Shifts in Thinking

What kind of a node am I?
What is my position in the network?
Am I aiding or inhibiting the flow of resources?
What does this mean for student outcomes?

Deficit Views
M&P, 27 - A deficit view is the belief that students cannot succeed due to a deficit. This deficit might be perceived as intellectual, motivational, behavioural, cultural or familial. Coming from this view, one sees the child, her culture or family as lacking, as the fountainhead for failure.

Prior experience of collaboration

Prior experiences negaively affecting perceptions of risk?
These initiatives have had limited success/results, often because we may not have had the proper structures and supports in place to enable them to function effectively, and no clear objectives have been established. With each successive iteration we show a little improvement, yet it would be hard to claim any significant successes.

Why am I like this?

Hargreaves and O/C, 77 - weak forms of collegiality were centered on gossip, talk, and sharing of ideas while strong forms of collegiality entailed actually working or laboring together in joint work that involved collective responsibility for results.

Hargreaves and O/C, 82 - Globally and historically, public school teaching has been rooted in a culture of individualism that has, in more developed and higher performing countries, begun to shift toward cultures of professional collaboration.

I am no more confident in the idea of collaboration across schools as I was in the beginning. I maintain my opinion that on the surface of it, collaboration is a worthwhile objective, I also maintain that it is not always easy to come by.

Reading these articles has solidified this position. Robinson (5 short articles) reflects this (pg. 16):
Weakness: The policy rhetoric is there – the practice not necessarily so. Implementation plans and resourcing have not always accompanied and supported the implementation processes of these documents

And this is indicative of not only the difficulties facing collaboration across schools, but can be distilled down to collaboration on a micro/individual level. Collaboration may be pushed from above (via PLCs or PD), but it may lack the necessary direction, objectives, or resources to make it feasible.

Timperley et al., 2020 - 'good intention is rarely enough to challenge the underlying biases that maintain the status quo of inequitable outcomes' (p. 79)

Future Challenges

In the future - I definitely feel that I have learned a great deal about unconscious bias, attributions, and teacher expectations throughout this module. I believe I will be able to look inward more than I did previously to investigate any such conditions. The best place to start is with myself. But, as Timp et al. suggest, this is not enough! I would like to develop the courage to speak up more in support of internal school solutions to problems that might be attributed to external factors (eg. academies, income level). I think the reason I withhold doing so is the nature of the main teacher who I am dealing with, his relative power within the school, and what I perceive as his unwillingness to look at alternative perspectives (based on a previous history).

Timp. et al., 2020, p. 66 - Raising awareness of, and explicitly challenging problematic bias and beliefs, requires leaders to embark on an ongoing, deliberate journey. This work is complex and there is no quick fix. It is immersed in seen and unseen emotion, vulnerability and risk. It requires courageous leadership underpinned by inquiry, evaluative thinking and an unwavering belief in social justice.

Intro/ Conclusion/ Future

Jan Robertson, from 5 Think Pieces - Everything in a system can socialize that system back into being what it has always been unless there are interventions of transformative change that prevent this.

Walkey et al. https://catalogue.library.auckland.ac.nz/permalink/f/1ac48r7/TN_cdi_webofscience_primary_000326848700003CitationCount
maintain that students are sensitive to messages from teachers and schools regarding high versus low expectations for success, and that such messages are communicated overtly and covertly.

M&P, 32 - lack of success is a result of what a student comes to school with or without – capabilities, motivation, ‘good’ home life – all external to the school or teaching.

Hynds, 549 - The types of social interactions that students experience with their teachers and their peers directly influence student motivation to engage. These include the expectations that teachers communicate to students as well as the types of instructional strategies teachers use in classrooms.

  • Teacher and school expectations have been
    shown to have a crucial impact on student outcomes

Unconscious Bias

  • Blank et al., 2016, p. 13
    Unconscious bias is an automatic tendency for humans to perceive people, situations and events in stereotypical ways. These attitudes and stereotypes, in turn, affect our understandings, actions and decisions unconsciously.

