Critical Reflections
Unit 1
Unit 2
Unit 3
Unit 4
Critical Connections
Noteworthy Conversations
Concepts and Takeaways
Platforms and Tools
Critical Connections
Noteworthy Conversations
Concepts and Takeaways
Platforms and Tools
Noteworthy Conversations
Platforms and Tools
Critical Connections
Concepts and Takeaways
Noteworthy Conversations
Platforms and Tools
Critical Connections
Concepts and Takeaways
Slack for a class
Coggle
Ted Lectures
Procrastination and human nature
Idea of real time notes being taking in a non-chronological pattern
Critical Consumption
Consumer Culture
Strategic Consumption with TMI-(Cottom)
Look at technology as in art
What experiences do we bring
How do we "thicken" engagement
Creating something "new"
Creation in technology=creating the future
Re-contextualizing (house hunters example)
gives content new life
Mixing up format draws attention to details
Digital Rhetoric
Recontextualizing
Defining Text
Digital platforms as the equivalent of a physical space- home, gallery, classroom
Kipple
Kipple thoughts
Kipple content
Impulse to improve the human condition
Problem->Solution not always the best path
Panic function of having a deadline
Long term procrastination
Media Diet
Seek information vs information that is already delivered
Innovation
Meaning Making
intertextuality
Hypermedia
10 hours a day interacting with media according to Neilsen's 2018 total audience report
Capacity for creative engagement
Profit Driven
relationship between texts
confuse, obfuscate, and in certain cases, exclude. It can also be used to deceive
can engender a sense of belonging and investment
If the audience is not part of one of the groups, the meaning will be obscured (example, references to avengers franchises, vs
Meta-Narrative
Good vs evil
Cover meta narratives-Like the avengers franchise "totalizing consumptive interests: or the persuasive flattening of individuated needs and desires in service of unifying, uncritical, avenues for consumption."
uncritical consuption
Masterplot
Capital, Commerce, consumption rather than just "new"
Persuasive Architecture
tacit consent to advertisement
Design choices
Social motivators, engagement
Balance???
Utopia/Disopia
Jedi/Sith??
What is good vs evil in the landscape
technological persuasion architectures vs traditional forms of persuasion (technological does not get a counter argument)
Digital media effect
Skimming
Media influences the message (nietzche's typewriter)
scatter our attention and diffuse our concentration
Google is "supplementing" our brain knowledge
Age old-Socates feared writing would start to confuse wise from the ignorant
lItalian humanist Hieronimo Squarciafico worried that the easy availability of books would lead to intellectual laziness, making men “less studious” and weakening their minds
lose those quiet spaces, or fill them up with “content,
Predictive text/Smart Compose
Very well funded
Written word is based in trade
click to edit
Grammarly rewarding writers with prestige complements
Data selling/ algorithms That we don't understand
Only work if there is a ton of data
Diagnosing mental health issues
The "rabbit hole"
Demobilization
Civic message Voting facebook experiment
Polarization
click to edit
power of influence too great, even if bad ethics are unintentional
Lack of transparency
Technology should support us, and be constrained by values
Thick reading=thinking and reflecting, considering context /opposite of thin/surface reading
Cudgel= club
absences of representation results in same people to replicate their perspective
Redlining
oppressive algorithms
predatory inclusion
Digital redlining
data use, algorithmic decision making
Complex world vd black and white construction
World Building=a speculative world
Imagining potential outcomes
Science fiction/creative/writing
process for coming up with the setting for narritive/meta narritive
Storyboard=outline-but can be in a creative form
Cultural imagination=collective (region, locality) meaning making.
systemic erasure
Podcast formats
You can use voice memo
RSS Feed????
Multiple Hosts
Solo
Interview
Scripted Nonfiction
Scripted fisction
Hybrid
Repurposed content
Think of a name, search terms
description (a couple sentances)
How long? 5 mins per project
Cover Art
Pexels
Burst
Unsplash
Canva design tool
Interstitial music must be legal
Find a good location- record downstairs where there is carpet
Check that the mic is far away from mouth, speak to sides
Room tone? Deal with that
or Resonate Recordings.
misrepresentation via search results
Some voices amplified, some silenced
We need to examine the shift to corporate, privately held company
context of search results- prolematic, further marginalizes
Ad dollars
results appear to be fair, objective, but are driven by commercial bias
Birth of American music
click to edit
What do you see as the episode's driving question?
