SE - OTF
Upbringing
Do you think upbringing or the geographical location you happened to be raised in, has any bearing on the truth of the belief?
If you were brought up in a different religion would you believe the same thing, would you believe a different thing with the same level of confidence?
Relativism
Are they just as correct in their belief as you are?
"I'd be of a different religion"
If it's a matter of the family you were raised in, what does it say to the truth of the belief?
Shouldn't truth be constant?
What about a person from another religion that believes with the same level of confidence?
Go relativist
Are they just as correct in their belief as you are?
Go deisthic
Would you think you are more justified in your position than the other person?
Could you both be correct?
How would we discover who is more correct?
Go "I'm right, they're wrong"
If people can use the same method to reach different conclusions, is the method reliable?
Where do you think they might have gotten "off track"?
How do you KNOW you're not the one misattributing ?
Would you use faith in other aspects of your life?
How is your situation different than theirs?
What makes you attribute it to (...a god / karma...)? (Instead of, for example a long lost relative from a different religion praying for you or just chance)
What do you think a ...(person with another belief)... Would do in the exact same scenario? (Who/what would they attribute the same thing to?)
If we traveled around the world, do you think (...some unrelated piece of data...) would be different?
Would a person raised in another belief (or lack there of), be just as correct in their belief as you being raised in your belief?
What's the difference between that truth and the truth about your religion
What is the relation between being raised with a belief and the belief being real?
How sure are you that your specific god exists?
Is there a chance the other person might be more correct than you?
What tool can I use to determine who is more correct of the two?
How do you KNOW you're not the one misattributing?
Could both be wrong?