CFO – Cathy Brown
OVERVIEW
- Cathy reports directly to the CEO, Jon
- Key player in ABS & likely Jon’s heir - been with the company for 15 years
- Cathy is considered to be an expert in mergers and acquisitions and has been the driver of ABSs acquisition strategy
- The company faces an EXISTENTIAL FINANCIAL CRISIS, primarily due to DRAMATIC YoY REVENUE SHORTFALL that is SQUEEZING CAPITAL, MARGINS & the COMPANY'S OPERATIONAL ABILITY TO RESPOND.
- Strategically, she feels technology will be critical to the future of ABS having seen the significant limitations that OUTDATED LANDSCAPE, MANUAL METHODS and ANTIQUATED PROCESSES have created for the business, and she will play a significant part in the creation of their future strategy
- IT reports to her and, as a strong and pragmatic leader, she favors business execution over politics
- Her “trust but verify” approach is behind hiring “supervision” for the CIO: Craig Stires. Lee is aware of this.
- Seeing her possible future, and the leadership void left by Jon, she is proactively developing the “group” structure on top of the old ABS hierarchy, which she intends to break up.
BACKGROUND
- University Degree in Business Administration
- Started career at Ernst & Young, progressed to Senior Manager position
- Joined ABS and quickly ascended to CFO role
- Involved in reporting project when SAP ERP was implemented
PERSONALITY
- Result-driven and very analytical
- Decisions are based on thinking and thorough investigation
- Seeks & values the opinions of others on her team, but retains final say on all spend decisions given the financial state of the company
INTERVIEW ATTITUDE
- Attitude towards SAP: NEUTRAL, however she sees the value in business continuity and leveraging existing assets
- Power: Significant power, Financial Decision Maker, controls all unbudgeted spend decisions
- Emotional state: Fiscally Cautious but loves the M&A game, calm-assertive
SITUATION
- Responsible for HR, Finance & Controls, Operations & IT
- Closely involved in the implementation of ERP, but the project went over budget, which damaged her professional reputation and is a slight black mark against SAP
- She knows that there were partner/implementation issues throughout that project
- NOTE: Hint at this history to allow the SAP Sales team to attempt to uncover and assess impact
- Responsible for managing the company through a 30% drop in the last 8 years, with continued market uncertainty further compounding critical business problems associated with significant technology/infrastructure gaps and mismanagement across their global operations
- Has had to make hard choices in order to make the least damaging but necessary cuts to all cost, and where unavoidable, profit centers in an effort to maintain operating and net margins in the wake of their dramatic revenue shortfall, even to IT and HR where she sees control paths to restoring profitability
- Cathy knows every investment must be justified and she is inclined to maximize past SAP investments vs. recreating the wheel and all the costs associated with that effort
- Not only is ABS looking for a significant reduction in hardware costs (leasing, licensing and support), but they also want a 40% reduction in maintenance costs
- Cathy is under considerable pressure to succeed and has the confidence of the board, for now
- Cathy’s has 882 full-time employees in Finance & 540 full-time employees in HR.