What is the podcast's structure (ie: what format does it follow)?
How does the structure affect the episode's approach to addressing that question?
What did you learn/what stuck with you from this episode?
What question(s) did the episode leave you with, and why?
1) A personal anecdote (Yacht Rock while cooking)
2) Lots of examples, short snippets of songs, with descriptions to explain right after
3) Descriptions turn into, like painting a picture (an artful description)
4) Gives us the premise, of Black American pain, and traditional music
Gives us an anecdote, a story
6) begins to go through a timeline of the development of American music (lots of music examples underneath)
How is Black history and culture inherent to American Music. The podcast concludes that Black music is the ultimate expression of a belief in American Freedom, but the case it builds is specific to music.
The structure was really interesting- it started with a personal, contemporary anecdote, which it circled back to. The episode not only provided interesting technical descriptions and examples of musical conventions, but also described the music in artful ways.
click to edit
click to edit
5) This story becomes a story about the beginning of exploitation- of blackface
Uses clips to illlustrate the growing popularity of these minstral shows/what becomes a troup
Explains how "classic" songs we sing today, are old minstrel songs, without examination
7) next stage is Black people preforming as caricatures, and main stream white stars also bought into doing blackface
How it makes the white audience feel (better about themselves), able to make a heavy topic a joke
8) Recording industry- Black people have access to studios (more music under the narration)
Muddy Waters- inventing and perfecting blues rhythm, blues ideas, blues expression, the expression of of a fully human black self in American popular art
Creates a uniquely American Culture/ rather than just rehashing Western Euro Music
8) circles back to cooking, "all that history is just very silently coursing through this music...thoroughly atomized into American culture."
Motown- descriptions of the themes
Motown-antidote to minstrel-Combats idea that Black people are inherently inferior
Social Network Analysis
click to edit
Architectural visibility
Social Distruption
digital underclass
hierarchy, competition, and groupthink
people who don't have internet access, or whose access is slow or spotty
those who are disproportionally excluded from the benefits of technological advancement
People who are marginalized-excluded from algorithmic progress narrative
hierarchical social systems are replicated
physical reflects and reproduces
New Jim Code
filter bubbles deepen polarization
Flattens discussions
incentivises conformity
Machine learning (week 2)
Recommended content
Deep fakes-
deep learning to create alternative representations of something or sometime.
click to edit
Who is considered a 'menace'
Those who shape technology, if technology is the menace
menaces=effect of societies problems.
what problems are people trying to fix
who is welcome
Predetermined reactions in social media, reflects the priorities of the company who designs the platform
Stifles expression, speech
Targeted in advertisement
Investment in only white infrastructure
American wealth is grounded in home ownership
If you aren't benefitting you are being harmed
discrimination can happen without a visible antagonist
"i'm not racist"-with other bad behavior, intention is not important
allure of objectivity
People look for statistics to justify
click to edit
Appeal to science as an arbiter
click to edit
click to edit
Power is not earned
social capital-norms that privilege those in charge
generational wealth
Civic capital
contrast in civic resources (broadband, schools, due process)
click to edit
“Emergence is the way complex systems and patterns arise out of a multiplicity of relatively simple
interactions”
1) a coherent visionary exploration of humanity
and 2) emergent strategies for being better humans.
"When we are engaged in acts of love, we humans are at our best...Perhaps humans’ core function is love. "
We are in an imagination battle.
I love the idea of shifting from “mile wide inch deep” movements to “inch
wide mile deep” movements that schism the existing paradigm
EMERGENT STRATEGY
a philosophy for how to be in harmony and love, in and with the world.
the adaptive and relational leadership model found in the work of Black science fiction writer Octavia Butler (and others). Grew into plans of action, personal practices and collective organizing tools that account for constant change and rely on the strength of relationship for adaptation. Includes ideas of biomimetrics and permaculture
being in the right relationship to our home and each other, to practice complexity, and grow a compelling future together through relatively simple interactions. Emergent strategy is how we intentionally change in ways that grow our capacity to embody the just and liberated worlds we long for.
