Please enable JavaScript.
Coggle requires JavaScript to display documents.
Observations (Evaluate participant, non-participant, naturalistic, overt…
Observations
Evaluate participant, non-participant, naturalistic, overt and covert observations
Participant observations
-
Strengths
Generates detailed, in-depth knowledge of a topic, that cannot be achieved through other research methods
Useful in exploring socially sensitive issues because the researcher can take different aspects into consideration (holistic approach)
Can avoid researcher bias since the researcher can understand the social process from the perspective of a participant
Extra details can be obtained from participants as the researcher establishes friendly, intimate relationship with them during the study
Combines emic dimension (subjective participant perspective) with an etic approach (objective researcher perspective)
Weaknesses
Data collection and analysis may be time consuming and costly, especially for longitudinal studies
-
-
The researcher may lose objectivity since it difficult to maintain involvement (as a participant) and detachment (as a researcher). Reflexivity methods can be used to reflect on potential areas of biases
Highly demanding task for the researcher since participation means involvement in an unfamiliar environment with strangers, all while taking notes of whatever happens
-
-
Overt observations
Strengths
Observer can obtain rich data by become part of the group and by not restricting specific target behaviours to be observed
Data less affected by demand characteristics since participants have the opportunity to get comfortable with the researcher
-
-
Weaknesses
-
The researcher's presence can lead to demand characteristics, leading to artificial participant behaviour and bias
-
-
Covert observations
-
Strengths
-
Reduce reactivity - people altering their behaviour due to the awareness that they are being observed
-
Weaknesses
Participants are not aware of the research thus cannot give consent, ethical considerations around the level of deception
-
Discuss considerations involved in setting up and carrying out an observation (eg. audience effect, Hawthorne effect, disclosure)
-
Ethical considerations
Informed consent - for covert observation, the group's permission to study them has not been obtained
Ensure anonymity of participants - destroying videotapes or materials that can reveal participant's identity
-
-
Disclosure
-
Revealing too much information to participants before the study regarding the aims and behaviours being observed can affect the validity of the results
Too little disclose can lead to ethical concerns, eg. inform consent may not be comprehensively done
-