Measuring States of Consciousness

Measurement of physiological responses

Consciousness is subjective and personal and not possible to measure directly. We need to measure the physiological changes that accompany a state of consciousness. These physiological responses are usually consistent and stable and can be recorded objectively. However, they don't really tell us much about the experiences that a person is having at that time. Also, physiological changes occur for reasons other than a change in SOC

The main physiological changes measured are: electrical activity in the brain, eyes and muscles; HR, BP and body temp; electrical conductivity of the skin

Measuring consciousness

Electro-oculograph (EOG)

Electromyograph (EMG)

Electroencephalograph (EEG)

This device detects, amplifies and records the electrical activity of the brain. This is in the form of "brainwaves". Many electrodes are placed close to the skull and measure the small electrical changes created by neurons in the brain. Different brainwave activity is associated with different levels of consciousness

Types of brainwaves

Alpha waves

Theta waves

Beta waves

Delta waves

Gamma waves

Occurs when a person is hyper alert; very high brain activity; observed during learning and memory, altruistic behaviour and simultaneous processing; can be seen when awake or asleep; can be associated with anxiety and stress if too much, or depression is too little

Can be observed when awake and alert and is the most common pattern seen during NWC; observed during conscious thought logical thinking and problem solving; too much can lead to anxiety and too little can lead to ADHD; high brain activity

Occurs during relaxed wakefulness, just prior to falling asleep or during a meditative state; associated with relaxation and calmness; too much prevents people from focusing, too little may cause insomnia

Seen during light sleep stages and also during daydreaming and deep meditation; also observed in young children and psychopaths whilst awake; too much is linked with ADHD and inattentiveness, too little with anxiety and stress; medium brain activity

Observed during very deep sleep which is restorative; characterised by very limited awareness of surroundings; seen more frequently in babies and adults with brain tumours; too much can lead to the inability to think, too little associated with poor sleep and inability to rejuvenate the body; low brain activity

Other brainwave patterns

Sleep spindle

K-complex

Sawtooth waves

Periodic bursts of rapid frequency; seen during stage 2 sleep

Sharp rise in amplitude lasting a few seconds; seen during stage 2 sleep

Random, fast waves, slightly bigger than alpha waves; similar to beat waves, but occur during REM sleep when dreaming

Detects, amplifies and records the electrical activity in the muscles that control eye movement. The changes in voltage as the muscles contract and relax is measured. The EOG is primarily used to detect rapid eye movement (REM) sleep, where high levels of electrical activity are seen

Detects amplifies and records the electrical activity of skeletal muscles (usually the ones under the chin). Muscle activity is high when we are awake, lower when asleep and almost non-existent during REM sleep

Behavioural and cognitive measurements

Subjective reporting

Speed and accuracy of cognitive tasks

We can use the speed and accuracy of completing a task as an indicator of our SOC. It is an objective measure we can compare across different states

Self-reporting

Video monitoring

Asking someone to rate their sleep last night is a subjective measure but still useful in giving and insight into a state of consciousness. Self-reports might take the form of: a questionnaire; diary entry; interview. Sleep diaries are commonly used with people experiencing sleep trouble.

Limitations of self-reporting: Forgetting to complete or forgetting details; accuracy/truthfulness of descriptions; reliable interpretation of information

Filming someone as they sleep is often used to diagnose sleep disorders. It can be done in a lab or at home, and usually involves a silent, infra-red camera. The recordings are viewed and interpreted to provide information on sleep patterns.

Limitations of sleep monitoring: Doesn't give information about what is happening inside the body; the interpretations of the footage are subjective