Findings #4

Kreager

Potential Threats to Homeschooling

The United Nations Convention on the Right of the Child

“All 50 states currently protect homeschooling in some respect or another. However, several parent and interest groups in the homeschooling field express concern that the comfortable position they enjoy may be in jeopardy. For example, a 2006 European Court of Human Rights decision upheld Germany’s ban on homeschooling, troubling homeschooling advocates who fear the decision might pave the way for a homeschooling ban in the United States.”

Increases in Regulation

Although these advocates do not seek to ban homeschooling altogether, they insist on strict regulation of homeschooling. Within the category of increased regulation, compulsory attendance statutes particularly concern homeschooling advocates

Introduction

The Development of Homeschooling in America

“In the years following the adoption of the Constitution, people viewed homeschooling as a parental right and responsibility.” (Kreager, 2010, p.228)

“By requiring children to attend public schools, compulsory attendance laws allowed public education advocates to flout the traditional parental right to determine the appropriate education for children.” (Kreager, 2010, p.229)

Current Homeschooling Environment

Regulaion of Homeschooling Through the Use of Private School Laws

"States using these laws regulate homeschooling as an arm of the private school system." (Kreager, 2010, p. 234)

A Proposal for More Effective Homeschooling Legislation

Regulation of Homeschooling Through Homeschooling Statues

“This type of regulation explicitly addresses homeschooling, which is the primary difference between this category of regulation and the other two categories.” (Kreager, 2010, p. 240)

Pennsylvania

“The first option utilizes Pennsylvania’s homeschooling statute, which allows parents to homeschool their children so long as they meet numerous requirements.” (Kreager, 2010, p. 244)

Ohio

"In Ohio, where the state's Supreme Court classified homeschooling as a fundamental right, children may receive home education "by a person qualified to teach the branches in which instruction is required." Additionally, parents wish to home school their children; assurance that parents will teach certain subjects; an outline of the intended curriculum and assurance of the parents qualifications to teach the children." (Kreager 2010 p.240)

Michigan

“Michigan’s Parental Rights Act further bolsters a parent’s right to homeschool in Michigan. This Act classifies a parent’s right to control the education of his or her children as a “natural, fundamental right.”” (Kreager, 2010, p. 242)

“Michigan law leaves a parent’s right to homeschool largely unrestricted.171 Parents do not need to notify or seek approval from the school district.172 Further, standardized testing requirements do not apply.173 Finally, parents do not need teacher qualifications prior to homeschooling their children.174 In fact, the Michigan Supreme Court held in People v. DeJonge that teacher qualifications are unconstitutional when they interfere with a parent’s free exercise clause rights (Kreager 241)”.

Iowa

“In Iowa, homeschooling is legal so long as the parent or legal guardian provides “competent private instruction.”185 Three aspects apply to the statutory definition of competent private instruction.186 First, parents must provide instruction on a daily basis.187 Second, children must receive at least 148 days of instruction per year, with at least 37 days of instruction provided each quarter.188 Third, the instruction’s design must result in the student making “adequate progress.” (Kreager 242)”.

“In addition to the requirement that parents provide competent private instruction, only a licensed instructor190 or the child’s parent or guardian may provide instruction under Iowa’s homeschool statute.191 Parents must meet three requirements if they wish to instruct the child.192 First, parents must provide a detailed report for the local school district that includes an outline of course study, the child’s immunization records and blood lead test results, and a list of textbooks that are used.193 Second, parents must evaluate the child annually to determine the child’s academic progress.194 Finally, the parents must report to the local school district the results of the child’s annual performance review no later than June 30 of each school year (Kreager 243)”.

Regulation of Homeschooling Through the Use of Equivalency Laws

Connecticut

“Teacher qualification requirements or standardized test requirements do not apply under Connecticut law. In addition, Connecticut law does not require parents to notify school officials of their intent to homeschool.”

