Please enable JavaScript.
Coggle requires JavaScript to display documents.
Rituals and prosocial (Signalling and rituals (they are "hard-to…
Rituals and prosocial
Signalling and rituals
-
-
-
they are "hard-to-fake" signals if rituals are genuinely painful and require endurance etc like in the Satere Maure tribe
whereas other signals, such as verbal, are "easy-to-fake" and unreliable... someone who says "trust me" is not necessarily trustworthy
HYPOTHESIS: costly rituals authenticate commitment to a group code and increase co-operation, therefore increase survival prospects of the group
Is this falsifiable?
Sosis high costs imposed on group members related to longevity for the whole group - actually live longer!
Soler (2011)
Candomble religion: CRSS (psychometric measure of costly signalling - costly aspects of religious involvement e.g. cleaning the terreiro/ meeting place or abstinence from sex, music etc) AND giving habits AMD public goods economic game
-
-
Xygalatas (2012)
extreme rituals and prosocial behaviour: Hindu ritual in Mauritius: males: 3 groups, HO performer, HO observer and LO observer
HYP: increased social identity related to high-ordeal i.e. higher commitment to group and higher social inclusion (Mauritius v Hindu)
rituals increase salience of the superordinate identity... :no_entry: might this be bad for the smaller group (Hindus)? as members are committed to a wider range/larger social group.
-
:no_entry: generalisations to 'prosociality' in general hard to make when basing off only one donation task?
Co-operative effects of costly rituals do seem to exist and rituals increase commitment which in turn benefits group as a whole
:no_entry: not in a laboratory so less control :check: which means its more reliable as is a field experiment
The issue of causality
Is participation in a costly ritual an expression of prosocial behaviour? or is it actually quite masochistic?
-
-
-
-
-
Defining
Rituals
examples
-
Satere Maure bullet ants
"if you live your life with no pain, suffering or effort then it will mean nothing to you"
-
-
-
-
Causal opaqueness: rituals lack purpose, structure or end goal to an independent observer Whitehouse - anthropological approach
religion fills the gap? and provides reasoning for otherwise seemingly pointless activities i.e. "because it pleases God"
Prosociality
any action which furthers the group interest e.g. enforcing norms, gaining resources etc. Doing something which helps another person other than yourself (doesn't necessarily need to be altruistic?). *putting the needs of the group ahead of the needs of any* single person
The gay participant hot sauce study: was aggression actually prosocial? Rejecting 'immoral' individuals benefits the group?
McKay and Whitehouse fractioning approach! warm/fuzzy tendencies not necessarily true/ best approach to regarding prosociality
-