Please enable JavaScript.

Coggle requires JavaScript to display documents.

Deriving Islamic Law (Is the text authentic? (Yes (Has it been…

- - - - Yes
        
        The Command Does not Apply
      - No
        
        The Text is Mujmal/Amibiguous
        
        Are there clues to suggest which meaning is intended?
        
        Yes
        
        The suggested meaning is likely
        
        What is the mood of the word?
        
        2 more items...
        
        No
        
        Formulation of law is at a standstill (tawaqquf)
        
        The Text is Zahir/Univocal
        
        Even Zahir expressions can have multiple possible meanings, it's simply less likely for the figurative meaning to be intended
        
        Are there clues to suggest a figurative meaning?
        
        Yes
        
        The Literal Meaning is Unlikely - Tawaqquf occurs
        
        No
        
        The Literal Meaning is Likely
        
        What is the mood of the word?
        
        2 more items...
  - - - Sanad
        
        Are there any missing links?
        
        Religions of the transmitters?
        
        Maturity of the transmitters?
        
        Memory of the transmitters?
        
        Character of the transmitters?
      - Text
        
        Does it Contradict the Qur'an?
        
        Does it Contradict other Hadith?
- - - - Possible Meanings
        
        Fingertips to Shoulder
        
        Is it Univocal or Ambiguous?
        
        Univocal
        
        Are there contextual clues to signify a figurative meaning?
        
        No
        
        1 more item...
        
        Yes
        
        1 more item...
        
        Ambiguous
        
        Are there contextual clues to signify that fingertips to shoulder is intended?
        
        Yes
        
        1 more item...
        
        No
        
        1 more item...
        
        Fingertips to Wrist
        
        Is it Univocal or Ambiguous?
        
        Univocal
        
        Are there contextual clues to signify a figurative meaning?
        
        No
        
        1 more item...
        
        Yes
        
        1 more item...
        
        Ambiguous
        
        Are there contextual clues to signify that fingertips to wrist is intended?
        
        Yes
        
        1 more item...
        
        No
        
        1 more item...
        
        Fingertips to Elbow
        
        Is it Univocal or Ambiguous?
        
        Univocal
        
        Are there contextual clues to signify a figurative meaning?
        
        No
        
        1 more item...
        
        Yes
        
        1 more item...
        
        Ambiguous
        
        Are there contextual clues to signify that fingertips to elbow is intended?
        
        Yes
        
        1 more item...
        
        No
        
        1 more item...
- - - - Univocal
        
        Are there contextual clues to signify a figurative meaning?
        
        No
        
        Amputate fingertips to wrist is likely meaning
        
        iqta'u is an imperative
        
        Is the imperative univocal or ambiguous?
        
        2 more items...
        
        Yes
        
        The literal meaning is unlikely (tawaqquf)
      - Ambiguous
        
        Are there contextual clues to signify that amputate is intended?
        
        Yes
        
        Most likely meaning is amputate fingertips to wrist
        
        iqta'u is an imperative
        
        Is the imperative univocal or ambiguous?
        
        2 more items...
        
        No
        
        Formulation of law is at a standstill (tawaqquf)
  - - - Univocal
        
        Are there contextual clues to signify a figurative meaning?
        
        No
        
        Lacerate fingertips to wrist is likely meaning
        
        iqta'u is an imperative
        
        Is the imperative univocal or ambiguous?
        
        2 more items...
        
        Yes
        
        The literal meaning is unlikely (tawaqquf)
      - Ambiguous
        
        Are there contextual clues to signify
        that lacerate is intended?
        
        Yes
        
        Most likely meaning is lacerate fingertips to wrist
        
        iqta'u is an imperative
        
        Is the imperative univocal or ambiguous?
        
        2 more items...
        
        No
        
        Formulation of law is at a standstill (tawaqquf)
- - - - Univocal
        
        Are there contextual clues to signify a figurative meaning?
        
        No
        
        Amputate fingertips to wrist is likely meaning
        
        Yes
        
        The literal meaning is unlikely (tawaqquf)
      - Ambiguous
        
        Are there contextual clues to signify that amputate is intended?
        
        Yes
        
        Most likely meaning is amputate fingertips to wrist
        
        No
        
        Formulation of law is at a standstill (tawaqquf)
  - - - Univocal
        
        Are there contextual clues to signify a figurative meaning?
        
        No
        
        Lacerate fingertips to wrist is likely meaning
        
        Yes
        
        The literal meaning is unlikely (tawaqquf)
      - Ambiguous
        
        Are there contextual clues to signify
        that lacerate is intended?
        
        Yes
        
        Most likely meaning is lacerate fingertips to wrist
        
        No
        
        Formulation of law is at a standstill (tawaqquf)
- - - - Univocal
        
        Are there contextual clues to signify a figurative meaning?
        
        No
        
        Amputate fingertips to elbow is likely meaning
        
        Yes
        
        The literal meaning is unlikely (tawaqquf)
      - Ambiguous
        
        Are there contextual clues to signify that amputate is intended?
        
        Yes
        
        Most likely meaning is amputate fingertips to elbow
        
        No
        
        Formulation of law is at a standstill (tawaqquf)
  - - - Univocal
        
        Are there contextual clues to signify a figurative meaning?
        
