Secularisation Theory

Definition (Wilson): The process whereby religious beliefs, practices and institutions lose social significance.

Evidence

Church attendance went from 40% in the mid-19th century to 10-15% by the 1960s.

The English Church Census has shown that attendances for large religious organisations has declined.

In 1971, 60% of wedding were in a church but by 2012 it decreased to 30%.

Number of Catholic priests fell by a third between 1965 and 2011.

Explanations for secularisation

Weber:

  • Rationalisation: People start rationalising life thus undermining the religious worldview of the Middle Ages.
  • Disenchantment: The Protestant Reformation started to see God as the creator of life but he didn't interfere with what went on with it.

Bruce: Argues that a technological worldview has replaced religious explanations of why supernatural things happen. Has greatly reduced the scope for religious explanations.

Parsons:

  • Structural differentiation: A process of specialisation which has occurred with the development of industrial society. Religion has become smaller with industrialisation and more of a specialised institution.
  • Disengagement: Where the functions of religion are transferred to other institutions.

Decline of community: Wilson argues that communities promoted shared values but due to more individualisation, religious influence has decreased.

Criticism: Some religious communities are "imagined communities" that interact through the use of global media.

Religious diversity (Berger):

  • Scared canopy: Catholic Church = monopoly (Middle Ages). Protestant Reformation = different versions of the truth. thus more plurality of life worlds.
  • Plausibility structure: Diversity undermines religion's "plausibility structure", the reasons why people find it believable. Religious belief become relative instead of absolute.

Criticism: Beckford agrees with the idea that religious diversity will lead to some questions or abandonment of their religious beliefs.

Secularisation in America

Declining church attendance: Hadaway: found that the level of attendance claimed in the interviews was 83% higher than actual attendance.

Secularisation from within: Bruce: Religion is more like a form of therapy in contemporary society. American religion has become more popular by becoming less religious.

Religious diversity: Lynd and Lynd: found that in 1924 94% of young people agreed that "Christianity is the one true religion and people should convert to it." but in 1977 only 41% agreed.

Criticisms:

  • Religion is not declining but changing.
  • One sided: ignore the growth of new religions
  • Ignores believing but not belonging.