Act of Six Articles and the Treason Laws were repealed, images destroyed and Communion in both kinds encouraged.
  • By 1549, moderately Protestant First Prayer Book had completed a significant shift in the rituals of the Church.
  • Somerset had been forced by domestic and FP constraints to tread water where doctrine was concerned. Restrained by fear of Charled V, rebellions of 1549 and by concern over war aginst Scotland.
  • Associated with leading reformers originally, Calvin regarded him as co-religionist.
  • However, moderate enforcement of Protestantism soon lost approval of radical protestants. Best described as an Erastian Protestant who struggled to reconcile demands of gov with the religious changes when the political situation made it impossible.

NORTHUMBERLAND:

  • Religious position described as an enigma. At several crucial moments declared himself Catholic, yet while head of the gov was decidedly Protestant.
  • Answer to enigma = Northumberland a politician first and foremost. Religion second to search for power.
  • Would have enjoyed significant amount of political benefits from moving towards Protestantism: Increased bond with and influence over E, a say in England's religious future (judged that this lay with Evangelical (protestants and appointed radicals), the power and money that lay with stripping the Catholic Church. Also, possibly 'public order considerations' as Protestantism saw social control.

PHASE ONE, Destructive:

  • 1547: Royal visitations = Commissioners sent to examine state of clergy, doctrine and practices of the Church. Episcopal authority suspended until completion.
  • July 1547: Book of Homilies and Paraphrases = Ordered Cranmer's Book of Homilies (had sermon supporting Lutheran belief of justification by faith alone) and Erasmus' Paraphrases to be placed in every church. Gardiner and Bonner imprisoned as they objected.
  • July 1547: Royal Injunctions = Orders given for all clergy to preach in English, and have English Bible and Protestant Lit in every Chruch. Superstitious images to be removed.
  • 4 Nov - 24 Dec 1547: Chantries Act of Parliament = Revived from Henry's last Parliament in 1545, contained new preamble condemning all prayers for dead.
  • 4 Nov - 24 Dec 1547: Treason Act repealed by Parliament = removed old heresy, treason, censorship and proclamation laws. Allowed people to discuss religion freely without fear of imprisonment and to print and publish freely. Radicals lept to opportunity to spread their views and in some cases destroyed Catholic images and altars. Gov stripped itself of powers needed to curb outbursts. Protestant pamphlets bitterly attacked Mass and Catholics in general.

Later changes under E:

  • 1550-52 more radical
  • Cranmer moving to introduce radical liturgy as seen in 2nd Book of Common Prayer 1552.
  • Ridley and Hooper = influential radical clergymen.
  • Continental reformers such as Bucer and Martyr move to England. English reformer had close links to Bullinger of Zurich, who had carried out Zwinglian reformation in city (Protestant belief).
    • Edward beginning to have more influence on policy making. Crown in debt so benefitted from stripping assets of Church ex. diocese combined and land passed over to Crown (Bishops of Worcester and Exeter combined and 66% of Worcester went to Crown).

PHASE TWO, State of Limbo:

  • Jan-March 1548: Series of Proclamations issued to dampen Protestant unrest = Privy Council need to asset that transubstantiation still in force and Catholic rites needed to be adhered to. Gov trying to achieve order and was playing for time while Cranmer produced new Prayer book.
  • 11 Feb 1548: All images to be removed from churches = Achieved with little opposition.
  • 24 April 1548: Proclamation stating only authorised clergy to preach = Gov felt that this was necessary because of flood of unauthorised Protestant preachers that had followed repeal of Treason and heresy laws.
  • 23 September 1548: Proclamation stating that no preaching until new liturgy introduced = Liturgy were instructions setting out how a service may be performed. Clear sign gov felt that situation was slipping out of control.

PHASE THREE, Formative:

  • Dec 1548: First Prayer Book = manual written by Cranmer outlining liturgy. ??
  • Jan 1549: Act of Uniformity = Made Book of Common Prayer official liturgy. Effectively enforced despite pockets of resistance such as Western rebellion.
  • Nov 1549: Parliament remove all laws against Clerical marriage. Ecclesiastical courts in King's name.
  • 25 Dec 1549: Proclamation ordering destruction of remainder of images.
  • Jan 1550: Reformed Ordinal = detailed ceremony to be followed when clergy ordained. Radical Hooper outraged by swearing of an oath to saints and by need to wear a white surplice. Controversy raged between Hooper and Ridley until Hooper forced to back down.
  • Nov 1550: Removal of stone altars and replacement by wooden ones.
  • Jan 1552: New Treason Act = made it an offense to question Royal Supremacy or any articles of faith in the Church.

