Comparative Essay Poem Ideas

Blessing

'Poem at 39'

Half-Past Two

Piano

Half-caste

Search for My Tongue

Do not go gentle into that good night

Remember

M - The poem is about someone who is remembering about when his mother used to play piano as a child. M2 the poem might want to show to the reader the emotional power of music and the nostalgic importance of a parental figure

Imagery

Language

Meaning

the helplessness of childhood

Meanings

About a municipal pipe bursting, and the locals rush to seize the water spilling out

themes

Universal Human Truths

Imagery

light and dark

Religious/godly imagery, “voice of a kindly god”, shows the worship of the lucky “blessings” that everyone rarely receives.

life and death

"

This poem can be about society breaking down, and them being desperate for a miracle, worshipping anyone that saves them.

Religious imagery "And you, my father" " Curse, bless, me" "I pray"

Semantic field of light and dark

Meaning

semantic field of suffering

Imagery

Very Wrong

escaped

scuttling

Repetition "rage, rage against the dying light"
"Do not go gentle into that good night"

Run

wicked

Structure

villanielle

enjambement, symbolising an incomplete life

too scared

Structure

cross

wicked

Onomatopoeias, “Imagine the drip of it…” “echo in a tin mug” and “screaming (in the liquid sun)”. Shows the contrasts in society with/without the “blessing”

11 Tercets , could reflect the fact that there are twelve numbers on a clock and he has no understanding of time

" Curse, bless, me" - is an Antithesis
(Antithesis, Greek for “setting opposite” means “a contrast or opposite.”)

shared human experience

life/death/existence

suffering/celebration

identitiy

identity

we are what we think?

the 8th stanza has no mention of time symbolising the absence of time in his imagination

Tone

comparing poems

structure

language

meaning

'remember' and 'do not go gentle into that good night'

enjambement

imagery

five three-line stanzas and a final quatrain

tone

Hope

fear

Anger

semantic field of light and dark

click to edit

repetition

" rage, rage against the dying of the light"

ironical mockery

'half past two' and 'poem at 39'

'blessing' and 'search for my tongue'

similarities

differences

4 stanzas

themes of childhood

M- questioning society and their racial standards (why are they discriminated when others aren't)

Death, fight against death, celebrating and cherishing life,

i

Tone

Influence of music in the poem: The writer uses appassionato which is a word in italian which is the language used for musical notation. The title 'Piano' isn't in a definite article, which could mean that the author wanted to refer to the meaning of the word piano in another language, which in italian means soft or little which could refer to how young the writer was when he the poem was happening and that the memory that the poem is talking about is a very pleasant memory. Each stanza is a quatrain which also could be a reference to the common time signature in music, which is 4 beats in a bar

click to edit

misspellings, little punctuation

Punctuation, highlighting contrast

scornful

bitter

'poem at 39' and 'piano'

identity

Language

Similies, “skin cracks like a pod” and “blessing sings over their small bones”. This can symbolise on how the children, who would understand the least, would also suffer unfairly.

In the first two stanzas, there is a tone of unfamiliarity. In the third stanza, the tone suddenly shifts to wealth and celebration. This can show how desperate or hopeless the people in “blessing” truly are. Due to the government property (or larger government as a whole) the people can prosper with “wealth” (water)

how loss shaped their identities

Half Caste and Search for My Tongue

click to edit

language

click to edit

click to edit

structure

click to edit

click to edit

Piano is focusing on one memory

in the poem 'piano' the poetic voice is using the memory of their parents to look back and not move forward

Poem at thirty nine

tone

happier

celebratory

loss

6 stanzas

Structure

All the stanzas are split up into different arcs or themes relating to the community featured in blessing. In the first and second stanza, it’s like a dream. It can symbolise the hopes that the community had for a “blessing”. In the third stanza it implies about the reality when the municipal pipe bursts. Finally, in the last stanza, it represents the result of the miracle that occured, with the children not understanding or caring, but prospering nonetheless