Please enable JavaScript.
Coggle requires JavaScript to display documents.
〔IMCMC〕G5-How to discuss a case (Rethink about case discussion (Take…
〔IMCMC〕G5-How to discuss a case
Rethink about case discussion
Case discussion
is use knowledge and intuition
to generate new knowledge
not opportunity to recite knowledge
Take responsibility for your own answer
develop an argument
be prepared to explain the argument
listen to other who disagree with you
construct meaning based on evidence
Case is a description of a situation
doesn't contain "right answer"
Don't be afraid to ask "dumb" question
The range of constructive comments is wide
lead to clarification
reveal misconception about the case
Collaboration
willingness to take risk
contribute to the understanding of a a case
learning with students
misunderstanding
Case contains right answer
case analysis is the process of finding correct answer
case discussion is for students
show they find the right answer
cases are a long word problem with answer
Discussion is competition
students prove to instructor thatthey find "right answer"
unwilling to listen to other students
comment is piercing insight
with debater's skill
In the case discussion you may face the risks
Language challenge
Cultural norms
Public consensus
Rhetorical complication
Reducing the risk
The wrong way
Canned comment
stockpile points and comments with high-impact which seems like broad coverage
great confidence to do discussion
the case points not you expect
to share your point because of frustration
everyone ignore your comment
a great comment at the wrong time is the worst thing
worst effect:own learning suffers
Speeches
preparation
choose a key issue
write out an extended comment
the moment to speak hardly ever arrives
Delay and access
entry to the discussion until feeling ease
study carefully and pay attention to others comments
find some comments that you are anticipate but also discern important issue
result
student becomes essentially invisible
other classmates feel resentfully
only believe high-quality comment with lofty standard
the longer you remain silent ,the harder it is to join conversation
the ways to solve
classmates boost her confidence
instructor jumpstart the participation
best way:solve by ourselves
The right way
Speak up early
Help you
Reduces nervousness
Assist you setting the realistic expectations
You should be brave
Why
At beginning you may have barrier that comments just be OK or worse
Overcome the barrier you can enhance the quality of your comments
Be prepared
Why
Single case has many variation.
Can't prepare for every possibility
How to prepare well
Familiar with information in the case
Draw on quantitative and qualitative evidence
Support your conclusion
Yield some understanding
Raise the salient question
How to successfully discuss
Before
Put limits on preparation
keep your life in balance
pay attention to how you analyze a case
healthy pressure makes people use the time well
Read actively
analyze efficiently
begin with an explicit process
do not ignore social's benefit
During discussion
Listening
gain knowledge
get different perspectives
help follow the flow
Be patient with yourself
listen actively
responses come to mind
raise your hand
stupid questions is usually everyone's question
start talking
mind become clear
better and better comments
spontaneous and natural humor
After
Reflect on what you learn
write down two or three takeaways(each case)
think and sift out the points
in the short term
greater clarity about the issues
in the long term
personal bible
組員
王芊云
盧雅筠
范奕媗
黃姿雅
柯瑋婷