PHASE FOUR, Completion:

  • Jan 1552: 2nd Book of Common Prayer = highly Protestant doc (produced by Cranmer with advice from Bucer), removing traces of Catholicism and est a Eucharist ceremony in line with Calin's belief of a spiritual presence. PRayers for dead and wearing of vestments removed. Still opposed by some reformers, who resented expectation to kneel during communion.
  • April 1552: Second Act of Uniformity = enforced Second Book of Common Prayer. Became an offense for both clergy and laity not to attend CofE services.
  • Nov 1552: 'Black Rubric' Proc. Explained that kneeling to recieve Communion was for sake of good order, not out of idolatry. Edward personally intervened in debate.
  • 24 Nov 1552: 42 Articles submitted = issued by Gov on 9 June 1553, but never became parliamentary law. Based on Cranmer's ideas. Strongly PRotestant, based on doctrine of justification by faith alone and on Calvin's belief in predestination. 42 Articles became the basis for the 39 Articles in E1's reign.
  • 1553: Short Catechism produced without parliamentary approval = a manual for teaching main beliefs of Church. Written in question-an-answer format. Luther and Calvin produced Catechisms.
  • Key components of 1st Book of Common Prayer 1549? Services in English. Confirmed 5 sacraments. Communion in both kinds. Clerical marriage allowed. Purgatory unclear. No prayers for dead. Worship of saints discouraged. Trad robes in church. Transubstantiation. Fast and holy days remain.
  • Why 1st BoCP turning point? Outlines shift towards more protestant liturgy. Led to 2nd Book. Demonstrates Cranmer attempting to appeal to political conventions and therefore resonated with no one. Catholics saw as Prot, Prots saw as Catholic.
  • Key components of 2ndBoCP: Clerarly est Eucharist in line w/ Calvin's 'spiritual presence'. Eucharist called Lord's Supper; communicants to kneel. Trad robes not worn. Altars replaced by communion tables. Sign of cross abolished in confirmation.
  • What was Black Rubric 1552? Imposed Protestant-approves justification to something previously seen as Catholic. E's intervention outlines decision as crucial in shift towards Prot. Ambiguous as to radicalism.
  • Catechism? Manual for teaching main beliefs of Church. Necessary to help people of England understand where Church stood in terms of views/where they should stand, and what they would have to do to ensure they remained true to their King and England's religion.
  • 42 Articles?
  • Features of E's religious policy that caused outrage?
    Repeal of Treason Act Dec 1547 - Radicals use to spread their views and destroy Catholic images. Prot pamphlets attacked the Mass and Catholics in general. Led to JAn-March 1548 proclamations to try and dampen prot unrest, April 1548 proclamation stating only authorised clergy could preach and Sept 48 proc stating no preaching until new liturgy introduced.
    Jan 1549 Act of Uniformity net with reisstence of Western Rebellion
    Jan 1550 New reformed Ordinal - Hooper outraged that he had to swear an oath to saints and the need to wear a white surplice.
    Jan 1552 Second Book of Common Prayer - some radicals opposed expectation of kneeling during Communion.
  • Nature of religious change in England by 1549? Slowly and gradually 1547-48 whilst Cranmer composing 1stBoCP and Act of Uniformity - even when published, still moderate and considerate of Catholics in country. 1550-1553 religious change sped up, and there was a deries of more extreme liturgical docs published placing English doc more in line with Reformers on continent.

Causes

Events

Response

Causes

Events

Significance

1549:

  • 16 rebellions this year, 23 counties affected. Year of concern for England due to overwhelming amount of unrest that erupted. Majority of rebellions all took place from May-July, meant that gov would have to divide attentions.
  • Country in state of transition concerning both religious identity - First Book of common prayer published this year, introducing people to the trend of Protestant reformation that would see further relevance, and the fall of Somerset also took place around this time.
  • People entirely divided - those who thought Book signified eradication of faith, and those who deemed it not radical enough.

Religious grievances:

  • Contrast to Kett's, religion unquestionably central issue that sparked Western rebels. List of articles resolutely demanded the reintroduction of Catholicism. To be achieved through reinstatement of H8's Act of Six Articles, use of Latin, Communion in one kind, prayers for dead and Mass every Sunday.
  • Widespread response of ordinary people was provoked as much by familiarity of new practices as by doctrinal and political issues behind them. Removal of images and intro of new Prayer Book could have left all community in no doubt as to how significantly religion under Somerset had changed.

