Tier 1
Strategies I chose for 'Failing to Turn In Work' are 'Assign a buddy or partner', 'Do Unfinished Work During Recess of Unstructured Time', and 'Color-Coded Folder'. In the 21st century, 'Collaboration' is one of the skills that is emphasized to be honed for learners. By paring students, a mentee can take her/his mentor as a model and push themselves to meet the mentor's level. For mentors, they can hone their leading skills and get confidence in themselves by taking care of their peers with responsibility. The second strategy is quite severe for middle school students, which is taking their privilege or happy time away from them. By using this strategy, they get to know the seriousness and consequence of their behavior and learn the fact they better follow the teacher's directions. With the case of students being simply clumsy, they should build a habit of organizing their stuff. By asking them to color-code their folders, it helps them where to keep and find certain handouts or materials based on the categories.
For 'Being Disruptive', I chose strategies which are 'Non-verbal cues', 'Take a break' and 'Use calm neutral tone'. Middle School Students are at the stage they just follow their emotions sometimes. Considering this, teachers should show calmness and peace when they point out students' misbehaviors not to make them take it personally. Besides, warning without taking an action first can make students feel that they are being respected by teachers as an individual.
I realized from this activity that I try to give a chance to the student first to fix their misbehavior or problems before teachers are being involved. By warning students with these strategies before start helps them out in earnest, I hope students think about what factors bother them to behave inappropriately.
Tier 2
Taking a look at the strategies I used for Tier 2, I found that I start to involve adults to solve the problems from Tier 2. For the students who keep failing to turn in work, I decided to take the strategy of 'Mentoring'. Mentor can be the student's classmates, but I meant here that mentors are who students in older grade than those support needed students or can be teachers as well. Also, since Tier 1 did not work, I thought students need personal help from one on one support using strategies like 'Behavior Contract' and 'Organizational Tools'. These two strategies would help students build their habits of organization and self-awareness skills.
For 'Being disruptive', I involved adults by using 'Behavior Intervention Plan (BIP)'. However, I still tried to deal with the problem without getting additional supports by speaking with students directly but privately in the hallway and implementing a reward system. It is the fact that middle school students are self-conscious and feel embarrassment getting assessed, especially negatively, in public. Thinking of this, the teacher should always be aware of who is around when they talk to students whatever it is light or serious topic.
Tier 3
Tier 3 is a serious stage that teachers need to request for additional help. In this stage, I chose to involve not only school-related supports but also parents and even outside of school professionals. For students who are unmotivated, disorganized and irresponsible on their tasks, they should be checked by specialists with 'Response to Intervention (RTI) or Check In Check Out (CICO) system. It can be interpreted that students have no willingness to even trying to change their misbehavior or clumsiness when they get Tier 3 intervention. So that they should be checked by specialists regularly and consistently for even small steps they have implemented.
Same for 'Being disruptive', I chose strategies involving parents and counselors. Even though students spend a long time at school with teachers, parents are the ones who know their child the best. They should be informed about their child's problems and work together with the school to help students.
I still believe that positive reinforcements and strategies should be used in Tier 3, but we also should acknowledge that being positive cannot fix some problems as well, such as students being severely disruptive and harm the community physically or mentally. Thus, I believe PBIS strategies should be the main root of dealing with students' issues, but teachers should carefully think about it when it comes to Tier 3 issues.