Please enable JavaScript.
Coggle requires JavaScript to display documents.
SUPERNATURAL TALES (means of expression (changelings (explanations…
SUPERNATURAL TALES
means of expression
under the surface
decode legends & see themes
social issues encoded
abduction, abuse, alcoholism, etc.
subtext clear
inconvenient moral issues
Black - whispered accusations (symbols)
disciplinary messages for women & children
unacceptable behaviour in patriarchal societies
rationalisation
changelings
reading of supernatural entity
society at early stage
rationalising what can't be explained
Celtic & Germanic cultures
all over the world
changelings
context
early modern scotland (1600-1800)
infant mortality 1 in 4
significant risk to mother
Church implicates midwives
c.f. witch trials
Malleus Maleficarum (1486)
devil's plan
first ref to changelings
developments blamed on parents
thoughts/actions during pregnancy
response
explain illegitimate child/archaic perceptions of infant disability
extreme measures 2000BC
continue through Middle Ages
explanations
disabilities
hydrocephalus, cerebral palsy, cretinism, dwarfing syndrome, down's syndrome, not looking alike/parents, irritable, TB/polio, poor digestion, etc.
justification for infanticide
rationalisation of serious illness/congenital disorder
attributing change/unexpected to supernatural intervention
the fairies
robert kirk
secret commonwealth (1691)
liminal, betwixt man and angel
less constricted by space
inversion of human world
no different to that under the sea - soon will understand
examines armour, religion, etc.
ideas correspond with witch trials
open and free collaboration
enabled by technology
part of God's creation
in a much more sympathetic light
characteristics
appearance
4ft tall & dressed in green
small, human sized, large
physical defects
one nostril, one eye, long breasts, webbed feet
fairy knoll
fairy gifts
could help, sometimes expected to repay
could kill or cripple
fairy touch inflicts injury
wear out humans/animals
same activity, time passes slowly
carding, weaving, food and drink
fairy lovers
gender differences
female - abandonment anxiety
men - tendency to leave them with a child
male - kidnap human lovers
Speyside tale
two wives - his or the community's?
changelings
characteristics
fairies attracted to newborns
steal & leave changeling in their place
most common 'fairy' tale
withered old man/woman
act out of character for newborn
dancing, drinking, cursing, biting
cures
left out overnight, heat, drowning/killing
causation
thoughts of mother during pregnancy
breaking of taboo
supernatural intervention
divine
hybridity, human/animal, small, unusual features, slowness all accounted for