Economic factors:

  • Although articles produced by rebels dominated by religious grievances, it is a simplification to state this as the sole cause. Earlier stages, economic grievances featured more heavily. Complaints about taxes on sheep and cloth generated rumours about taxes on other animals. List of demands produced was a second list that superseded first. Initial list contained complaints about taxes and food prices, probably reflecting more accurately the fears of the rank and file members of crowd. Small group of clergy led by Robert Welsh hijacked control of movement.

Personality clashes:

  • In Devon, gov agent William Body had intensified antagonism felt towards religious changes with heavy-handed investigation into church property.

Background:

  • Cornwall had its own language, and its geographical location at the edge of the country made it a 'and apart'. Largest town in Bodmin had only 1,000 inhabitants, and county relied on profits made from tin mining. Poverty and vigorous regional industry had triggered the rebellion in 1497 against H7's tax request and had led to 3000 people joining Warbeck's attempt to claim the throne later on. Devon shared much of it's neighbours natural conservatism with regard to social and religious matters, and the common people of the country were more hostile towards gentry than in other parts of England.

Trigger causes:

  • Western rebellion had 2 principle triggers: William Body, a commissioner investigating church property in the country in 1547. His arrogance and the investigation into the Chantries created a swirl of rumours and fears about the confiscation of church goods. The destruction of the church images by Body the following year led a group in Helston to set upon and murder him. Devon quickly dealt with the uprising, but the deep-seated antagonism remained. The final straw was the introduction of the new Prayer Book on 10 June 1547.
  • In Devon, in the village of Sampford Courtenay, the people were also provoked by their priests use of the new Prayer Book on Whitsunday.

The rebellion takes hold:

  • In Cornwall, protestors assembled in Bodmin. They soon came under the leadership of Humphrey Arundell and a list of Articles was compiled. The crowd then marched on into Devon.
  • In Sampford Courtenay, the rebels persuaded the priest to deliver a traditional Catholic Mass and then moved on to join forced from Cornwall at Crediton on 20 June.

Local reaction:

  • Very quickly the gentry lost their grip on the counties. A gentleman called Hellier, who attempted to clam the rebels in Devon, was hacked to pieces. Sir Peter Carew, the leading gentleman in Devon, rode to meet the combined force at Crediton on 21 June. Carew succeeded in aggravating the situation, as he was a known protestant and his tense meeting with the rebels nearly erupted into violence when one of his servants inadvertently set fire to a barn.
  • Fled back to Exeter and then London.
  • The sizeable rebel army moved up to the walls of Exeter then to Clyst St Mary on 23 June.
  • Two gentlemen made further unsuccessful attempts to conciliate the rebels by agreeing that religion should remain as it was during Henry 8's reign until E came of age.

First gov response:

  • Somerset acting on inadequate info and had only limited resources at his disposal.
  • On 29 June he urged Lord Russell, a Catholic member of the Council, to find a peaceful settlement and wrote his own conciliatory response to the rebel demands.
  • At the time, Somerset was struggling to suppress enclosure riots in the Midlands, maintain forces on the Scottish border and watch for any French aggression.
  • He could therefore provide the cautious Russell with only a small army. Russell, knowing the weakness of his position, avoided confronting the enemy.

Descent into bloodshed:

  • Loyalty to Crown led Exonians to defend their city staunchly against the rebel attack for 6 weeks. Russell still prevaricated and on 8 July he made his last attempt to reach a settlement with the rebels.
  • On 12 July reinforcements under Lord Grey were delayed by another uprising in Oxfordshire.
  • On 28 July, in response to the pressure from Somerset, Russell began his advance against the rebels. He was aided by the much-needed arrival of the forces of Lord Grey on 3 Aug.

Gov suppression:

  • Confrontations between the rebels and the Government forces under Russell took place at Fenny Bridges, Clyst St Mary and Clyst Heath, each time the rebels were pushed further back.
  • On 6 August, Exeter and Gov reinforcements under Sir William Herbert arrived. Time was running out for the rebels. Somserset heaped yet more pressure on Russell to finish the job, as the French had declared war on England on 8 Aug.
  • Finally, on 16 Aug, Russell advanced on and defeated the rebel forces at Sampford Courtenay.