        No
        
        Lacerate fingertips to elbow is likely meaning
        
        Yes
        
        The literal meaning is unlikely (tawaqquf)
      - Ambiguous
        
        Are there contextual clues to signify
        that lacerate is intended?
        
        Yes
        
        Most likely meaning is lacerate fingertips to elbow
        
        No
        
        Formulation of law is at a standstill (tawaqquf)
- - - - Univocal
        
        Are there contextual clues to signify a figurative meaning?
        
        No
        
        Amputate fingertips to elbow is likely meaning
        
        Yes
        
        The literal meaning is unlikely (tawaqquf)
      - Ambiguous
        
        Are there contextual clues to signify that amputate is intended?
        
        Yes
        
        Most likely meaning is amputate fingertips to elbow
        
        No
        
        Formulation of law is at a standstill (tawaqquf)
  - - - Univocal
        
        Are there contextual clues to signify a figurative meaning?
        
        No
        
        Lacerate fingertips to elbow is likely meaning
        
        Yes
        
        The literal meaning is unlikely (tawaqquf)
      - Ambiguous
        
        Are there contextual clues to signify
        that lacerate is intended?
        
        Yes
        
        Most likely meaning is lacerate fingertips to elbow
        
        No
        
        Formulation of law is at a standstill (tawaqquf)
- - - - Univocal
        
        Are there contextual clues to signify a figurative meaning?
        
        No
        
        Amputate fingertips to shoulder is likely meaning
        
        iqta'u is an imperative
        
        Is the imperative univocal or ambiguous?
        
        2 more items...
        
        Yes
        
        The literal meaning is unlikely (tawaqquf)
      - Ambiguous
        
        Are there contextual clues to signify that amputate is intended?
        
        Yes
        
        Most likely meaning is amputate fingertips to shoulder
        
        iqta'u is an imperative
        
        Is the imperative univocal or ambiguous?
        
        2 more items...
        
        No
        
        Formulation of law is at a standstill (tawaqquf)
  - - - Univocal
        
        Are there contextual clues to signify a figurative meaning?
        
        No
        
        Lacerate fingertips to shoulder is likely meaning
        
        iqta'u is an imperative
        
        Is the imperative univocal or ambiguous?
        
        2 more items...
        
        Yes
        
        The literal meaning is unlikely (tawaqquf)
      - Ambiguous
        
        Are there contextual clues to signify
        that lacerate is intended?
        
        Yes
        
        Most likely meaning is lacerate fingertips to shoulder
        
        iqta'u is an imperative
        
        Is the imperative univocal or ambiguous?
        
        2 more items...
        
        No
        
        Formulation of law is at a standstill (tawaqquf)
- - - - Univocal
        
        Are there contextual clues to signify a figurative meaning?
        
        No
        
        Amputate fingertips to shoulder is likely meaning
        
        Yes
        
        The literal meaning is unlikely (tawaqquf)
      - Ambiguous
        
        Are there contextual clues to signify that amputate is intended?
        
        Yes
        
        Most likely meaning is amputate fingertips to shoulder
        
        No
        
        Formulation of law is at a standstill (tawaqquf)
  - - - Univocal
        
        Are there contextual clues to signify a figurative meaning?
        
        No
        
        Lacerate fingertips to shoulder is likely meaning
        
        Yes
        
        The literal meaning is unlikely (tawaqquf)
      - Ambiguous
        
        Are there contextual clues to signify
        that lacerate is intended?
        
        Yes
        
        Most likely meaning is lacerate fingertips to shoulder
        
        No
        
        Formulation of law is at a standstill (tawaqquf)
- - - - Fingertips to Elbow
        
        Is it Univocal or Ambiguous?
        
        Univocal
        
        Are there contextual clues to signify a figurative meaning?
        
        No
        
        Fingertips to elbow is likely meaning
        
        1 more item...
        
        Yes
        
        The literal meaning is unlikely (tawaqquf)
        
        Ambiguous
        
        Are there contextual clues to signify that fingertips to elbow is intended?
        
        Yes
        
        Most likely meaning is fingertips to elbow
        
        1 more item...
        
        No
        
        Formulation of law is at a standstill (tawaqquf)
      - Fingertips to Shoulder
        
        Is it Univocal or Ambiguous?
        
        Univocal
        
        Are there contextual clues to signify a figurative meaning?
        
        No
        
        Fingertips to shoulder is likely meaning
        
        1 more item...
        
        Yes
        
        The literal meaning is unlikely (tawaqquf)
        
        Ambiguous
        
        Are there contextual clues to signify that fingertips to shoulder is intended?
        
        Yes
        
        Most likely meaning is fingertips to shoulder
        
        1 more item...
        
        No
        
        Formulation of law is at a standstill (tawaqquf)
      - Fingertips to Wrist
        
        Is it Univocal or Ambiguous?
        
        Ambiguous
        
        Are there contextual clues to signify that fingertips to wrist is intended?
        
        Yes
        
        Most likely meaning is fingertips to wrist
        
        1 more item...
        
        No
        
        Formulation of law is at a standstill (tawaqquf)
        
        Univocal
        
        Are there contextual clues to signify a figurative meaning?
        
        No
        
        Fingertips to wrist is likely meaning
        
        1 more item...
        
        Yes
        
        The literal meaning is unlikely (tawaqquf)