“[E]ach parent or other person having control of a child five years of age and over and under eighteen years of age shall cause such child to attend a public school regularly during the hours and terms the public school in the district in which such child resides is in session, unless such child is a high school graduate or the parent or person having control of such child is able to show that the child is elsewhere receiving equivalent instruction in the studies taught in the public schools (Kreager 237)”.

Massachusetts

“Like Connecticut, Massachusetts utilizes equivalency laws to regulate homeschooling.134 Parents wishing to homeschool their children in Massachusetts must obtain approval from the local school superintendent or school committee (Kreager 238)”.

New Jersey

“Every parent, guardian or other person having custody and control of a child between the ages of six and [sixteen] years shall cause such child regularly to attend the public schools of the district or a day school in which there is given instruction equivalent to that provided in the public schools for children of similar grades and attainments or to receive equivalent instruction elsewhere than at school (Kreager 239-240)”.

“The New Jersey courts have stated that “parents do have a constitutional right to choose the type and character of education they feel is best suited for their children, be it secular or sectarian.””

Conclusion

“Although regulated in various ways, homeschooling is currently legal in all 50 states”

Ficarra, "Comparative International Approaches to Better Understanding and Supporting Refugee Learners"

Interventions for Meeting the Needs of Refugee Students in Comparative Perspective

• “We see that refugees have all different kinds of educational experiences prior to arriving in their resettlement country. Some have had formal education in their home country that has been interrupted; others were born in refugee camps and had limited access to education based on ethnic or religious identity” (Ficarra, 2017, pg. 77).

o “What then could in-service teachers and schools be doing to both meet the unique needs of refugee students while at the same time mitigating the negative impact of the exclusion inherent in ‘special refugee programming’ which can end up making students feel isolated racially and culturally?” (Ficarra, 2017, pg. 87).

Teacher Training

• “However, other work suggests that in-classroom learning is not enough, but rather that pre-service teachers should participate in service learning in refugee communities during their preparation programming, giving them an opportunity to learn from refugees themselves” (Ficarra, 2017, pg.80).

Resettlement, Rationalization, and Gendered Expectations in Comparative Perspective

“While most of the world’s refugees are currently living in the Global South—in countries where they originally sought asylum, many will eventually be permanently resettled in the so called Global North. The United States is the top resettlement destination, with Australia and Canada also providing a number of placements. Researchers in all three national contexts have documented the particular struggles faced by refugee students in particular as well as the prejudice and discrimination that they face. Yet, little work has been done to bring these perspectives into conversations with each other in hopes of policy transfer, or knowledge transfer particularly for teacher educators” (Ficarra, 76).

Directions for Further Research and Synthesis

“More should be done to bring research from across national contexts into conversations with each other, and further, more work should be done to bring non-Western voices in to research and practice” (Ficarra,2017, pg.83).

“Much of the research on meeting the educational need of refugee students is concentrated in the areas of multicultural inclusion, ESL teaching and learning, as well as in preparing teachers for diverse learners. There is less research on some of the themes that this review attempts to bring to the fore, namely; the comparative schooling experiences of refugee students before resettlement and the racialization of refugee students upon arrival and how this impacts them as students and as member of society” (Ficarra, 82).

Refugees Volatile Educational Experience in Camps Prior to Resettlement

“Despite the terms of the 1951 United Nations Convention which states that refugee children should be accorded “the same treatment as is accorded to nationals with respect to elementary education”, most countries which host refugees in camps have difficulties living up to this standard - primarily due to funding restraints but also due to the liminal status of refugees within their borders” (Ficarra, 75).

“Bush and Salterelli suggest the goal of education in refugee camps should specifically focus on pacifying the impact of conflict, nurturing and sustaining an ethnically tolerant climate, and cultivating inclusive citizenship. However, they state that in the case of large, fast, influxes of refugees to camps, this type of education rarely happens” (Ficarra, 75)

Introduction

"our responsibility as humans and particularly as teacher educators extends beyond the adrenaline induced drama of sharing news stories on social media or even donating money to organizations that support refugees" (Ficarra, 73-74).