Aftermath:

  • Resilience and commitment of rebels remained strong to end and, even after victory on battlefield, Russell had to deal with rearguard action and pockets of reisstance until an estimated 3,000 people had been killed.
  • Robert Welsh, the vicar of the church of St. Thomas and probably the leader of the rebellion, was hanged on the gallows erected on his church tower, in his vestments and with a 'holy water bucket, a sprinkle, a sacring bell, a pair of beads and auch other like popish trash hanged about him.'
  • The Gov operation further deepened hostility as Gov forces had acted illegally, executing without trials and confiscating and redistributing property.

Enclosure:

  • Rebel attack on fences and hedges show opposition to enclosure in wooded pasture areas. First article of demands opposed future enclosure (but did protect the enclosure of expensive saffron fields).
  • Over prior 1/2 cent more enclosures had been created because more money in sale of wool and other animal products than in cereal crops. In response to this, some farmers had begun to specialise in sheep farming and had built enclosed sheep rune.
  • Attack on Flowerdew's enclosure that triggered the whole rebellion. List of demands does, however, contain complaints on a whole range of local farming issues, not just enclosure.
    • Gov action against enclosure: May 1548: royal deer park at Hampton Court was disparked (removed fences). 1 June 1548: Proclamation against men being 'driven to extreme poverty and compelled to leave placed they were born because of enclosure'. Simmer 1548: unusually large no of rural riots broke out including in Buckinghamshire where Hales was investigating. Summer 1548: The Council voiced opposition and with the populace increasingly restless, Hales began work of his commission again, but his work was a failure and he did not manage to bring proceedings against enclosures.

Rents: - Rebels also complain about rapid increase in rents. These complaints came in a period of rapid inflation, which worsened the economic situation for ordinary people. Rack renting was seen as a way in which unscrupulous landlords passed on the increased costs to the peasantry.

Somerset's policies:

  • Somerset's rep as the 'Good Duke' was largely built in his social policy. Somerset's perceived sympathy with the plight of the poor and the social and agrarian problems they faced was believed by contemporaries and some historians to have encouraged the common people to riot. If some of the rebels were confident of the Protector's support, it gave them an extra incentive to express their grievances. Ev for Somerset's sympathy is as follows:
    • He gave support to 'Commonwealth men' - a group of Christian reformers who campaigned against exploitation of poor.
    • He appointed John Hales to lead a commission into enclosure (one of the most fiercely resented of the agrarian problems that the common people faced).
    • He attacked landlord's greed.
    • He passed an Act protecting the rights of copyhold tenants on his own estates.

Protest against bad gov in East Anglia:

  • Kett's rebels picked out gentry and JPs in their country for the most vehement attack both in their articles and their actions. Kett's tactics seem to have been to appeal over the heads of the local gentry, directly to the central gov. - This appeal fits in with the traditional belief that the Gov wold respond to valid grievances and work on behalf of the ordinary people to redress them. Kett must have been devastated when on 21 June this was rejected.
  • To prove that the quality of the gov of the county was one of the major concerns, the rebels ran Mousehold Heath camp fairly and effectively, setting up their own court and sending out searches for food with commissions in the King's name. There was no gentry involvement in the rebellion and it was led throughout those just outside governing classes, who may have been ambitious for power themselves.

Religion and the Clergy:

  • The articles relating to religion are thoughtful calls for more competent and involved clergy, rather than controversial doctrinal statements. There was clearly concern with the poor quality of priests and their failure to fulfil their duties. One article requests that they do more to educate the poor and another states that the clergy should just be priests for the whole community and not just chaplains for the gentry.
  • The rebels inclination towards Protestantism is shown by their demand for congregations to choose their own clergy and by their use of the new Prayer Book at Mousehold Heath camp.

Personality clashes:

  • In both rebellions, hatred of particular individuals helped tip the countries into rebellion. In Norfolk, the first few fences and hedges to be uprooted were those of John Flowerdew, who had outraged the village of Wymondham with his rapacity.

Background:
East Anglia most densely populated and industrialised part of country. After London, Norwich was second biggest city in the country. (16,000 people) and had become a major textile centre. A collapse in the textile industry had thrown large numbers of cloth workers out of work, and many independent, small farmers were being badly affected by the enclosure of wooded pastoral areas by gentry and yeoman farmers.

Trigger causes

Rebellion takes hold

Local reaction

First gov response

Descent into bloodshed

Gov's first attempt at suppression

Full-scale rebellion

Gov suppression

Aftermath