The Restoration of Papal Authority 1553-1558

Mary's accession, aims and opposition

obstacles to the restoration of the catholic church

The royal supremacy and problems with her first parliament

the issue of the Spanish marriage

The restoration of papal authority

the limits of the restoration

The second parliament and the Restoration of Papal authority and Catholic doctrine

Mary as a reformer

Persecution and reform

reasons for, extent of and repercussions of the persecution of Protestants

Mary, Pole and the attempt to reform Catholicism

Opposition and conformity

the war with France and the loss of Calais

Wyatt and other opposition to changes

support for the changes and the extent of conformity

Henry hadn't wanted her succession

First female monarch since 12th century (one before had gone badly + Henry scared about this

Had reformed the church to avoid her succession

she wanted reverse changes + return to Rome but wouldn't do this without parliamentary support

Privy Council

Had overcome northumberland in only successful rebellion in Tudor era

Had quite broad and inclusive privy council

had those who supported her: Stephen Gardiner = Lord Chancellor

also had Edward's previous advisers e.g. William Paget

reformers such as JOhn latimer, Hooper, Cranmer were arested b/c had been implicated in plot to make Mary Queen

Norfolk released from prison where he had been for 6 years

Privy Chamber consisted of women = affecting what advice she got

called five parliaments during her reign

very ambitious legislative programme

There was a lot of disagreement over religious reform = conflict in house of lords b/c gardiner and William Paget were in House of lords (both had different opinions)

there was resistance to religious policy in House of Commons when she tried to reinstate bishopric of Durham which had been surpressed by Edward

First parliament

restored service in use at Henry's death

repealed religious legislation of Edward's reign w/ exception of Chantries act

didn't reinstate old heresy laws b/c riots following Somerset's repeal of Act of 6 articles

property was a big issue

beneficiaries of property seized in Henry's reign was nobles sitting in House of Lords + gentry sitting in COmmons

They didn't want it returned to rome which might have been requirement of Pope

Why she wanted marriage

knew that she would need heir to protect england going back to Protestantism under Elizabeth

Was 37 so time running out

Third Act of succession in 1543 required any marriage of Mary to ahve agreement of Privy Council

Possible suitors

Edward Courtenay

Gardiner wanted to oppose Mary's plans to marry Philip of SPain so promoted Courtenay

Personally unsuitable b/c had spent life in prison since 12 so had no social graces

marriage to noble could be divisive

Philip of Spain

when mary died England could just become province of larger empire

Philip was catholic + spanish (mary was 1/2 spanish)

Antwerp (major trading partner) was part of Habsburg's territories

had been recently widowed + already had heir = more attractive to Mary

Privy council didn't want England to be involved in Hapsburg-Valois hositlities

didn't find possible marraige as attractive as mary tho

Proposal was made 10 October 1553 and Mary accepted by end of the month

little formal discussion about it in Privy council

Privy council

officially informed of marriage at start of November (after Mary had already accepted)

some, like Paget supported but Gardiner still tried to push for Courtenay

Deputation of privy council tried to urge her to rethink but she dismissed them

Terms of the Marriage

worked on by Mary, Paget, Gardiner and Renard

Philip to be joint sovereign but no foreigner's to hold office

If no heir, crown would go to Elizabeth

England wouldn't be involved in Philip's wars against its will

Needed to gain popular support b/c lots of xenophobia in commons

concern that authority of ENgland would go to Spanish King

Terms announcedin Jan 1554: Wyatt's rebellion

People were now used to The way things were in the Church

Ceremonious look of churches destroyed under Edward's reign

Protestantism encouraged discussion but catholicism encouraged obedience

The second parliament

Called in April 1554

Used by Gardiner

wanted to have religious policy that would bring England back to rome

Passed number of bills

9 April: bill to revives statutes against lollards + heretics

Revive act of 6 articles

restricting eating of meat on holy days

prevented pope from reclaiming abbey lands

all passed by may 1 in commons

only restoration of Bishopric of Durham passed in House of Lords

Parliament was stopped + Paget fell (opposed Gardiner)

Members of house of lords benefited from acquisition of porperty + returning of land claimed by papacy as first stage of return to rome

Restoration of papal authority and Catholic doctrine

Philip pressured for quick return to rome b/c didn't want to be king of schismatic country

Pope Julius wanted Reginald Pole to b papal legate + he arrived in England November 1554 and called 3rd parliament

