Please enable JavaScript.
Coggle requires JavaScript to display documents.
Youth Crime (Functionalist explanation (Sub-cultural Strain theory /…
Youth Crime
-
Marxist explanation
CCCS ~ deviance is a form of resistance against society's control and a reaction to their identity being threatened
Conflict theories
Neo-Marxism:
- crisis of hegemony
- symbolic resistance
- CCS (Marxist subcultural theory)
- fully social theory of deviance
- selective policing
Labelling:
- social construction of deviance
- deviance as relative concept
- labelling process and selective policing
- effects of labelling (primary-secondary deviance)
- deviance amplification
- rule creation
Traditional Marxism:
- criminogenic capitalism
- laws serve ruling class
- ideological role of law/social control
- white collar crime
- selective law enforcement
- society shaped by economic base
- capitalist exploit working class
- society based on conflict, inequality and power central to crime and deviance
- law serves powerful ~ ideological
Critics:
- not all laws are just serving ruling class, many benefit workers
- laws reflect value consensus
- too deterministic
- high crime rates in socialist countries
- ignore importance of values/culture and socialisation in criminality
- ignores individual motivation
- ignores gender/ethnic inequality
- not all white people commit crime
- laws can act against the ruling class
White collar crime
Types:
- employee theft
- fraud
- computer crime
- tax fraud
- crimes against consumers
- crimes against employees
Level of harm:
- 20 x more harmful than street crime
- harm from faulty goods/safety/infringements/pollution etc
- fraud, far greater than burglary, muffing, theft
- middle class crime by people of high status/respectability
- corporate crimes
- white collar (employees)
Why it's hard to detect:
- very hard to investigate due to invisible nature
- hard to isolate blame
- no direct victim
- law is ambiguous/grey area
- consumers don't report/trivial
- policed by inspectors
- technical knowledge/ complex ahead of police skill set
Studies:
Phil Cohen:
- skinheads
- ultra working class symbols
- response to destruction of working class communities in 60s
Hebdige:
- Punk
- shock collaging of symbols and distorted images
Hall:
- Rastas/ Rudies
- challenges to racist Babylon
-
- working class youths find 'magical solutions' to oppression
- resistance through rituals
- symbolic resistance expressed through subcultures
- subculture bricolage ~ stealing signs and distorting their meaning
New Right/Control Theory
- fears of moral decay
- desire for greater control of people who harm normal society
- critical of welfare state
- people are naturally selfish
- need control through laws
- rational choice ~ cost/benefit analysis
- welfare = dependency = laziness = damaged bonds and informal social control
Underclass theory ~ Murray:
- underclass reject mainstream norms and values
- dependency culture
- rise of single parents, lack of discipline, no father figure, poor socialisation, instability
- communities damaged, no bonds, 'good people' move away
- moral decline
Rational choice theory
Wilson (broken Windows)
- communities need informal social control to regulate deviance
- cost-benefit analysis = less chance of getting caught/no fear of punishment
- neighbourhood watch
- strength communities, surveillance and chance of being caught
Etzionl
- government is dis-empowering communities
Clarke (rational choice)
- crime is choice when rewards outweigh costs = low chance of being caught and punishment doesn't deter
Control theory ~ Hirschi
- low attachments = low crime
- bonds (attachment, commitment, belief, involvement)
- family = vital for socialisation
- collapse of community and bonds
Critics:
- Marxists are critical as the right use this theory to justify inequality
- Contradiction ~ belief in selfish interests and community
- most working class citizens are moral even though struggling in poverty
- ignores middle class crime
- ignores how powerful manipulate society to control poor
- attack single parents
- ethnocentric-ism ~ bias
- ignores wider structural causes e.g poverty
- assumes rational choice, doesn't explain violence
- blames environment not values/culture
- no empirical evidence of underclass subculture
Felson
- absence of 'capable guardian'
- need informal social control/community to trigger the 'inner policeman' (morality/duty)
-
-
-
-
Ricky Taylor (1998) analysis of official stats between 1957/1997 show in 1958 56% of guilty/cautioned offenders were 20 or under, with 38% in 1997
-
-