Introduction to Markets
How Markets Work
Demand
Rational decision making
A rational agent wants to maximise their utility.
To do this, they will try to maximise their total utility.
A rational consumer will want to consume something up until the point where marginal utility and price are equal.
Agents
Rational agents are agents (people, governments or companies/producers) who use utility theory to guide their decision-making.
Producers
Consumers
Traditional theory says that firms will try and maximise profits, and this is how most of their utility is gained.
Reasons for wanting to maximise profit include:
In a world of asymmetric information, firms may have other objectives too, such as:
Governments
Survival.
To reinvest profits.
Nature of Economics
To offer managers and staff members better rewards.
Maximising revenue.
Maximising market share (and gaining monopoly power).
Ethical objectives (e.g. supporting the local economy).
Governments
Consumers
Governments should act in ways that best serve the population and, roughly speaking, try to maximise overall welfare.
This includes:
Achieving economic growth.
Reducing inflation.
Reducing or eliminating unemployment.
Achieving a balance between payments in and payments out (equilibrium).
Consumers
The Economic Problem
Consumers are said to act rationally and maximise utility within the limits of their income.
Different consumers will have different interpretations of utility. One consumer might prioritise financial security (e.g. in saving for a property). Another consumer might want flashy clothes.
Consumers may also want to maximise their work-life balance (i.e. maximising their income while enjoying as much free time as they can). Consumers act as workers when they do this.
Resources
Positive & Normative Economic Statements
Economics as a Social Science
Price and Quantity
Price is what the buyer pays for a specific goods or service.
Quantity is the total number of units purchased at that price.
The demand curve is downward sloping and shows the relationship between price and quantity.
This means that the higher the price is, the lower demand is.
The law of demand shows the inverse relationship between price and quantity, assuming all other variables are constant.
Production Possibility Frontiers
Specialisation & Division of Labour
Income effect - when prices fall, consumers can afford a greater quantity of goods and services
Types of Economies
Substitution effect - when the price of one good falls, consumers will buy more of the cheaper good or service and less of the more costly good or service.
Ceteris Paribus
Economists rely on the ceteris paribus assumption.
This means 'everything else remains equal'.
Substitute goods - an increase in the price of one good will increase the quantity demanded of the other.
Complement goods - an increase in the price of one good will cause a decrease in the quantity demanded of the other
So when economists study the relationship between two factors, they'll assume that one factor changes while the rest stay constant.
This is the most important assumption for economists to create functioning models
Elasticity of Demand
click to edit
Elasticity measures the responsiveness of one variable to the change in another variable.
Price elasticity = % change in quantity demanded ÷ % change in price.
Elastic demand is where the PED > 1.
Inelastic demand is where the PED < 1.
Unitary elasticity is where the PED = 1.
PED is almost always negative as an increase in price would result in a decrease in demand. But you may see some questions refer to it as positive for ease.
Income elasticity of demand (YED)
Positive statements
Income elasticity of demand = % change in quantity demanded ÷ % change in income.
Normal goods have a positive income elasticity, YED > 0 (income rises; demand increases).
Inferior goods have negative income elasticity, YED < 0 (income rises; demand decreases).
Normative statements
Cross Price elasticity of demand (XED)
Positive statements describe the world as it is. They are objective statements that can be proved.
E.g the proposal of the new high speed rail HS2. If the exact benefits exceed the exact costs, you could say the project is worth doing. This positive analysis. However, you may not always know costs & benefits perfectly.
Cross-price elasticity of demand is when a change in the price of one good can change the quantity demanded of another.
Cross-price elasticity of demand = % change in quantity demanded of good A ÷ % change in the price of good B.
If XED is close to zero this would suggest that the goods are unrelated.
click to edit
Normative statements describe how the world should be. They are opinions that contain value judgements.
E.g imagine an economist argued for higher unemployment benefits during a recession, because a rich country should take care of its citizens. This is normative analysis.