Keegan, "Belonging, Place, and Identity: The Role of Social Trust in Developing the Civic Capacities of Transnational Dominican Youth"

Introduction

“In New York City, a place with a long and rich history of migration, an estimated 77,000 public school students are foreign-born. More than 40% of all students speak a language other than English at home, a plurality of whom are Dominican (NYC Department of Education, 2013)” (Keegan,2017, pg.203).

Literature Review

“Given current rates of global migration, it is imperative that civic education of transnational youth takes into consideration how different affiliations and scales of belonging inform their emerging civic identities” (Keegan,2017, pg.204).

Theoretical Framework

“Civic identity is derived from a sense of belonging to a particular place, space, or geographic territory (Mitchell & Elwood, 2012; Sánchez & Machado-Casas, 2009). Current research on citizenship education in schools focuses on the teaching of particular skills necessary for political engagement or the kinds of citizens needed in a diverse society (Westheimer and Kahne, 2007)” (Keegan,2017, pg.206).

Findings

“Another way that transnational family ties contributed to the civic identities of these youth, was through their desire to fulfill a civic obligation to family and community in their home country.” (Keegan, 2017, p. 216)

“Another way that transnational family ties contributed to the civic identities of these youth, was through their desire to fulfill a civic obligation to family and community in their home country.” (Keegan, 2017, p. 216)

Methodology

“A purposeful sample (Bogdan & Biklen, 2007) of five Dominican youth aged 17– 21 years old was selected to participate. With help from the assistant principal at the school, efforts were made to recruit a diversity of participants based on gender, English language ability, socioeconomic status, migration history, and family arrangements” (Keegan, 2017, p. 208)

Data Analysis

“In order to learn about the civic identities of my participants, my analysis of the photos focused on what they revealed about the subjectivity of the photographers, who they were, and what mattered to them (Yates, 2010).” (Keegan, 2017, p. 210)

Researcher Positionality

“As a European-American, White, male, monolingual English speaker, my positionality affected the research in a number of ways” (Keegan,2017, pg.210).

“In addition to being a monolingual English speaker, my racial identity as White may have contributed to additional power imbalances. The subject of race was notably absent in the interviews, something that surprised me, since other studies have found that Dominican migrant youth undergo complex racial identity constructions after arriving in the U.S.” (Keegan,2017, pg.210).

Conclusion

“Making the most of educational opportunities in the U.S. was not an individualistic goal, but rather a collective endeavor, that included working with their peers and teachers as part of a supportive community, creating social capital.” (Keegan, 2017, p. 218)

“As Americans, we must examine these threats to homeschooling, especially since our nation embraces diversity. If we are to pride ourselves on diversity, we should fight for educational diversity.” (Kreager, 2010, p. 246)

Spoto

• “In recent years, the concept of intersectionality has taken center stage and become a dominant model with which to engage in how differences such as “race,” gender, class, sexuality, age, disability, and religion interweave and intersect upon individual lives in a modern “risk” society. Intersectionality has become a model upon which to understand, analyse and engage with difference in which difference itself becomes a defining feature of “otherness.” Otherness is related to the notion that identity itself is fragmented, fragile even, yet constantly evolving through multiple engagements and relationships in society; and through this complexity, intersectionality helps us to engage with understanding outsiders and what it means to be a “stranger” in modern society. (2012, 1).” (Holowchk, 2010, p.79)

Education is an Intersectional Issue

"Instead of turning towards a presumed neutral category in order to understand and analyze people’s experiences (usually the white heterosexual first-world male perspective), intersectionality recognizes a plurality of perspectives, which can be drawn upon to create a more nuanced and complex understanding of history and events” (Spoto, 2014/2015, 80).

"To move towards intersectional education is to understand that the Western canon is set up in support of this “neutral” category and acts as reinforcement for what bell hooks calls the “white supremacist capitalist patriarchy” (1997, 7) and what Omolade names as the “Western intellectual tradition of exclusivity and chauvinism” (1987, 32)” (Spoto, 2014/2015, 80-81).