PRINCIPLES/ELEMENTS
click to edit
Small is good, small is all. (The large is a reflection of the small.)
Change is constant. (Be like water).
There is always enough time for the right work.
There is a conversation in the room that only these people at this moment can have.
Never a failure, always a lesson.
Trust the People. (If you trust the people, they become trustworthy).
Move at the speed of trust.
Focus on critical connections more than critical mass—build the resilience by building the relationships
Less prep, more presence.
What you pay attention to grows
ANTI-Nurture
a western/US context are socialized to work against respecting the emergent processes of the world
and each other
storytelling as a way to share analysis
Fractal
Adaptative
Interdepnendence and decentralization
Non-linier and iterative
Resilience and Transformative Justice
Creating More Possibilities
click to edit
Black Twitter
Respectability politics
participatory futures in which the most disadvantaged among us can thrive
The Public
"imagined community" or linguistic placeholder for a dynamic collection of ideas, feelings, assumptions, shorthand's, hopes, and dreams that "are all competing to become the correct image" of who and what we are
Counter Public
paces in which marginalized communities can counter state violence, engage in political organizing, and affirm critical teaching and learning
mutual aid resources in response to systemic racism; it's a grieving space for those who have lost loved ones to police brutality; it's an archive for those who work to combat civic and cultural erasure; it's a place to share art, data, and strategies for resistance; and it's also a vehicle for naming digital patterns that bleed over from physical spaces
click to edit
resistance network
Canva slides
The Public
Who defines the publics wants and needs
click to edit
importance of public opinion- systems should confirm to the whim
Vs Tyranny of majority
being able to use polling to generalize
Reporting of polling creates bandwagons
zeitgeist
Marc Lamont Hill
Fraser and others have argued, the Habermasian conception of the public sphere neglected the various ways that oppressed groups (e.g., women; working class; lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender [LGBT]; Black) have been historically marginalized or altogether excluded from the bourgeois public sphere.
marginalized groups have always formed their own subaltern counterpublics
Speed in which to get a critical mass
generate critical racial political discourses outside the gaze of the White mainstream
these surveillances (cell phone videos of bad cops) serve as concrete forms of resistance to state violence by placing otherwise private interactions between citizens and law enforcement within a broader set of public and counterpublic spheres. When linked to Black Twitter and other digital counterpublics, these tools enable new forms of pedagogy, resistance and, most fundamentally, survival.
click to edit
Summarize your definition of pedagogies of resistance
Sharing a quote from the text that connects to this summary.
Sharing some of your notes on how you interpreted/read
the essay and what you took away from your reading.
Considering how your life experiences/ what you've learned
to-date may have shaped your interpretation/
what you took away from the essay (similar to God's response to Martha).
click to edit
click to edit
click to edit
click to edit
Respectability politics
Regardless of Lillard’s personal politics, his comments became a public text that could be used as a site of critical interrogation. The critical response to Lillard’s tweets enabled the Black Twitter community to engage in a critical pedagogy, both internally and to the broader publics (e.g., mainstream television news outlets, blogs, and other sectors of Twitter) that observed and shared the event.
texts can be globally distributed without sanction or mediation from corporate media or law enforcement institutions.
These expectations, which are centered around patriarchal norms of femininity, politeness, and deference to male authority, lead to disproportionate arrests when defied by Black women and girls (Freiburger & Burke, 2011; Nanda, 2012; Saar et al., 2015). In addition, stories about sexual violence, assaults on pregnant women, and gendered profiling were all included in Black Twitter conversations using the #SayHerName hashtag. Through these narratives, Black Twitter did not merely append female faces to male-centered narratives, but also radically shifted how state violence is imagined and contested within the space.
Retrograde analysis
Working backwards from the goal
Controlling the story to have it get to the desired result (like chess game)
useful for extrapolating a prior path (like BAC example)
Design Thinking is essentially a problem-solving approach specific to design, which involves assessing known aspects of a problem and identifying the more ambiguous or peripheral factors that contribute to the conditions of a problem.