Please enable JavaScript.
Coggle requires JavaScript to display documents.
Constructivism (What is constructivism? (Core: social construction of…
Constructivism
What is constructivism?
Significant aspects of IR are historically and socially constructed, rather than inevitable consequences of human nature or other essential characteristics of world politics
Social forces such as ideas, knowledge, norms, and rules influence states' identities and interests and the organization of world politics
Social theory, not a substantive theory of international politics: concerned with how to conceptualize the relationship between agents and structures
-
Norms & Rules
-
Even in a world of no overarching authority, there are norms that regulate behaviour
Alexander Wendt (1992): "Anarchy is what states make of it" = different beliefs and practices will generate divergent patters and organizations of world politics
Constructivism in the ME
Encompasses a wide variety of different theories: post-colonialism, feminism, Marxism, etc. - very vague
Also encompasses reductionist explanations such as Samuel Huntington's Clash of Civilizations thesis
Fred Halliday (2005)
Cultural explanations seemed to take the ME as the exemplar of this approach - culture was deemed an all-explanatory source from which all else could be deduced
-
However, ideational approach raises some difficulties
In regard to the West/Middle East dichotomy, it would be a mistake to swap an externally imposed set of categories for one bases on simple acceptance or understanding: vantage point of regional actor might equally contain its own illusions, distortions of history and its own warped animosities towards other people in the region
-
-
Michael Barnett (1998)
-
Arab politics can be understood as a series of dialogues concerning the relationship between identities, norms and regional order
-
Maybe it is wrong to exclusively apply one IR theory to a conflict and deem this the only valid explanation
IR theories merely provide different lenses that make light of different layers that make up a conflict
One must always keep in mind that the theories and their related conclusions function merely as instruments inside the toolbox of understanding for each unique case-by-case scenario
Identity
Entity that refers to the history, common memory, territorial place and culture of a people
-
Alexander Wendt: identities express a performative and constitutive relation between the "self" and the "other"
Religion & Culture are often referred to in order to explain and/or justify political attitudes in the MENA region