"Instead of turning towards a presumed neutral category in order to understand and analyze people’s experiences (usually the white heterosexual first-world male perspective), intersectionality recognizes a plurality of perspectives, which can be drawn upon to create a more nuanced and complex understanding of history and events” (Spoto, 2014/2015, 80).

Imagining Anarchist Educations

"When attempting to envision the possibilities for an education that lives up to the standards of an almost impossible ideal, most anarchist theorists advocate a questioning of the very nature and purpose of education to begin with” (Spoto, 2014/2015, 88).

"Like Rouhani and countless others who have been influenced by anarchist pedagogies, I work to not only bring anarchist theories into my classrooms but to apply the very method of my “teaching” to the aim of removing the authority of the instructor and creating a sense of empowerment as I encourage my students to take control and responsibility over their own learning” (Spoto, 2014/2015, 89).

The School-to-Prison Pipeline

• “Children of color, children who are immigrants, and children who are poor are more likely to be denied access to alternative resources 82 Journal of Feminist Scholarship 7/8 (Fall 2014/Spring 2015) and recommended for or forced into detention (Faruqee 2013, 1); once there, they lose educational and employment opportunities as well as the support of their family and community, a network which is then replaced by the trauma of child detention. A recent study has suggested that perhaps over 90 percent of children in detention experience trauma that could lead to PTSD (Abram et al. 2004, 403–10).” ( Holowchk, 2010, p.80,81)

"Children of color, children who are immigrants, and children who are poor are more likely to be denied access to alternative resources and recommended for or forced into detention (Faruqee 2013, 1); once there, they lose educational and employment opportunities as well as the support of their family and community, a network which is then replaced by the trauma of child detention” (Spoto, 2014/2015, 81-82).

"These institutionalized hierarchies within education facilitate the exploitation of poor migrant families, whose children are less likely to be given a high-quality education and more likely to be recommended for child detention, and then eventually sent to jail or prison. The education system has become perhaps the greatest site for the reinforcement of hierarchies and oppression, and so must become a primary site of our struggle” (Spoto, 2014/2015, 82-83).

click to edit

Theory/Practice - Classroom/Society: Educating Towards Revolution

we cannot be part of shifts towards equality and liberation without adopting a holistic approach to revolutionary social theory- it must inform our teaching materials, our teaching methods, our place in the classroom and our place in society (Spoto, 2015, p. 88).

Classrooms as Sites of Struggle

"While noting that the classroom is only one of many sites for struggles—the educators must take their fight to the streets as well—it is our focus in the classroom that constructs our education practice as either emancipatory or simply a tool that reinforces the “white supremacist capitalist patriarchy” and becomes coopted, serving merely to strengthen hierarchies and state power” (Spoto, 2014/2015, 84).

• “I wonder if I am “doing something different in my classroom or just reinforcing and reproducing state and corporate interests” (Haworth 2012, 1). And as I move towards anarchist models of pedagogy, I wonder if my efforts to abolish hierarchies within a state institution are being coopted by those structural hierarchies themselves, reinforcing them by offering the illusion of intellectual and, therefore, personal freedom.” (Holowchk, 2010, p. 83)

Dismantling Power and Teaching Against Hierarchies

• “When considering methodologies, it is a hindrance to the evolution of science and to revolutions to have anything but an open and nondogmatic approach to any potential theory; a determined fixation on any one theory or methodology as a universal truth or fixed set of rules, Feyerabend believed, was not only unrealistic but also detrimental to scientific development itself.” (Holowchk, 2010, p. 85)

Rather than adhering to an educational model that presents students as blank slates upon which the teacher can encode knowledge, in Rancière’s model the teacher enters into a dialogic relationship with the students, and instead of merely striving to create an impression of the teacher onto the student, the teacher, as Myles Horton and Paulo Freire say, becomes a tool which the students can use in their own curiosity and exploration” (Spoto, 2014/2015, 86).

"Removing the authority of the teacher from the classroom is an important part of radical education models for Rancière and Freire, and indeed the current system of hierarchy in the classroom is merely a result of the way that oppressive power relationships perpetuate themselves” (Spoto, 2014/2015, 86).