Value judgments
click to edit
Value judgments are often found in normative statements. They are judgements about society that cannot be quantified and tested.
E.g the homelessness problem in Oxford needs to be addressed and funds should be redistributed to do this. This judgement is within a normative statement.
Value judgements affect economic decision-making, so normative statements are important.
Perfectly elastic demand - PED = +/- infinity and any price increase will mean that demand drops to 0
Wants and Needs
Consumers have needs and wants that people hope will be satisfied.
Needs - things people can't live without (e.g. water).
Wants - things people can live without but desire (e.g. smartphones).
This is achieved by economic activity and the production of goods and services.
Perfectly inelastic demand - PED = zero.
Any price change won't affect demand.
Basic economic problem
There are not enough resources on earth to satisfy humans' unlimited wants and needs.
The basic economic problem involves working out how to allocate limited resources as effectively as possible to satisfy people's unlimited wants and needs.
Allocating scarce resources
Allocating scarce resources
There are scarce resources in society. Because of this, choices have to be made on how to use these resources.
The foundation of economic decisions are:
What goods/services we produce?
How we produce those goods/services?
Who we produce those goods/services for?
click to edit
Economic agents
Economic agent decision-making
Economic agents make decisions based on their various incentives.
E.g. for firms this might be profit maximisation.
Producers must decide what products to make and the selling price of products.
Consumers decide what products to purchase and how much they want to spend on products.
Governments decide how much they should get involved in the production and consumption process.
If there is unitary elasticity, any percentage change in price will be offset by an equivalent percentage change in quantity demanded so for moderate price changes, revenue will not change.
If a product is price elastic in demand:
Decreasing price = increases total revenue.
Increasing price = decreases total revenue.
Economic activity
Economic agents
It's up to economic agents to decide on how to allocate resources.
The three main economic agents are:
Producers - people/firms that produce goods or supply services.
Consumers - people/firms who purchase the goods/services.
Governments - establishes rules for economies.
Economic activity
Decreasing price = decreases total revenue.
Increasing price = increases total revenue.
Supply
Economic activity includes a wide variety of actions, such as:
Production of goods (tangible products) and services (intangible products).
Consumption of goods/services.
Because resources are scarce, we must ask three questions about economic activity.
What, how, and who to produce for?
Details of the PPF
PPF and trade-offs
When a firm's profits increase, it is incentivised to produce more output. This is because the more it produces, the more profit it will earn.
So, when costs of production fall, a firm will be incentivised to supply a higher quantity at a given price.
This is shown by a rightward shift in the supply curve.
The PPF shows economy at its maximum productive potential.
Society can choose any two goods on or inside the PPF.
The opportunity cost is the slope of the PPF.
The PPF is curved because of the law of diminishing returns.
As you increase units of one resource and keep other factors constant, the marginal benefit from the extra units will eventually start to decline.
Things that could cause a shift in the supply cure
Changes in the price of inputs (these will affect the cost of production).
A discovery of a new technology (allowing the firm to produce at a lower cost).
Changes in Government policy.
Taxes are treated as a cost by businesses.
Higher costs decrease supply.
So taxes decrease supply.
PPF and economic growth
PPF and productive efficiency
The PPF shifts outward if there is economic growth.
This is because the productive capacity of the economy has increased.
E.g. this could be caused from improvements in technology.
But this improvement isn't necessarily equal across all products.
E.g. an improvement in the technology to produce cars isn't necessarily going to affect the ability to produce butter.
The trade-offs occur when producing on the PPF.
To produce more of one good, you must produce less of another.
For example, if an economy is producing at point A and wants to increase the number of Good X they produce, they must give up producing some of good Y.
The PPF shows the economy working at its maximum potential.
If there are any points underneath the PPF, this means not all economic resources are being deployed.
What could cause an increase
Point A is a point outside the PPF. It is not currently possible to produce at this point.
Point B is a point on the PPF. At this point, all available factors of production are being fully used. All points along the PPF like point B are productively efficient.
