Please enable JavaScript.
Coggle requires JavaScript to display documents.
What is the sense of agency - prospective or retrospective - Coggle Diagram
What is the sense of agency - prospective or retrospective
the competing models
perspective
premotor
efferent signals
internal
prereflective motor instructions
models
action selection model
phenomenal model
it's an addition to the retro comperator model
retrospective
afferent signal
retro evalution
comperator model
limitations
thought insertion
some schizophrenics attribute agency to one’s self and some attribute it to the others
intentional action
why question
due to reason
first person awareness of the action
different levels of reasoning
first person - I want to do this and that
third person - he try to relax himself (automatic in the first person eyes)
feel of control (SoA place)
there is scale of different agent levels
intentional
subintentional
moving the hands while speaking
reflex
preintentional
movement that accompanied to intentional one - like saccadic eye movement
two types of SoA
Experimental
Sense of Agency
lower-level, sensorimotor, pre-reflective processes
Judgment of agency
high order belief-constructs or reflective processes
I think it might be prereflective too
post factum - after
conclusion - SoA could be only epiphenomenal
Experiments
the EBS experiment - subjects think that they move a limb (SoA) or actually move it. moreover in some cases they recall having a reason for the movement
conclusion - SoA without efferent copy nor decision making
exception - it might happened in the neural level
strong case for the difference between SeO and JoA
further reading
further reading in the relevant paper
The alien hand experiment
further reading