“In our classrooms, we must not only offer antiracist and feminist materials but also model our teaching according to those practices. Furthermore, once we leave the classroom, our dedication to radical social change should not remain amongst the desks and chalkboards—our struggles in the classrooms must also be paired with our struggles on the streets” (Spoto, 2014/2015, 79).

Holowchak

Anarchy in Education

• Anarchy in Education

• “It is a needed companion to and a check of centralized industrialism and technological movement in democracies.” (Holowchak, 2010, p.220)

• “Goodman believed that spontaneity and connection were the warp and woof of a sound education. Following Dewey,5 Goodman maintained humans were naturally curious and, thus, much education occurs on its own – independent of the Ethics and Education 221 educational institutions. Goodman writes, ‘Dewey’s maxim is a good one: there is no need to bother about curriculum, for whatever a child turns to is potentially educative and, with good management, one thing leads to another’ (Goodman 1970, 104).” (Holowchk, 2010, p.222)

• “Jefferson taught us, Goodman states, that the nature of man is not fixed, but capable of significant improvement and that it is the nature of each successive generation to advance on the knowledge of prior generations. For that, there can be no ‘rules and policing’ for students and faculty. Instead, students ought to be encouraged to be self-sufficient.” (Holowchk, 2010, p.220)

Capitalism and Conformity

“The key difficulties are centralized industrialism and technological advance, which function to estrange people and strip them of their individuality by brainwashing them and making them idle, frivolous consumers (Goodman 1964, 61). Centralized industrialism is not due to failure of liberal ideals, Goodman adds in Growing up absurd. Liberalism has succeeded remarkably well in shaking off governmental controls on enterprise, but it has failed in the aim of distributing wealth evenly or fairly through free markets and honest informed choice” (Holowchak, 2010, pg. 218).

• “Goodman believed that spontaneity and connection were the warp and woof of a sound education. Following Dewey,5 Goodman maintained humans were naturally curious and, thus, much education occurs on its own – independent of the Ethics and Education 221 educational institutions. Goodman writes, ‘Dewey’s maxim is a good one: there is no need to bother about curriculum, for whatever a child turns to is potentially educative and, with good management, one thing leads to another’ (Goodman 1970, 104).” (Holowchk, 2010, p.222)

Education as apprenticeship

“Overall, Goodman maintained that effective education was apprenticeship and apprenticeship was a matter of aiding students to perceive and navigate through meaningful life experiences, not through perfunctory and vapid lecture sessions. Effective education is limited by improper teaching of philosophy, literature, and history, which constantly recognize humans for what they appear to be, instead of recognizing them for what they might be (Goodman 1962, 252)” (Holowchak, 2010, pg. 223).

“Fourth, there is Goodman’s notion of education as apprenticeship. Skill and expertize are established by apprenticeship with a fully capable teacher in the role of a life craftsperson” (Hollowchak, 2010, pg. 226).

“That is a reasonable claim, so long as one does not take Goodman to be saying that all education has to be apprenticeship, for certain disciplines (e.g., chemistry and archeology) lend themselves to apprenticeship more readily than others (e.g., logic, math, and languages)” (Hollowchak, 2010, pg. 226).

“Overall, progressive education is essentially a political movement. Fueled by the energy of youth protest, it aims ‘to liberate what has been distorted or repressed in children growing up’ and this liberation is essentially part of a revolutionary political movement to be carried out by disenchanted youth” (Hollowchak, 2010, pg. 224).

Spontaneity and connection

“Goodman believed that spontaneity and connection were the warp and woof of a sound education. Following Dewey,5 Goodman maintained humans were naturally curious and, thus, much education occurs on its own – independent of the educational institutions. Goodman writes, ‘Dewey’s maxim is a good one: there is no need to bother about curriculum, for whatever a child turns to is potentially educative and, with good management, one thing leads to another’ (Goodman 1970, 104)” (Holowchak, 2010, pg. 222).