- She needs a 40% cost reduction in HR that must balance the CEO’s initiative to implement an enterprise-wide HCM system
Cathy is friends with Michael Mant, the account manager at IBM. They play golf together in their spare time
Overall, ABS has:
- 8.082b € in revenue
- 5.657b € in operating costs
- 2.425b € in profits annually
Deferring to Tom
- to provide a plan to address near and intermediate term revenue growth
Deferring to Lee (CIO)
- to address the EDI issue that is putting strategic customer relationships in jeopardy
Cathy is not naïve about Tom's & Lee's ability to solve these problems and will completely take over control if necessary
Key Business Drivers/KPIs
- Reduce IT maintenance costs by 30% by the end of current year
- Reduce HR operating budget by 40% by the end of current year
- Reduce days to close annual books from current 60 days to 30 days (50% decrease)
- Reduce DSO from current 80.4 days to 70 days (13% decrease)
- Reduce SG&A to 10% of revenue (current is 15.7% of revenue – 36% decrease)
- Significantly reduce monthly reports processing time, from current 15 days to 7 days (50% decrease) and eliminate extra costs with external resources
- Avoid over-payments /Compliance Optimize working capital
- Working capital employed per unit of sales
- Inventory days
- Reduce DSO
- Reduce DSO Increase net margin/profit/income Increase operating margin/profit/income
- Reduce COGS/COS (gross profit margin management)
- Reduce variable cost of production
- Reduce IT/Finance/Marketing/Manufacturing related CAPEX/ OPEX
- Revenue Growth Rate
- Total Shareholder Return (TSR) – Large Enterprise
- Economic Value Added (EVA)
- Return on Investment (ROI)
- Return on Capital Employed (ROCE)
- Return on Assets (ROA)
- Return on Equity (ROE) – Large Enterprise
- Debt-to-Equity (D/E) Ratio – Large Enterprise
- Cash Conversion Cycle (CCC)
- Working Capital Ratio
- Operating Expense Ratio (OER)
- CAPEX to Sales Ratio Price Earnings Ratio (P/E Ratio) – Large Enterprise
Role player note
Cathy is not unlike most CFO’s in this economy who have taken direct control over IT in order to manage this cost center, and the CIO, who has rarely enjoyed Board level confidence in terms of being perceived as strategic to the business
She is embracing technology and has a vision, however, is not technical herself but sees the operating efficiencies that properly aligned and deployed technology bring to the business
While she has been slightly burned by technology she sees it as more predictable and profitable than people when implemented properly
She is acutely aware of the high operating costs associated with FTE’s and seeks to have more control over both human capital and the revenue driving aspects of the business
She is ambitious and wants the CEO role and sees the opportunity to put the company back on its revenue track
While she would not admit this out loud she is emotionally attached to the acquisitions that she had so much to do with and does not want to see the company divest any of its operations, least of all the companies that have been acquired under her watch
While she personally likes Tom, she is not convinced that his visceral approach to the business is a fit for the future that she wants to build, this crisis will be his test
She has little patience for politics and sees Lee in a make or break position. She will defer heavily to Craig’s opinion in terms of how capable he is to assess IT solutions with respect to their impact on the business.
What she is not sharing with her leaders is that she is willing to make significant IT investments as a “one step back in order to make two steps forward” if she believes that the business impact exceeds the costs within a reasonable amount of time. She is a realist when it comes to the systemic nature of this problem and will commit funds if the return is compelling and financially justified. This is her chance to show the board what she can do visa vis the current CEO
When playing the role of Cathy - Push the sales teams to transcend the technology and SPEAK THE BUSINESS VALUE that SAP has brought to similar businesses in similar situations. Amateurs compete with each other, professionals compete with themselves.
PROBLEM 1 - fragmented & outdated technology infrastructure crippling revenue
- While Cathy is deferring to her Sales/Marketing, IT, HR & Operations leaders to manage their own KPIs, she is aware of the “elephant in the room” problems associated with the company’s fragmented and outdated technology infrastructure that is crippling revenue
- Given that she is the ultimate financial decision maker, any revenue related solutions are going to be high on her priority list (see LoBs leaders profiles for details on specific problem).
PROBLEM 2 - REPORTING
- Insight into the business is critical to Cathy and the other leaders’ ability to respond quickly to the changing needs of the market and the business and make more effective and profitable decisions
- Currently, there are just a few people in charge of reporting. They can’t fulfill all requirements from the business in time
- Furthermore, due to the fragmented data landscape, creating reports is extremely time-consuming.
IMPACT
- Leadership has to wait too long to get requested information, which negatively affects decision making process
- Valuable/Expensive staff must work overtime
- The finance department had to source two additional resources from to deliver the required monthly reports (at a cost of approximately 1,200 Euro each day).
Goals and Desires / Need Pay Offs
When there is one uniform data source that is easy to use:
Business users will be able to create reports in real time
External hiring costs can be reduced
There will be less pressure on Cathy and success will help rebuild her reputation.