Point C is inside the PPF. At this point, there are factors of production being underemployed.
Rise in price
Better technology and more efficient production
Government subsidies
Increasing productivity
The division of labour
Economies of scale
In the late 1700s, Adam Smith proved through example that division of labour could boost productivity in his book The Wealth of Nations.
He used the example of a pin factory he visited. He said 10 workers produced 48,000 pins through specialisation. But if each individual carried out every step of production themselves, they'd only make 10-20 each. So the firm avoids employing 2,400-4,800 people through division of labour.
Elasticity of Supply
Modern businesses divide their labour force.
E.g restaurant operations like Nando's divide up their labour force.
There will be a business manager to oversee the process, as well as designated cooks to make the food and sometimes waiters to serve it.
If each person does one job a lot, they are usually better at that one job than if they did four different jobs with a quarter of their time.
Economies of scale
PES = % change in quantity supplied ÷ % change in price.
So an elasticity of supply greater than one means that the percentage change in quantity supplied will be greater than a one % price change.
Specialisation through division of labour allows firms to take advantage of economies of scale. So as production increases, average unit cost decreases.
E.g if a BMW factory made 1,000 cars each year, each car would be quite expensive.
If they make 50,000 each year, then it can set up an assembly line and cost per unit will decrease.
Elastic supply, PES > 1.
So a higher PES value means more elastic supply.
Inelastic supply, 1 > PES > 0
Unit elasticity of supply, PES = 1.
Percentage change in quantity supplied = percentage change in price.
Free market
Negatives of the free market
Negatives of command economies
Command economy
This type of market allocates scarce resources based on the price mechanism.
The benefits of this:
It is efficient - only the highest value products are in demand. So firms are incentivised to produce as efficiently as they can.
It rewards entrepreneurship.
Consumers have greater choice of products because of the increased levels of innovation.
Inequitable - what is fair in the free market may not necessarily be fair in reality.
Missing markets - goods we need in society may not be produced if they cannot generate a profit.
Monopolies may arise.
Government is in charge of resource allocation. North Korea has a command economy.
This can correct the inequalities that exist in the free market.
There could also be a possible reduction in unemployment.
They can break up monopolies.
Negatives of command economies
Less efficient - the government is not a profit maximising entity. So the incentive for entrepreneurship and efficiency pushing activities is reduced.
Asymmetric information - the government may not actually know what is best because of asymmetric information.
Choice restriction.
Perishable Goods
Products that are likely to perish because of weather conditions will have a more inelastic supply.
E.g crops and agriculture.
Recessionary period
During periods of high unemployment, we tend to see a more elastic supply.
Price determination
Price mechanism
Consumer and producer surplus
Indirect taxes & subsidies
This is because if a firm tried to expand their production, they would have a larger pool of labour to hire.
Firms that are agile keep high levels of stock.
More generally, firms with agile factor mobility will be more price elastic in supply.
This makes supply price elastic as they can quickly respond to increases in demand by releasing more stock.
Equilibrium price
Disequilibrium
Excess supply and demand
Pressure to reach equilibrium
This is the only price where the amount consumers want to buy is equal to the amount producers want to sell.
If the market is at equilibrium, there is no reason to move away.
Supply and demand (market forces) dictate the equilibrium quantity and price in a free market.
Disequilibrium is when the market is not at a stable price and quantity.
If the market is not at equilibrium, economic pressure arises to move the market towards a stable price and quantity.
E.g if petrol prices were to rise above their equilibrium level, the market would respond and the quantity demanded would fall.
Producer Surplus
The supply line represents the cost of producing a good or service.
At the market price, firms who can produce the good or service at or below the market price will supply it to the market.
The sum of the extra money earned above the cost of production is the producer surplus.
Consumer Surplus
The demand line represents the value that consumers place on a particular good or service.
At the market price each consumer who values the good or service at or above that price will buy and consume it. A number of consumers value the good or service above the market price and gain utility from the good compared to keeping the money they paid for it.
