Please enable JavaScript.
Coggle requires JavaScript to display documents.
attempts - Coggle Diagram
attempts
mens rea
-
recklessness is not sufficient for attempt even if the full crime is a basic intent offence (millard and vernon)
-
theft must have an intention to permanently deprive. in AG's Ref (nos 1 and 2 of 1979) it was determined that conditional intent is sufficient for an attempt
the mens rea for attempted murder is intention to kill. there is a higher level of mens rea for attempted murder than there is for murder (Whybrow)
overview
a person can be found guilty of an attempted crime if the full offence can be tried on indictment (murder, s.18, theft)
-
charging a person with a 'criminal attempt' is justified on the basis that the defendant should be punished as he took steps to commit the offence- this criminalises the potential harm
an attempt is where a person tries to commit an offence but for some reason fails to complete it (e.g. White). this is now defined by s.1 (1) criminal attempts act 1981 'if with intent to commit an offence a person does an act which is more than merely preparatory to the commission of the offence, he is guilty of attempting to commit the offence
actus reus
-
even though attempts is defined in statute we still rely on cases to try to determine what 'merely preparatory' means
-
Geddes 1996 the court of appeal asked two questions; has the accused moved from planning or preparation to execution or implementation? has the accused done an act showing he was actually trying to commit the full offence, or had he only got so far as getting ready/ putting himself in position to commit the offence?
impossibility
in some situations a person may intend to commit an offence, and may do everything they possibly can to commit it, but in fact the offence is impossible to commit
s.1(2) criminal attempts act 1981 determined that a defendant could be guilts of an attempt even if the full offence was impossible. 'a person may be guilty of attempting to commit an offence even though the facts are such that the commission of the offence is impossible'. demonstrated in Shiypuri