“The key, thus, is to spark spontaneity, while helping students to establish connections with not only the past but also the present and future. To establish connections with the present and future, Goodman maintains that educative activities must free human imagination to help students actively explore a situation and to imagine it other than it is” (Holowchak, 2010, pg. 222).

• “The United States is undergoing a political crisis, Goodman says at the end of his introduction to Compulsory mis-education: Though the forms of democracy are intact, the content is vanishing.... [T]here is a proliferation of media communication and messages communicated... yet, partly because of communications, there is brainwashing and conformity.... It is essential to find alternative ways of educating.” (Holowchak, 2010, p.217)

• “If education is to be liberal in the Jeffersonian sense, and Goodman is a Jeffersonian, it ought to promote individuation and uphold individuals’ rights, while cultivating political engagement.” (Holowck, 2010, p.219)

Being ‘swamped by presentness’

“‘The argument of this book’, Goodman writes in Compulsory mis-education, ‘is that every child must be educated to the fullest extent, brought up to be useful to society and to fulfill his own best powers’. For the majority of the young, the proper education is not a matter of penning up them in schools during adolescence and early adulthood (Goodman 1964, 139–40)” (Holowchak, 2010, pg. 219).

“That functions mostly to get young people out of the way. For fulfillment to occur, there is need of some amount of compulsory miseducation – i.e., of breaking the bromidic molds of traditional education” (Holowchak, 2010, pg. 219).

Findings #4: Atypical Schooling: Online Schooling

Renzulli

Triad Model

“In order to understand the qualitative differences in learning guided by the Enrichment Triad Model it is necessary to review briefly the pedagogy or learning theory upon which Triad is based.” (Renzulli, 2019, pg 22)

Type 1 Enrichment

Expose students to different disciplines,topics, people and events

Type 3 Enrichment

students pursue a specific area and are willing to take advanced courses and take extra time to push towards this goal

Type 2 Enrichment

materials and methods to promote the development of thinking and feeling processes

"The SEM also includes a continuum of service concept that includes seperate organizational approaches (e.g. special classes, pull-out programs, grade skipping, and differentiation in the regular classroom), which overcomes the 'one best way' to develop high levels of talent in young people" (Renzulli, 2012, p. 20).

The Schoolwide Enrichment Model (SEM) is the organizational framework of our programming model

Inductive vs Deductive

Inductive Learning is where the student learns from Outside the formal Classroom

" inductive learning, on the other hand, focuses on the present use of content and processes as a way of integrating material and thinking skills into the more enduring structures of the learner's repertoire" (Renzulli, 2012,p. 23).

Deductive Learning is where the student is learning inside the formal classroom

Thompson

Khan Academy

“Khan Academy is an educational website that, as its tagline puts it, aims to let anyone “learn almost anything—for free.” Students, or anyone interested enough to surf by, can watch some 2,400 videos in which the site’s founder, Salman Khan, chattily discusses principles of math, science, and economics (with a smattering of social science topics thrown in).” (Thompson, 2019, pg 2)

"Khan academy is a great tool if used responsibly" Zach

Positives

Students who are using Khan are able to learn and tackle difficult topics.

"Khan is clearly helping students master difficult and vital subjects." (Thompson, 2011, p.3)

"For years teachers like Thordarson have complained about the frustrations of teaching to the "middle" of the class." (Thompson, 2011, p.3)

Negatives

What methods are teachers using inorder to ensure that students aren't going to far ahead with such a great tool!

“Since the rise of personal computers in the early ’80s, educators have hoped that technology could solve this problem by offering lessons tailored to each kid. Schools have blown millions, maybe billions, of dollars on sophisticated classroom technology, but the effort has been in vain.” (Thompson, 2019, pg 3)

“Not all educators are enamored with Khan and his site. Gary Stager, a longtime educational consultant and advocate of laptops in classrooms, thinks Khan Academy isn’t innovative at all." (Thompson, 2019, pg 8)

" Carpenter, who attends Santa Rita Elementary, a public school in Los, Altos California, shouldnt be doing work anywhere near this advanced" (Thompson,2011,p.2).