Introducing Sign Language Literature, Folklore, and creativity Chapter 14
Handshape
Aesthetic Function of Handshape
Symbolic Function of Handshape: Inherent Symbolism
Symbolic Function of Handshape: Contextual Symbolism
Fiver Parameters Constitute a Sign
Handshape, location, movement, palm orientation & nonverbal elements
Any of them can be manipulated to create poetic effect in sign language literature, but of the five, manipulation of the handshape is arguably the most prominent
As Blondel & Miller put it "organizing the structure of a poem around the repetition of a single handshape seems to be the most usual, the most conscious & the most easily perceivable organizing principle"
Deaf poets often pay great attention to the choice of handshape because they are aware of its impact
Limited Number of Handshapes
Within every sign language, a limited number of handshapes combine with other parameters to create a very large number of potential signs to form the vocabulary of everyday sign language
There are 57 different handshapes listed in the Dictionary of British Sign Language, some of which have more than 100 established signs associated with them
Choice of Handshape
The choice of handshape for a sign is often visually motivated, because a particular handshape visually represents a particular concept
For example, a 'B' handshape is used in many signs to refer to a door because it is broad & flat like a door, or a '1' handshape is used as a classifier to describe a long thin object because it is long & thin like these objects
In other instances, however, the handshape of a sign has no apparent visual motivation
Repeated Use of Handshape
In different signs creates a visual resonance
Visual resonance creates harmony & rhythm among signs with aesthetic visual appeal
Several types of stories with constraints, in which handshape can be manipulated at a very conscious & deliberate level, such as ABC stories, single handshape stories & number stories
In single handshape stories the narrator is allowed to use only one handshape to tell a story. This can be a challenge, as the signer needs to produce a coherent storyline using the limited number of established signs with that particular handshape, or make use of its visual features & create new meaning
Strict Handshape Constraints
John Wilson's Home follows strict handshape oncstraints
The poem juxtaposes the fate of a Deaf schoolboy being forced to speak & that of Laika, the first dog who was sent to space in Sputnik - a symbol of sacrifice in a major scientific experiment. The story alternates scenes focusing on the boy & the dog. The scenes told from the boys perspective exclusively use handshakes 'H' & 'V' and scenes in which the dog is the focus are told using only 'B' or '5' handshapes
While these stories with constraint can be simply for linguistic challenge aesthetic function of handshape can be achieved in a more subtle way & contributes to the poetic effect
Equivalent of Rhyme in Spoken Language Poetry
The repetition of handshapes is often considered to be an equivalent of rhyme in spoken language poetry
Rhyme is a repetition of identical sounds that come at the end of different words, & can contribute to a broad range of aesthetic patterns within a poem
Individual poets may choose where & why the rhyming words occur but they frequently occur at line ends
Aesthetic Effect of Visual Resonance
Sometimes the aesthetic effect of visual resonance created by repeating the same or similar handshapes is enough to explain its role in the poem
In some carefully crafted poems, howerver, the manipulation of handshapes goes beyond simple repetition & resonance, & symbiolically represents the theme of the poem in indirect ways
There is a meaningful relationship between the form & the meaning
Poets do not choose handshapes randomly, but can carefully select the ones whose visual appearance appeals best to the impression they intend to create in the mind of the audience
Emotional Effects
Many scholars, studying different sign languages have remarked that certain emotional effects can be imposed by a particular configuration of handshape, even before it is combined with other parameters to constitute a sign
Clayton Valli (1991) refers to what he calls 'soft' & 'hard' handshapes in ASL poetry; Ulrike Zeshan (2000) in her cross-linguistic research on handshapes, finds that some handshapes, such as closed & open, constribute to different impressions
Handshape Symbolism
This association of hand configuration & meaning can be termed handshape symbolism, following the notion of sound symbolism in spoken language
Sound symbolism is the idea that although most speech sounds in words are arbitrary, some sounds are associated with certain concepts & thus appeal to the listener/reader's emotions
In many languages, words that mean 'small' or 'tiny' use closed vowels (i, e) while those that mean 'big' or 'large' tend to use more open vowels (a, o)
Associated with Certain Meanings
Contextual Symbolism
Negative Handshapes
Another poem by Wim Emmerik, Desert also makes use of negative handshapes
The signs used in this poem are very simple, but highly symoblic
A careful selection of handshapes contributes to such symbolism
The same handshape can be seen differently depending on the context in which it is produces. We can call this 'contextual symbolism' as opposed to the 'inherent symbolism' discussed
The works of the Dutch poet Wim Emmerik provide good examples to highlight the ocntextual symbolism in sign language poetry as his poems strongly associate bent handshakes with negative meaning
Individual handshapes can be associated with certain meanings through their visual appearance, such inherent symbolism of handshapes is rarely noticed in everyday signing
We speak or sign in day-to-day situations without paying attention to the potential associations between the form & meaning
We don't think about any creepy or unsettling associations with bent fingers when we sign APPLE because the handshape is motivated by the size, shape & tension of the grip needed to hold an apple. When placed in poetic context, however, the potential symbolic power of the handshape can be 'reactivated' & foregrounded or creates a new way of being symbolic