PROBLEM 3 - Unreliable XLS Planning & Budgeting
- Planning & budgeting is unreliable & requires lots of manual XLS work
IMPACT
- Ineffective and incorrect decisions are being made because data is not accurate or too late (no ‘real time’ capabilities)
- High costs for an external accountant to generate the annual report on risk and compliance. Currently the reports take 60 days to be released to Cathy to review, her target is to have it in 30 days (50% reduction in time)
Goals and Desires / Need Pay Offs
- If ABS has a central solution for planning and budgeting
- With the elimination of homemade spreadsheets, accurate data and better decision-making in uncertain markets will significantly help operations
- There will be a decrease in accounting costs, along with a strengthening of operational processes
Goals and Desires / Need Pay Offs
If ABS has a central solution for planning and budgeting:
- With the elimination of homemade spreadsheets, accurate data and better decision-making in uncertain markets will significantly help operations
- There will be a decrease in accounting costs, along with a strengthening of operational processes
PROBLEM 4 - HR Costs too HIGH
The costs of HR are too high. Due to past acquisitions, the HR processes and IT systems are fragmented and the number of HR employees is disproportionate. Cathy believes that this can be solved with technology rather than expensive FTE’s.
IMPACT
- High cost level of HR impacts profitability
- Low employee satisfaction due to low service level of HR
Goals and Desires / Need Pay Offs
When ABS has an HR self-service solution for employees and managers:
- HR headcount can be reduced and profitability will increase
- Employee satisfaction will increase
SOLUTIONS/VALUES EXPECTED TO BE ON OFFERED
FOCUS should be on data analysis and real time report
Have to be able to integrate the current infrastructure and have a single source of truth for all departments.
Reporting solutions can help quickly analyze data coming from different systems.
Self Service Analytics
Further requirement can be met with Business Integrated Planning
Bonanza's Financial Issues Summary
- The first is of course the decreasing revenue which we believe is the basis of the whole scenario. When revenue decreases it affects most benchmarks negatively. The question is what caused the revenue to drop, losing customers or discounting the products. Or both?
- Decreasing gross margin indicates that the efficiency in the production and/or the price realization is poor. Increasing competition puts pressure on the pricing with a decreasing gross margin in its wake. Procurement has an obvious effect on the gross margin and if working capital improvements are prioritized it might have a negative effect on pricing.
- EBIT margin (Operating margin) is also dropping indicating that the company is not able to cut costs at the same pace as the revenue is decreasing. In order to decrease the costs, the processes within SG&A must be focused and streamlined which means a great deal of structural and operational IT investments.
- The cash conversion cycle is far too high. The main reason is that both DSO (Days Sales Outstanding) and ITO (Inventory Turnover Ratio) are high and more importantly, trending the wrong way. DPO is developing in a positive direction but not enough.
- Cash flow is positive, yet small, and the cash situation is not an issue right now. The cash situation has improved by increased borrowings, capital injection and zero dividends for 2019, which indicates that the owners and board have the insight and willingness to do something about the current situation.
- R&D is picking up. ABS has not spent much on R&D historically and now they are in a situation where their products are lagging. During the last year, more resources have been allocated to R&D as it is evident that they need to develop products for new market segments.
7. The inefficiency is also visible in the slight increase in SG&A, much of this is probably IT related.
Inventory includes all the goods a company has in its stock that will ultimately be sold. Inventory turnover indicates the rate at which a company sells and replaces its stock of goods during a particular period. The inventory turnover ratio formula is the cost of goods sold divided by the average inventory for the same period.
Inventory Turnover Ratio = Cost Of Goods Sold ÷ Average Inventory
DSO is the average number of days that it takes a company to collect payment for a sale. DSO is often determined on a monthly, quarterly, or annual basis.
The days sales outstanding formula is as follows: Divide the total number of accounts receivable during a given period by the total value of credit sales during the same period and multiply the result by the number of days in the period being measured.
Days sales outstanding (DSO) is the average number of days it takes a company to receive payment for a sale. A high DSO number suggests that a company is experiencing delays in receiving payments. That can cause a cash flow problem. A low DSO indicates that the company is getting its payments quickly. That money can be put back into the business to good effect. Generally speaking, a DSO under 45 days is considered low.
Days payable outstanding (DPO) is a financial ratio that indicates the average time (in days) that a company takes to pay its bills and invoices to its trade creditors, which may include suppliers, vendors, or financiers. The ratio is typically calculated on a quarterly or annual basis, and indicates how well the company’s cash outflows are being managed.