Holistic Medicine Essay

Scapegoating/Hate in Pandemics

Black Death (1347-51)

Groups targetted

Clerics and Beggars in Narbonne (Cohn, 2012)

Pogroms of Jews (Cohn, 2012) ✅

Further waves didn't set of the same waves of hatred

Murder of Catalans in Sicily (Cohn, 2012)

No blame of the poor (Cohn, 2012)

Determinants of Hate-causing pandemics

Syphilis (15th and 16th Centuries)

Names given

Neapolitan disease (Cohn, 2012) (Nelkin, 1988)

French disease (Cohn, 2012) (Nelkin, 1988)

Polish disease (Cohn, 2012) (Nelkin, 1988)

Disease of Portuguese (Cohn, 2012) (Nelkin, 1988)

Disease of the Turks (Cohn, 2012) (Nelkin, 1988)

HIV/AIDS (1980s)

Fear/Hatred of the the four H's; Homosexuals, Heroin addicts, Haitians, Haemophiliacs and Hookers (Cohn, 2012) (Grmek, 1989) ✅

Novelty of a disease could be the cause of extreme insecurity and fear that leads to this (Cohn, 2012)

Big killers with rapid person-to-person spread are most likely (Cohn, 2012)

Confounded by the flu of 1918-19; behaved as a new disease and didn't cause hate (Cohn, 2012) #

'Name of a disease suggests both disease and blame' (Cohn, 2012) (Johnson, 2006)

Contradicted by the Spanish Flu in Britain (Johnson, 2006)

Very unlikely due to a single factor (Cohn, 2012)

TB (19th & 20th Centuires)

'Jewish disease', despite being less afflicted (Cohn, 2012) (Kraut, 1995)


Polio (1907 & 1916)

'Italian Disease' (Cohn, 2012) (Kraut, 1995)

Hate and scapegoating isn't necessarily the rule when considering pandemics (Cohn, 2012) ✅

COVID-19

Terminology

'Chinese Virus' by the US

Done in order to externalise responsibility for the spread (Bieber, 2020) ✅

Evidence of disease to provide justification of discrimination and blaming of politically sidelined groups, as they're thought of as carriers. Evidenced in COVID-19 (Bieber, 2020), and in part provided justification in the Holocaust with typoid, and Armenian massacare (Cohn, 2012). The identities of the groups get so associated with the disease, they effectively become one with the disease from the perspective of the perpetrators; link normalises the non-human nature the perpetrators want to propagate. (Cohn, 2012) ✅

Bieber proposes, based on Eberhardt's writing, that the association of a marginalised group with a disease could perhaps influence the long-term implicit biases of a population (Bieber, 2020) (Eberhardt, 2019) #✅

Thought Process

Asian Americans are seen as Chinese, and in turn carriers of disease, regardless of country of origin, or generational status (Tessler, 2020) ✅

'Perpetual Foreigners' (Tessler, 2020) ✅

Documented Incidents

Boycott of Asian businesses UK (Lindrea et al, 2020) ✅

anti-Asian slurs used, demonstrating racialisation of asian americans (Tessler, 2020) (ADL, 2020) ✅

Need for a group to blame for the anger, fear, restrictions and insecurity that a new pandemic brings (Tessler, 2020)

Health Burden of Racism

Pandemic Specific

Ebola

(Lin et al, 2015) Described racism against Africans living in China during in Ebola, and stated that preventative measures should apply to all people coming back from Ebola-stricken countries, not just African nationals. ?link between this and anti-asian policies in COVID # #

(Kapiriri et al, 2020) Discusses how some literature surrounding pandemics can oversimplify the cause; relating it to cultural practices at the expense of exploring the impact of other complex factors that can lead to outbreaks ✅

SARS

Public blame was aimed at Asian-Canadian community in Toronto for bringing the outbreak there (Kapiriri et al, 2020)

The international response was too short-term as the disease was designated as racialised; an African problem (Kapiriri, 2020) (Jones, 2011) ✅

The further marginalisation of groups during pandemics makes them more vulnerable; emphasis should be placed on protection and the group's vulnerability, rather than placing blame and exacerbating the marginalisation (Kapiriri, 2020)

Implicit Bias

Most discrimination against Chinese nationals abroad was faced in high income countries (He et al, 2020)

Less likely to experience of discrimination with more confirmed cases of COVID-19 (He et al, 2020) #

In China, cars with Hubei registration have been attacked (He et al, 2020)

Social stigma during pandemics can reduce likelihood of seeking help, and therefore preventing early spread (He et al, 2020)✅

