Please enable JavaScript.
Coggle requires JavaScript to display documents.
Gorlok Prep- 18/36 (Missouri State (Genevieve Patterson (Ban transfer thru…
Gorlok Prep- 18/36
-
Hillsdale
Alexandra Negrich
eliminate police unions -police unions prevent reform and encourage misconduct -targets minorities --solv: weeds out "bad seeds" and increases accountability --adv:collective bargaining
-
-
-
-
-
-
Justin Politzer
end federal equitable sharing program (CAF) -sessions expanding program -program undermines property rights -property rights key to poverty -poverty key to human rights --adv: financial incentive in the war on drugs -targets minorities
-
-
Nebraska-Lincoln
-
Britnee Hart
amend the Death in Custody Reporting Act of 2013 to require police to file a report whenever they draw or use a firearm
-
CSU Sac/ Sac State
Kelly Buckband
requiring Police Licenses -bad seeds rehired -undermines all police -civilian distrust --adv 1: civilian trust key to anti-terror efforts -nuke terror -extinction --adv 2: civilian trust key to US heg -heg key to disease, terror, and wmd -extinction
-
-
Raj Singh
send seized assets to fed gov, create new standard, and end federal equitable sharing program (CAF) -profit policing -unconstitutional -sessions expanding --solv: ending program prevents profit policing and new standard key --Adv 1: -program creates public mistrust -trust key to heg -heg key to disease, terror, and wmd -extinction --Adv 2: -financial incentive in the war on drugs -war on drugs= hyper incarceration -crowded prisons= disease -extinction -moral obligation to end "african genocide" in the US???
-
Illinois State
Tyler Smith
embrace negritude (K Aff) --framework: traditional debate excludes POC -white is a color too??? --link: police are domestic soldiers -they bring violence instead of peace --impact: colonialism -structural violence increase crime, thus increasing policing -dehum allows slavery and genocide --Alt Solv: embrace neg in abolition of racial privileges -negritude key to revolutionary end to racism -talk about race in the debate space for the shame -shame key to revolution -revolution solves colonialism
Tyler fails to embrace negritude in their own 1ac by neglecting to provide us with the revolutionary poetry that disrupts our white consciousness: no in round solvency means debate space remains under the white gaze
Embracing negritude embraces segregation, segregation strengthens racial divides, racial divides exacerbate misconduct: tuns case
Counter K: Feminism --link(s): _ excludes the feminine, marginalizes women, particularly WOC
Counter Framework: Critical debate excludes POC, women, etc. via elitism
-
-
Advocacy Statement Flaws
Should: the word should in a advocacy statement can't be fiated because that theory applies to specifically plan texts. No fiat = No solvency.
-
Consciousness is based on experiences: blacks have different experiences, thus blacks have different consciousnesses. Aff oversimplifies and generalizes an entire undefined group
-
Shame is used as a mean to an end and is not recognized as purposeful in and of itself, which is what many cultures value. Thus, Aff dehumanizes and objectifies "other" cultural practices to use them as a means to an end
Aff provides a utopian solvency post-advocacy. This means the discussion is closed from counter-narratives and consciousnesses: Latina, etc.
-
-
Nicholas Honeysett
end 1033 -military grade weapons escalates misconduct --solv: eliminating militarization decreases misconduct --adv 1: militarization silences protests -ending militarization key to increasing protests -protests key to civil society -protests key to democracy --adv 2: militarization is a public health concern -ending militarization key to ending misconduct -agencies perception of minorities increases misconduct -dehum
Amend 1033 PIC: end the part of the program that gives weapons, keep the other equipment
Other Equipment DA: natural disasters disproportionately effect minorities, turns Adv 2
Central Michigan U
Cam Patton :no_entry:
SCOTUS overturn Joe Arpaio prez pardon and end pardon power adv 1: court legitimacy adv 2: racial profiling
I ran Misconduct T, Regulation T, Test Case Theory, and Trump Base DA -Kelli, round 1
-
-
West Kentucky
-
Diego Martinez
Updating SRO programs -current programs don't protect all students -SROs are fastest growing police -SROs inefficient & relied on as enforcers -police in schools gives them too much power -SROs increase crime --solv: new program uses SROs as last resort -less SROs = better education -educated citizens = reform to corrupt systems = less police misconduct overall --adv: school to prison pipeline: arresting kids feeds the PIC & system of oppression -SRO/SOC racism link -solving schools solves prisons -oppression = extinction -fighting racism framework
-
-
Crowder
Vikas Yadav
Require police to wear and use body cams -no federal regulations exist --solv: bodycams reduce excessive force complaints and restore public trust -aff is a step in the right direction -aff is topical; reduces misconduct --adv: public trust low due to misconduct -bodycams restore trust -bodycams give perceived legitimacy, that allows police to solve crime and terror -bodycams help police w terror -terror attack has global consequences
-
Increase T: federal regulations on body cams don't exist; plan is a creation, not an increase
-
-
Misconduct T: cameras record everything (not just misconduct), this makes it Extra T at best
Increase T: federal regulations on body cams don't exist; plan is a creation, not an increase
-
-
Their Pasternack 17 (internal link/ solvency to terror) is taken out of context, they talk about bodycams with specific tech upgrades. Plan doesn't mandate those specific upgrades.
-
Truman State
Caleb Daniels
Give Domesticated Pets the Same Protections as Law Enforcement Animals and provide police training for interactions
law enforcement animals are given rights because of their ability to serve humans, not because of their independent worth as living things. this is anthro in intent
Thus, giving pets the same rights is also anthro in intent
Advantage 1 AND 2: the discourse here is focused on how anthro effects humans. THAT IS INHERENTLY ANTHRO. Discourse Turn on case.
K/ Link turn: giving privileges to pets and not to other animals is anthro itself. it recognizes that only pets matter because they are in some direct relation to us.
PIC: stop killing all non-human animals
-
Extra T: first part of the plan text gives protections to pets from the public; this is NOT police misconduct
No Internal Link: giving pets protections is not the same as establishing sentience; thus no solvency to anthro
-
-