The sum of all the extra benefit consumers in a market get from buying and consuming a good or service is the consumer surplus.
Total Surplus
Total surplus is the producer surplus plus the consumer surplus. Total surplus is the total benefit to society of economic agents buying and selling a particular good or service.
If the market isn't at the market clearing equilibrium there is a deadweight loss. This is because there is an extra possible benefit to society which isn't being generated due to over or under production and consumption.
Excess supply and demand occur at disequilibrium.
The higher price makes it more profitable for petrol producers, so output expands.
The difference between the quantity demanded and quantity supplied is now the excess supply.
When quantity demanded exceeds quantity supplied, there is excess demand.
The market price is unstable when there is excess demand or supply.
Excess supply will force producers to cut the price because it is better to sell at a lower price than not at all. Others will follow.
Excess demand will signal to producers they can generate more profit by raising the price and will do so.
So excess demand and supply can lead to price change.
When a tax is imposed, the producer may pass on some of this cost to the consumer in the form of a higher price (grey area on the diagram) and absorb the rest (red area).
The proportion of the tax passed onto the consumer depends on the elasticity of demand. The more inelastic the demand, the more of a tax is passed on and less 'absorbed'.
Indirect taxes generate revenues for governments. These revenues can then be spent on capital investment (e.g hospitals for the NHS) or transfer (or welfare) payments.
If demand is perfectly inelastic, the quantity consumed won't change and tax revenues will increase. However, the burden of a tax would fall completely on consumers. If this was a market made up of mainly poor consumers, then this may not be a good intervention for the government. However, this would need a value judgment.
Functions of the price mechanism
The price mechanism locally & globally
The price mechanism
The price mechanism shows how demand and supply interact.
A change in the price of a good will change the quantity demanded.
The price mechanism is free from bias because it is not governed by one human, but lots of different agents interacting.
Incentive function: rising prices encourage firms to expand their level of output because of higher profits.
Signalling function: if the price of a good changes, this signals to the consumer or producer that they should change their level of consumption or production.
Rationing function: resources are scarce. The price of a good rations that good. This limits supply to those who are willing and able to pay for it.
Impact on consumers
If demand was perfectly inelastic, then the demand curve would be vertical.
The quantity demanded would not change but the price paid would rise.
The burden of the tax would fall completely on the consumer.
If demand was perfectly elastic (horizontal demand curve), then the burden would fall completely on the producer.
Local markets: In a local marketplace for fruit, if one market stall sells apples for £20 and sells out of 1,000 apples. Then this is a signal for that firm to increase production and sell more apples. It also signals to competitors that they should start selling apples.
National markets: If Amazon lists a book at £10, but nobody buys it, then there is a signal that nobody demands that book at £10. Either people don't want the good or they are buying it elsewhere at a lower price. There is an incentive to reduce the quantity produced or to reduce the sale price.
Global markets: If the USA can produce steel for £100/ton and sells it for £1,000/ton, this is a signal to nations like China and India that they can make profits by producing steel. They have an incentive to produce steel and enter the market.
Impact on producers
If demand is elastic, then producers bear the whole burden of an indirect tax.
If demand is inelastic, then consumers bear the whole burden of an indirect tax.
Market failure
Government failure
The Externalities of Education
Externalities
Public Goods
Types of Market Failure
Information Gaps
Pollution Permits and Regulation
State Provision and Information Provision
Subsidies and Price Controls
Government Failure
Government Intervention in Markets
Market failure
Externalities are the effects that producing or consuming goods have on other third parties or society as a whole. Buyers or producers do not consider externalities when making decisions. This can lead to market failure because goods or services can be under or over consumed.
Social cohesion & cultural values
Public goods are not provided by the free market and government intervention is needed to change this missing market.
What is asymmetric information?
Market failure is when the price mechanism leads to a misallocation of resources.
Resources are misallocated when they are not devoted to the use that will give society the most welfare.
