Please enable JavaScript.
Coggle requires JavaScript to display documents.
L10 Specifications : Make vs. Buy (Types of Specifications (1 Performance…
L10 Specifications : Make vs. Buy
Types of
Specifications
2 Product specification
Technical specification.
1 All the information
2 provide objective evidence to follow performance specification
Give the breath to design
technical specifications may constrain suppliers and increase lead-times
and cost (Hicks, McGovern, and Earl 2000).
產品規格
Seperate to many doc 👆
1 Performance
Functional specification
identifying customer requirements ➡️
feature/characteristics/process condition/ limit
no technical detail
Functional specifications allow suppliers to innovate and reduce costs (Hicks, McGovern, and Earl 2000).
prepare 👇/ follow 👆
效能規格
3 Process specifications
how you are going to produce the products
detailed guidance on the technical and procedural aspects of product implementation.
Broad / General nature
Product cost commitment
(McGovern and Hicks)
Market development ➡️ Conceptual design ➡️ Product design
➡️ Manufacturing ➡️ Product use
Better design at the start can prevent avoidable costs which can commit substantiak $ during manufacturing and product use stage
Automotive industry
3 Tiered suppliers
Diffierent supplier/ capability
Different
Specification
OEMs have 1st/2nd
1st tier join the design
benefit Japan's car
Product development
“Black Box” Engineering
1 Lean systems
2 Close link between buyers/suppliers
1 Repetitive buyer behavour
2 Well defined design
avoid change and cost
Engineer-to-order (ETO) companies
B 3 type(Typology) of companies
(McGovern and Hicks)
Outsource or not
C Two stages of ETO supply chain
A Tendering
initiative stage
general performance specification
B Contract execution
non physical+ physical
for supplier who are awarded
A Highly customized/ low volume
always decide specification
only after design
hard to outsource
diversed requirement
hard to modular design
A mixed specification of ETO
Performance: system suppliers
Product: items that relate to core technology
that are designed in-house
Make vs. Buy
Concern
Outsourcing
opportunity
(Hicks, McGovern, and Earl 2000).
better suppliers/ flexibility/ reduce cycle time/ quailty
problems
Lysons and Farrington, 2015
cost/overdependence/lack of flexibility/ unrealistic expectation
Core activities
Decisions
2 Tactical make/buy decisions
be review when circumstance change
(Baily et al. 2015, p.188)
3 Make-buy decisions
volume/ peak demand/ risk/ waste.cost/level of inventory...
1 Strategic make/buy decisions
what to make/ investment/
develop new products/
3 approaches
(Hibbert)
1 Operational/ cost- based
Cost saving
operational advantage
no relationship to overall strategy
2 Business
a system of continuing evaluation
multifuncional department
based on 中短期 ,可能有缺點被忽視
3 Policy
1 strategic direction of firms公司策略和科技
2 technological strength/ weakness
difficult to intergrate
4 area
Platts et al. framework (2002)
1 Technology &manufacturing process
2 Costing 3 LSCM 4 Supporting system
11 stages of sourcing
(Lysons and Farrington)
definition
broad
forum for dialogue
narrow
one-way/ written description