Meta analyses have shown the negative impact of discrimination and racism on mental health outcomes and wellbeing, as well as CVD outcomes and maladaptvie health behaviours such as alcohol consumption (Williams et al, 2019)

Percieved discriminiation makes a larger contrivbution for racial/ethnic inequalities in mental health and self reported physical health than SES (Williams et al, 2019) (Williams et al, 2009)

Combat/prevent

Utilisation of health services

Many pandemics don't differentiate based on national origin, and so while racially targetted groups have to bear the burden of the fear of getting ill (as does everyone else), they also have to bear the burden of the fear of discrimination and racism (Tessler, 2020)✅

Common fears of being ignored, not trusted, or general negative experiences with accesing therapy reveals implicit power dynamics (Bhui et al 2018)

Racism doesn't need to be aimed at the individual to trigger a stress response (Huynh et al, 2017)✅

Psychological Effects

Linked psychosis, depression, substance misuse and anger (Bhui et al 2018) (Williams et al, 2009) (Lewis et al, 2015)

A fear of racism can lead to poor health outcomes (Karlsen et al, 2004)(Williams et al, 2009)✅

A reduced use of health services leads to poorer health then stigmatisation (and stereotyping based on these conditions), further driving inequalities and discrimination (Bhui et al, 2018)✅

This can be linked to the generally more forensic, crisis or restrictive way Black people access healthcare (rather than primary care) (Bhui et al, 2003)

An American study showed patient communication was different dependant on the patient's race; physicians were more dominant and less patient-centred with African Americans vs white (Johnson et al, 2004) This kind of communication was linked to implicit bias against Blacks (Blair et al, 2013)(Fitzgerald et al 2017)

Explicit bias like discrimination and racism is the tip of the iceberg; implicit bias might be more widespread, and therefore insidiously impact; implicit attitudes frequently diverge from explicit attitudes (Fitzgerald et al 2017)✅

Implicit Biases are amplified in physicians in response to cognitive stressors (Johnson et al, 2016)✅

In physicians, negative bias toward black people is associated with higher symptoms of burnout (Dyrbye et al, 2019)✅

Interventions during medical school may be an effective strategy to counter this (van Ryn et al, 2015)

Prevalence

In a review, overall, healthcare professionals associate black americans with being less cooporative, compliant and responsible in a medical context (Hall et al, 2015)

In a US study, patient race was associated with physicians' assessment of patient intelligence, feelings of affiliation toward the patient, and beliefs about patient's likelihood of risk behavior and adherence with medical advice (van Rhyn, 2000)

Racial implicit bias is prevalent across healthcare workers in multiple specialities (Hall et al, 2015) (Fitzgerald et al 2017)✅

Bias is related to socio-demographic characterists of healthcare workers (Fitzgerald et al 2017)

Negative correlation between implicit bias and indicators of quality of care (Fitzgerald et al 2017)✅

Important not to neglect the presence of patient's implicit biases, and overlapping of group biases (Blair et al, 2011)

Strategies to change

Presence of admired individuals belonging to the group in question may change attitudes and bias (Greenwald et al, 2001)

(Fitzgerald et al 2017) provides suggestions on how to combat implicit bias as a clinician, researcher, policy maker, and patient

Short term strategies may show changes, however in a review, no strategies showed long term chagnes (Lai et al, 2016)✅

While this approach can be theoretically helpful in tackling change by partially removing some of the blame for bias that may be grounded in culture, some argue that it's not right that people are not being able to be held account for racism (Goldhill, 2017)

HR departments have tried to measure implicit bias using IAT, implement programmes on this bases, however not seen significant changes (Goldhill, 2017)

Singaporean student beat up in London (Sullivan, 2020)✅

Online; (L1ght, 2020) ✅

Further, with the case of HIV/AIDs, lots of the discourse blames 'self-indulgent' behaviour patterns as the cause, limiting responsibility of transmission to a very select population or individuals, and negating the responsibilities of the wider population (Nelkin, 1988) #✅

More examples (Jeung, 2020)

In 8 weeks (as of May 2020), almost 1900 documented case of anti-asian discrimination abuse in US; most common being verbal abuse and shunning (Turton, 2020) ✅

Present in EU, and propagated by public ministers of some members (FRA, 2020) ✅

Present in France and Australia (Zeng, 2020) ✅

Lots of blame and abuse placed towards chinese 'disgusting' eating habits of fruit bats (Zeng, 2020)✅

Costs lives, as we focus too much on this, rather than tackling issues such as globalisation and health equity that may play a bigger part in the effect that the pandemic has caused✅

Stress is linked to decreased antibody response to vaccination (Powell, 2011)✅

Health/bodily stigma is linked to reduced capability to seek help, eveni if available (Das, 2001)✅