Timp, 2020, 59 - Biases influence judgments and expectations - good for top learners, not for others:
Biases influence judgements through what is noticed, and they inform decision making and actions. Leaders and teachers must make multiple decisions throughout the school day and beyond. Most of these in-the-moment decisions are based on tacit knowledge and perceptions of learners with unconscious bias playing a part when deciding what to teach to whom. They influence expectations. This works favourably for those learners who experience high expectations from their teachers but impacts negatively for those who experience low expectations

Bolton, 27 - Lower expectations for priority learner groups:
In New Zealand, as in many other countries, some teachers hold an unconscious bias against priority learner groups that can lead to lower expectations for these populations.

Timp, 2020, 59 - Biases are difficult to address, both in the classroom and beyond. This is, in part, because most people are unaware of them, do not fully understand how they work and, understandably, reject the idea that they hold them because they want the best for their students. It is difficult to address something that we are not consciously aware of and that our daily experiences may unknowingly reinforce.

Blank, 30 - Simply put, when teachers expect students to do well and show intellectual growth, they do. When teachers do not have such expectations – students perform poorly.
31 - Planting positive expectations seems vital – for both students and teachers.

Thinking before the course

Social capital & Social Network Theory

  • unfamiliar with this concept
  • believed I was collegially and professionally well-connected
  • understood part of my value was my relatable nature

Future Challenges

Thinking before the course

With students, I recognize that I have consistently formed opinions and expectations about their academic performance and abilities. These are largely based on prior experience, but of course I am sure my assumptions and biases have played a role too. I would like to set clear goals and expectations for my students going forward. I would like to explicitly communicate my high expectations for all of them, get their agreement, and then hold myself and them accountable for their achievement. I need to consistently message high achievement to all my students.

What triggered the shift?

"The effort involved in effective collaboration means hard-pressed and time-poor leaders and teachers may not believe that such commitment is worth it." (p. 5 - M2 - Munby & Fullan, 2016)

I am not a fan. I often struggle to relinquish control of situations, and can stick to what has worked for me in the past. I am happy to make my ideas and opinions known to others, and believe that I am fairly open minded when listening to others’.
Operating individually still remains my goal.

Why this is a problem:

  • there is a danger I am becoming a bottleneck that inhibits the flow of resources

Introverted

Vang, 36 - For teachers an important drawback
is related to a threat towards their strongly appreciated individual autonomy and independence.

What triggered the shift?

Regulalry noticing a desire to say something, but lacking the courage to so so

During the course

  • began to develop an awareness of the concepts and how they applied to me - what traits did I display
  • informal centrality - staff regularly coming to me for teaching advice, often mini-meetings occuring in my class
  • formal central actor - HoD - access to more information
  • much more frquently sought-out for advice than seeking
  • am I allowing the flow of resources, or creating a bottleneck?
  • definitely acknowleged that I am the last to meetings, leave informal chats at the school gate quickly, engaging less frequently - due to study commitments
  • how does this reflect on me as a formal and informal leader?

Good leadership needs to be redefined

  • currently not dsiplaying traits of leadership for SJ
  • how can I stand up for SJ, espcially when others are clearly closed to it?

Theo, 253 - SJ leadership is the new definition of good leadership, and years of 'good leadership' alone have led to inequity:
the leadership described in this article goes beyond what has been seen as good leadership and raises the challenge to recast good leadership as leadership for social justice.... leadership that is not focused on and successful at creating more just and equitable schools for marginalized students is indeed not good leadership. I caution us all to consider that decades of good leadership have created and sanctioned unjust and inequitable schools. The kind of leadership that needs to be defined and discussed as good leadership is the leadership the principals in this study have pioneered, leadership centered on enacting social justice, and leadership that creates equitable schools

click to edit

Aware of biases in varying contexts eg. stereotypes

  • no real hardened conceptual understanding - no theoretical base

Can see the issue in other teachers (language, stance) eg. Suah

  • Less able to recognize my own deficit views eg. Lucy
  • Blindspot due to her zero level when she first started. To me she has made a lot of progress, to others, she has not made enough. Am I willing to accept less because of where she started? What does that say about equity?
  • Recognizing my own unconscious bias


  • Having the guts to call out others

Identifying and surfacing deficit views