Please enable JavaScript.
Coggle requires JavaScript to display documents.
Objectivity in Decision-making:
The process by which we discover truth…
Objectivity in Decision-making:
The process by which we discover truth and knowledge, and the recognition of the perceptions included along the way, aids us in judgment.
Fair Process
Intellectual Honesty
Philosophy is about conviction by means of argument, and the philosopher uses argument to discover the truth of things (Gaukroger, p. 16).
-
-
Falsifiability, not verifiability
Karl Popper: the aim of scientific inquiry is not to try to and confirm or verify one's theories, but to try to falsify them (Gaukroger, p. 17).
"Fighting his natural inclinations, the scientist must himself try to show the theories he has nurtured to be false. In compensation, he attains to a form of intellectual morality of a profound kind to which no one can reasonably aspire: the scientist becomes the only truly intellectually honest person, for only the scientist is so concerned for truth that he attempts to show that his own theories are false," (Gaukroger, p. 18)
Scientific Method
Galileo: I got my own back, watch as I prove my heliocentric theory by disproving yours.
"Galileo's response is to reinterpret the evidence, arguing that what the observation shows is not the falsity of the hypothesis Earth moves, but the falsity of an implicit auxiliary hypothesis which his opponents hold: namely that the path of the falling body is not affected by whether it is initially in motion or stationary," (Gaukroger, p. 21).
-
-
Known Perceptions
Conceptual Structuring
Immanuel Kant: The world as it is is not possible, we change it as we perceive it.
Perceiving the world as "phenomenal (as it is structured by our minds) and not as it is in itself (as in its unstructured form)," (Gaukroger, p. 43).
-
-
A judgment or theory should be prejudice-free (Gaukroger, p. 10). # #
A judgement or theory should be assumption-free (Gaukroger, p. 10). # #
A judgment or theory should be an accurate representation (Gaukroger, p. 10). # #
References:
Stephen Gaukroger, "Objectivity, a Very Short Introduction," Oxford University Press, 2012.