Complete and partial market failure
Complete market failure happens where, unless the good or service is provided outside the mechanism, there wouldn't be a market for it.
E.g a country's military services.
Partial market failure happens when the private sector may partially provide it but at the wrong price or quantity.
E.g private healthcare vs NHS.
Positive consumption externalities
This is a 'good' externality created in the consumption of a good.
The marginal social benefit is the total benefit of consuming a good or service to society. MSB = MPB + Externality.
If the consumption externality is positive, then the marginal social benefit is more than the marginal private benefit.
Consumers do not account for the benefit of the externality and this good will be under-consumed.
E.g. school education is a positive consumption externality because students become more productive for employers.
Negative consumption externalities
This is a 'bad' externality created in the consumption of goods/services (e.g cigarettes).
The marginal social benefit is the total benefit of consuming a good or service to society. It is equal to the marginal private benefit plus the value of the consumption externality.
If the consumption externality is negative, then the marginal social benefit is less than the marginal private benefit and the good will be overconsumed (vs the socially optimal level).
Negative production externalities
Positive production externalities
These are externalities incurred when producing a good or service.
Marginal social cost = Marginal private cost - Production externality. MSC is the total cost of producing a good or service to society.
If the production externality is positive, then the social cost is less than the private cost and the good will be underproduced.
These are externalities created when producing a good or service.
If the production externality is negative, then the social cost is greater than the private cost and the good will be overproduced (vs the socially optimal level).
E.g a factory producing noise and air pollution is likely to have a social cost larger than the private cost.
Economic growth
Crime reduction
Crime reduces other people's welfare.
Moretti's (2001) research found that people with higher levels of education were more likely to vote and less likely to be involved in crime.
Everyone in a society learning to get along with one another, mixing at school and having a shared knowledge base should have a positive impact on cohesion in a society.
Economic growth involves using the same inputs to create more or higher quality outputs. This should benefit everyone. In the UK, someone with a median income probably lives better than the Queen 100 years ago.
Krueger & Lindahl (2001) find that people receiving better education is associated with faster economic growth.
Barro & Sala-i-Martin (1995) completed statistical analysis that found that a 1% rise in spending on education as a % of GDP led to a 0.15% increase in economic growth.
Public vs private goods
Quasi-public goods
Characteristics of public goods
Public goods and market failure
Non-rivalry: if one person consumes a good this doesn't stop another person from consuming it.
E.g one person gaining benefit from a street lamp doesn't stop another person from gaining benefit from it.
Non-excludable: someone not paying for a good doesn't affect their ability to consume it.
E.g not paying for a streetlamp doesn't mean you can't see when you walk down a street at night.
Private goods exhibit both excludability and rivalry.
E.g a phone is a private good.
If I purchase a particular phone, that means someone else cannot have that phone (rivalry).
If I do not pay for the phone, I cannot have the benefits of the phone (excludable).
A public good can start to have private characteristics and become quasi-public.
E.g putting a tollbooth on a road makes it excludable, and so a quasi-public good.
The private sector rarely provides true public goods (as there is little financial incentive to).
The government must intervene and decide the suitable quantity of public goods for society. To do so, the government has to guess the marginal social benefit (which may be inaccurate).
The 'Lemons' problem
Asymmetric information can cause a decline in prices or quantity of products sold.
A situation of asymmetric information happens when both parties in a transaction have an unequal amount of information.
Consider Marvin, who is buying a used car from a dealership.
The car could either be a 'lemon', which is a defective vehicle, or a high quality vehicle. Because of asymmetric information, Marvin does not know which the car is.
This is called a misallocation of resources.
This limits his ability to make a rational choice and pay the appropriate price for the car.
The free market can result in a misallocation of resources (or market failures). Governments can intervene to correct these market failures.
Irrationality
Overconsuming demerit goods
Underconsuming merit goods
Meeting basic needs
Governments may want people to consume more things like education, which have positive externalities.
