Compare how authors of two texts you have studied present barriers to love?

what are the barriers to love?

love vs duty, freedom and restraint. Etiquette is the barrier, class conventions of society and expected behavior

the view is living a life that is unrestrained from the conventions of society. Forster is encouraging readers to break away from the norm.

people act as a barrier written in the 16th century, Thomas Wyatt embodies the courtly lover. loving an unattainable woman, male perspective, powerless male.

Shakespeare is saying there is no barrier to love, if love is true then it can get over any barrier. woman did not have any choice over who they married.

where are the barriers?

chapter 1- when Charlotte is against Lucy speaking to the Emerson's, they are of a lower class, and its etiquette for a young woman to not be associated with them.

chapter 6- Georges kiss with Lucy, challenging etiquette with natural imagery, Charlotte acts as a barrier.

chapter 4- George crosses a boundary (fountain) when the murder happens. Lucy is her own barrier when she reacts to George, she tries to run away from him and follow whats expected of her.

5- the driver and his lover are separated by Mr Eager. he acts as a barrier to love.

20- the reaction of the family to Lucy marrying George.

methods of the barriers?

chapters- structure of the novel, setting- Italy or England,characters- Cecil, Lucy to herself, Charlotte, Mrs honey church, Mr Beebe, Mr eager, narrative structure - omniscient narrator, third person limited

structure of poem, extended metaphor of hunt, metaphor of net, personal feel from the first person, octave and sestet.

metaphors- key images, show love is enduring, structure makes same point 3 times then concludes.

form?

novel, prose fiction

Petrachan sonnet

Shakespearean sonnet

influence of context

Victorian mindset- Forster associates them as restrictive, Edwardian- radical, challenges victorian

novel is seen as modernist, Lucy is crossing boundaries and having control over her own life.

influenced by courtly love, renaissance, Ann Boleyn is his lover.

women had no choice over marriage, pure love can be seen as luxury.

links

pursuit of the unattainable woman, to George Lucy is unattainable, he is a lower class, pain and suffering of a courtly lover link speaker pain to George suffering after he gets rejected. compare how George gets Lucy and the speaker doesn't get the deer.

contrast Shakespeare women to Lucy, she has choice, Shakespeare makes true love seem a luxury, link with Mr Emerson and Lucy convo Shakespeare form is typical but ideas are radical

116 quotes

love is not love which alters when alteration finds

ever fixed mark

is never shaken

loves not times fool

rosie lips and cheeks

bending sickles compasse come

beares it out even to the edge of doom

love alters not with his breefe houres and weekes

who so list to hount

sithens in a nett i seke to hold the wynde

diamonds in letters plain

collar symbolises wealth and she is a possession- courtly love

impossible to catch the wind like it is to catch her

the vayne travaill has weried me so sore

suffering typical of cl, link to george

click to edit