Please enable JavaScript.
Coggle requires JavaScript to display documents.
reading 28: The politics of choice - Coggle Diagram
reading 28: The politics of choice
Reading 28: The politics of choice
The social democratic left
Many social democrats are instinctively hostile to choice and competition in public services. This is partly because choice and competition are associated with markets
not for conusumers being exploited into buying unneccsessary
Does not agree with privatisation of health care
quasi market
believe in the "trust" model - 4 models of public service
believe public sector should be trusted to get on with their job and shouldn't need to be incentivized
use voice to get what they want
The Conservative Right
more likely to favour choice and competition over other models of public service delivery
public service workers not looked at egotistical people thinking of their own interests
they as why market is quasi and not full market
"hence any model of public service delivery that incorporates market elements such as user choice and provider competition is likely to be superior to models that do not
this viewpoint can be problematic - the ones with more money can pay for good healthcare and education, leaving others behind - penalising children for parents
Providers
reform causes prolems - felt like no say or control
Change of autonomy in health service caused problems
public sector prefer trust model but if not will accept quasi model
Users
most want choice in public sector
Voluteering
Competing Values Framework (CVF)
collaborative
create
control
compete
trust & legitimacy important to framework
Differnet elements:
collectovely
security
personal utility
autonomy
Arnstein Ladder of engagement
Citizin Power: Citizin control delegated powers. Partnership
Tokenism: Placation, consultaton, informing