Third parliament 1554-5

Statute of Repeal

restored religious legislation to that of 1529

didn't restore monastic land (this didn't pass through parliament)

ended Royal Supremacy + england returned to Papal Authority

Mary still recognised authority of Parliament over matters of religion which had been established by reformation parliament

Pope no longer had sole authority

The Restoration of Catholic Doctrine

Laity didn't oppose changes

realised she needed to work w/ smaller group of advisors after dispute surrounding her marriage = Paget Petre and Paulet were key councillors

Financial reform

Edward's policy had caused problems

Selling of Crown lands = less income to Crown

Debasing of coinage = inflation

still debased coins in circulation despite Northumberland's efforst

Plans for recoinage but not done b/c of harvest failure in 1556-7

only put in place in 1160 (during Elizabethan reign)

Mary's actions

surveyed crown lands

revaluated + brought up rent = higher income

Increased custom rates for first time since 1507

brought in extra £29,000 in 1558

Elizabeth benefitted more from this than Mary

Changed bolt-on offices

e.g court of augmentations

streamlined finaincal administrations

meant less departments received money

treasure given responsibility for 75% rather than 30% of crown's income

Reform of armed forces

problems

wars w/ France and Scotland had cost a lot and not produced benefits

Army still relied on Nobility

elsewhere in Europe, Spain + France, had more professional armies w/ better supplies

Act for the Taking of Musters in 1558

transferred responsibility for raising, training + equipping armies to shires

meant each group in each county had to supply men, horses + weapons

Weapons act specified what weapons were allowed for each rank in society

Modernisation of Weapons + stricter controls on absence + desertion transformed army

Navy

established by Henry VII and developed by Henry VIII

suffered erosion of strength after war against France

sinking of flagship Mary Rose in Portsmouth harbour

Mary paid for construction of 6 ships + repair of many more

contributed to win against spanish armada

obstacles

ppl still wanted to be Protestant = fled the country

bishops deprived + replaced w/ catholci ones

wouldn't tolerate married clergy

800 parish clergy deprived of living

restoration of heresy laws prevented this

1557 Arhcdeacon Nicholas Harpsfield surveyed Kent

supporter of Wyatt rebellion

Area where Edward's regime had had greatest impact

lots of burnings took place in Kent

almost all parishes in Kent had minimum equipment including stone High altar, Rood screen w/ carved figures + 2 sets of vestments

shows that there was overwhelming consent to Marian reforms in Kent

Heresy

although many did recant and return to catholicism

Mary's early death = religious foundations weren't built on

didn't have enough time to reverse fully destruction of Catholic church

Reasons

Act of 6 Articles in 1539 had made denying transubstantiation punishiable by death by burning

enhanced consequences for individual of denying teachings of Catholic faith = fires they would experience would be nothing compared to those in eternal hell

propaganda of getting former bishops to re-cant

Trying to save their souls?

Forcing hand of bishops = saving their souls and those who follow them

Could be propaganda to show that bishops were insincere and self seeking

people denounced others who had destroyed church images in Edward's reign b/c had vendetta against them

Extent

285 died between 1555 and 1558

burnt Cranmer, Latimer and Ridley

Lots chose exile over being burnt

further 30 died in prison

A lot of people were freed + given opportunity to reform their faith only to be arrested again and executed

Sometimes those executed sent around the country so they could be an example to others (many lost on the way)

It was an event = lots attended

Priest converted heretics to Catholicism before burnings

Cranmer

Mary saw propaganda potential in burning Cranmer

helped protestant cause b/c he denied Catholicism and put the hand that had signed the recantation into the fire first

Cranmer burned for heresy (even though reason why he was arreseted was for support of Lady Jane Grey) + Mary held him responsible for break w/ rome

Latimer and Ridley in October 1555

Latimer argued that docrines of presence of Christ in transubstantiation were unbiblical

Impact

400 key protestants sought exile, mainly in Geneva (ppl who had connections and could afford to do so)

some say communities didn't want to hand ppl over = not much impact

Others say that the burnings happened as a result of ppl snitching b/c they were alarmed at extent of protestant reform during Edward's reign

Peaked in 1557 and then decreased

successful

protestant church had been deprived of leading churchmen

laity wouldn't risk resitance w/o leadership

use of printing press

Some argued it failed

pole underestimated extent to which laity needed to be re-energised about Catholicism

didn't use printing press like Protestants

"A profitable and necessary doctrine" by Bonner

reworked King's Book (Henry VIII)