Subsidies or free state provision may be used to encourage the consumption of merit goods.
The UK government has a Nudge unit, which implies that consumers may not be rational agents and need guidance.
Demerit goods like cigarettes may be overconsumed.
Taxes or bans may be interventions to solve this issue.
In a market-based economy, a consumer's ability to consume goods and services depends on their income and wealth.
If a consumer has a low income, they may not be able to afford basic goods to satisfy their needs.
The market is under-providing these goods and this can be a source of market failure.
Governments pay producers subsidies to help keep the price of products low.
Encouraging production/consumption
Advantages of subsidies
Disadvantages of subsidies
Subsidies can correct market failure by encouraging the consumption and production of a good with positive externalities.
This is represented on the diagram by a shift to the right in supply, toward a more socially optimal level.
Subsidies can reduce the cost of a product and allow a firm to exploit economies of scale.
This will improve long-run efficiency and competitiveness abroad.
Consumer preferences may change as a result of a subsidy.
Subsidies may encourage laziness from producers because they do not need to be as efficient.
There is also an opportunity cost to a subsidy.
Elasticity of demand determines how effective a subsidy is.
Subsidised goods may be of a lower standard than alternatives they're trying to replace.
Trade pollution permits are allocated to businesses in an attempt to control pollution levels.
Disadvantages of trade pollution permits
What are permits?
benefits of trade pollution permits
This system can put a cap on the level of pollution.
The lower the pollution of a firm, the more they can benefit. This encourages firms to lower their pollution levels.
Governments make revenue.
There is a cost to implementing the scheme.
Deciding on the level of pollution is difficult.
The market for permits is subject to failure also.
Governments can set an optimal limit on pollution by allocating permits to firms.
These permits can be traded through the price mechanism.
The European Union emissions trading system (ETS) is a way to do this. EU member governments are issued with permits to allocate to firms.
The ETS annually cuts the number of permits. This incentivises firms to reduce emissions because they may be forced to buy more permits for not doing so.
The state can provide a number of goods and services for consumers. This is called state provision.
Advantages of state provision
Disadvantages of state provision
State provision
The government either provides state provisions itself (e.g. state education) or provides free goods or services to the public that it's bought from the private sector (e.g. private health services offered free to NHS patients).
The government pays for goods/services through tax revenues. It then offers them to the public for free.
Examples:
The National Health Service (NHS).
Police service.
Secondary school education.
State provision can reduce inequality by redistributing money from the wealthy to the poor. This is something the market doesn't always do.
Without state provision, some services might not exist as they aren't profitable.
E.g. some train routes that aren't profitable do not exist.
Value judgements need to be made about what the state can and can't provide well.
Without a drive for profit, there is less incentive to make a service as efficient as possible. The economic incentives for efficiency could be eroded.
There is an opportunity cost of providing one service over another.
With asymmetric information, there is a risk of government failure.
Government failure is the unintended worsening allocation of resources as a consequence of a policy the government has implemented to correct a market failure. It produces a net welfare loss.
Bureaucracy
Inadequate or imperfect information
Administrative costs
Misallocation of resources
Resources are needed to implement government intervention.
If the cost is too high, the intervention may not be worthwhile.
Daniel Kahneman's inside view explains why governments may frequently underestimate the cost of their projects. The Scottish parliament in Holyrood was forecast to cost £10-40M but cost £414M.
The private sector has the incentive to maximise profits, but individuals working for governments rarely get the benefits.
Governments are also very large and may suffer from material diseconomies of scale.
In a world of perfect information, governments should be able to make the right decisions to improve allocation.
Asymmetric information limits the governments ability to critically assess market failures and possible solutions.
So the right decision isn't always made and government failure can arise.
Government failure is the result of a policy trying to correct a market failure that has led to a misallocation of resources.
This means there is a welfare loss to society.
E.g the council might charge people for some forms of waste disposal.
This may increase fly-tipping, which is a worsening of the initial pollution externality.