Public health professionals must understand the neces- sary balance needed to protect the public’s health with appropriate exclusionary practices, while at the same time preventing fear, stigmatization, and discrimination of spe- cific segments of the population. (Person et al, 2004)

2015 WHO guidelines SPECIFICALLY state that diseases shouldn't be named after a specific area; something that has been subverted by politicians and the media throughout the coronavirus outbreak (WHO, 2015) ✅

Example of how stigma of disease developed fear of health services is exemplified in the early 1900s black death in San Francisco Chinatown (Tansey, 2019)✅

UC Berkeley stated to feel xenophobic was a 'normal' reaction (and later redacted this) (Chiu, 2020)

Weaponisation of disease to target groups (Colborne, 2020)

More than 30% Americans have witnessed anti-asian racism (Ellerbeck, 2020) # ✅

Possibly a very large driver, as evidence shows that most of NYC covid was spread from Europe (Langreth, 2020)✅

Yellow Peril

Belief that east asians are a threat to Western Ideals and politics; an 'invading force' ✅

Large anti-asian discrimination (Eichelberger, 2007) (Leung, 2008) ✅

It was noted that a lesson to be learnt is the power of the media in spreading racial fear, and the process of 'othering' perpetuating discrimination. This clearly wasn't heeded in COVID-19 (Eichelberger, 2007) #✅

Blaming a culture or behaviour, further engrains that population's status as inferior or dangerous (Eichelberger, 2007). This could lead to more discrimination, and then unwillingness to engage with medical services due to stigma; a self fulfilling prophecy #✅

Africans in China

Africans in China already experienced significant racism, limiting health and social support (Hall et al, 2014)

Use of disease/illness terminology used to describe the asian community in Vancouver in the late 1800s (Leung, 2008) together with the 'diseasification' of the Jews by Nazi Germany (Cohn, 2012) ties together the assocation of illness and marginalised groups in discourse, and therefore further strengthens the notion that the basis of racism, xenophobia and scapegoating during pandemics could predominantly be an opportunistic expression of underlying beliefs✅

further example of both culture attack and asian racialisation exists in the graffiti of a michelin star korean restaurant in NYC: 'Stop eating dogs' (Adams, 2020) # ✅

Targetted racism and 'othering' not too dissimilar to what Chinese are experiencing elsewhere in the world during COVID-19. This includes somewhat unjustified restrictions limited to African individuals (Vincent, 2020)

Trump's 'Chinese Virus'; and the fact he defended it 'because it's from China', (Aratani, 2020) shows either ignorance to the delicate nature of disease discourse, or a malicious intent. ✅

Racism is linked to delayed reciept of healthcare, and poor treatment adherance (Ben et al, 2017)(Williams et al, 2009)

General mental health affected (Lewis et al, 2015)

Religious behaviour and beliefs, mindfulness, emotional support can help reduce the negative effect of discrimination on heath (Williams et al, 2019) (Lewis et al, 2015)

Williams and Cooper (2019) argue that three areas need to be tackled; combat structural racism limiting the social determinants of health, plan culturally specific and appropriate preventative medicine initiatives, and increase awareness of inequalities and their impact on society, hoping to cause political and societal empathy strong enough to change. Multiple aspects of these focus on the PHE document to help address the proportionally negative effect of COVID-19 on BAME communities (PHE, 2020)

Interventions should be tested in medical environments (high exposre to stress) #

Therefore the burnout symptoms (As they lead to reduced quality of care) could be one explanation for the health disparity (Same author as original)

Be aware of terminology and explicit bias displayed by role models/superiors in medicine; a higher level of implciit bias in medical students was associated with observing remarks made by physicians with respect to african americans (van Ryn, 2015)

900% rise in anti-china/ese hate speech on twitter, but also rise in towards asians in general

70% rise in hate between children and adolescents

Media outlets have propagated this through instigating terminology #

Tech providers should take a stronger stand in stamping out hate speech

A crude example can be seen with 'swine flu' of 2009; where pigs were slaughtered and pork imports prevented, despite pigs not spreading the disease (Kupferschmidt, 2015) ✅

All four epidemics killing more than 1000000 people in the 20th century featured names blaming a population subgroup (Hoppe, 2018) ✅

As Hoppe states, a name is often the first thing that the public find out about a new disease/pandemic; it's essential steps are taken to get this right (Hoppe, 2018) ✅

Xenophobia to asian medical students in poland before the virus had reached the country (Rzymski, 2020)✅

BAME groups had worse clinical outcomes of COVID (Pan et al, 2020)(PHE, 2020)

Cultural competance is one aspect that needs to be worked on for this to happen (PHE, 2020)