What happened to Ichabod? Who dun' it?
Dustin - Ichabod was hit w/ pumpkin and when he woke up, he ran away. "Haunted by the ghost of the unfortunate schoolmaster" or "still alive, studied law""
Lex - Having fun in this town, but got hit and dragged away. He's alive somewhere else practicing law.
Britton - Ichabod was killed. HH hit him w/ pumpkin. They found horse, but if he were smart and was running away, he'd take it with him. Quoted incident w/ HH. HH grabbed him as he was going by.
Mitchell - agreed w/ Britton. Schoolhouse said to be haunted by schoolmaster.
Austin - BB did it. He was trying to get rid of Ichabod to have Katrina.
Ava - BB married Katrina. Thinks he threatened but didn't kill him. He wanted to get rid of him.
BB knows more to the story (smile on his face when he told story); there was more to the story. BB did something to get HH to attack Ichabod or stole his horse.
JaColby - did not agree w/ Lex that HH dragged him away. "Quoted how he tumbled into the dust." Thinks BB - knocked out by HH, but BB found him and dragged him out and made sure he didn't come back.
Kiarah - agrees with Ava and Austin. Still alive but scared off by HH. BB probably had something to do with it. Old farmer spotted him in another county. BB knew more but didn't tell, and he married Katrina.
Agree/ Disagree: BB used disguise of HH to attack Ichabod. In stories, HH turned away before the bridge, but that night, he attacked him despite bridge.
Don't think BB was pretending to be HH. He said he had encountered him before.
Believes there is a HH, but that night it was BB.
A pumpkin can't kill you, but maybe.
BB wanted to challenge Ichabod to fights and did things like stopping up chimney to smoke him out of schoolhouse therefore they were trying to get rid of him.
Bethany - his smirk and reaction made you feel he knew more than he led on.
"horseman suddenly turned into a skeleton" not humanly possible, therefore not fake. There was a real HH, but it wasn't him that night.
HH is real but the night of the encounter, it wasn't the real HH but BB.
BB was the one to attack Ichabod because pumpkin was real and HH made it across bridge w/o bursting into flames.
Erik - HH was BB
Ghosts can kill you -- real objects can be held and hurled by ghost and can kill.
Whether you believe in ghosts or not, story of ghosts is believed by some.
click to edit