Included 14 homilies teaching basic catholic doctrine e.g. justification, transubstantiation

Pole was against indiscriminate reading of Bible by the Clergy

Primers

books which explained basic catholic blief in response for demand from laity for instruction in Catholic belief

35 editions of Sarum Primer + 4 editions of York primer VS 17 between 1547 and 1543

believed that it lead to religious argument that was damaging to faith

Did not try to go back to Catholicism of the past

established distinctive identity through using academics to create catholic tradition

a lot based on humanistic tradition e.g. insitstence on scripture, the need for educated clergy + development of inner piety

didn't talk about pilgrimages, saints

influence of Catherine Parr and educational experience formed this view

Pope Julius died in 1555 and replaced by Pope Paul IV

new pope hated Pole + Hapsburgs

this made relations between crown and Role impossible

stripped pole of his title of Papal legate

called him to rome but Pole refused to go + stayed in Englad

w/o support of Rome, couldn't install bishops = when Mary died, there were 7 dioceses vacant

Wyatt's rebellion: 1554

Reason

reacted to Mary's engagement to Philip of Spain

Wasn't focused on religion

needed to gain support from both religiouns e.g. Gardiner

challenging monarchy = treason so couldn't focus on religion

Plan

To take place on Palm Sunday

4 uprisings in different parts of the country

Also have French fleet on south coast to stop Philip landing and marrying mary

would convene in London and replace Mary w/ Elizabeth

Elizabeth would marry Edward de Courtenay

who was involved

By January Spanish ambassador, Simon Renard had heard of the plans

Thomas Croft, was Lord Deputy in IReland

Government response

William Thomas, Clerk to council of Edward VI

Peter Carew (failed to stop western rebellion)

Sir Thomas Wyatt (had been soldier in Henry VIII's army during French Campaign)

Duke of Suffolk, Lady Jane Grey's dad

Elizabeth and Jane weren't involved but presented alternatives of Queen

Found out about plan in January and had Peter Carew appear before Council

What actually happened

Tried in January b/c gov. found out

not a good time b/c muddy roads

Little support raised

Croft didn't try in Hertfordshire

ppl in Leicester raised arms against Duke instead of helping him

Carew couldn't get support b/c of his actions in 1549

Suffolk + 140 supporters were taken to the Tower (him and Jane were executed

Thomas Wyatt's troops

as Sherrif had trained military

by 27 Jan had raised 2000 troops

Kent was closer to the action so more affected

more support b/c were involved in cloth production which was still depressed + protestants

Government tried to stop

300 troops raised by Lord Cobham deserted him and joined the rebels

At Gravesend, Wyatt had 3000

looked like he was going to March to London

attacked Cobham at cooling Castle first

then stopped at Blackheath to consider Queen's offer

arrived to see that London Bridge held against rebels

by wasting time by the time they got to Charing Cross they were a dwindling force

mary made speech to Londoner's demonstrating her love to the ppl

gained enough support for her so that ppl didn't support rebels

punishments

Phillip demanded that Both Edward de Courtenay and Elizabeth were removed

Edward exiled but no evidence against Elizabeth

480 charged w/ conspiracy but only 100 executed

Wyatt and Suffolk executed for their involvement

LJG and Guilford Dudley (her husband) also executed b/c they were too much of a threat

main issue w/ marriage is that ppl didn't want England to be involved in another war

key part of marriage agreement was that Phillip couldn't force England into war

1557: refused b/c of bad harvests and needed grain from France

April 1557: French naval attack on Scarborough castle --> protestant Thomas Stafford seized it and was supplied by French

easily quashed but enough motive for war

The war

some success

Channel cleared of French fleet

St Quentin was captured

Scottish border defended to prevent scotts attacking England

Failure at Calais

1600 English against 27,000 French

some blamed Phillip for his failure to send reinforcements at request

really b/c of fluke as French were running out of supplies + made last ditch attempt

Major blow to Mary's prestige

loss of Calais could have been beneficial b/c now didn't have to pay to garrison it (especially bad in times of low revenue and high inflation)

failure to produce heir was major threat

after false pregnancy in 1555 Philip left

not much chance of making baby

1558 Mary fell ill and left England to her sister