OPPOSING:
There hasbeen a continuous debate about the death toll of the resulting famine,with scholarly estimates ranging from 18 million to about 30 milliondeaths, but with recent estimates by an e-media participant as low as200,000. So the claim by Chang and Halliday (2005) that Mao murdered38 million people, and other claims that he was only partially responsi-ble and that the death tolls were much smaller, need to be reconsidered.There are now so many different interpretations of the Great LeapForward and Mao’s part in it that they need to be re-evaluated..The Cultural Revolution discourse is a prime example. Formany Chinese government officials and members of the intelligentsia
w
meanwhile :
who were dismissed from their posts and were ordered to live andwork in what was called Wu qi gan xiao (the May Seventh CadreSchool), the experience is now narrated as ‘detention in a labour camp’,and a violation of fundamental human rights. But for Mao and othersat that time, and for many even now, it was intended to create newsubjectivity. It was intended that the urban and social elite would expe-rience physical labour so that they would be able to understand andempathize with the reality of life of the majority of the people. It wasmeant to be an approach to a new way of governing and governance.The Chinese Communist Party’s (CCP) official view of the CulturalRevolution, corresponding to the mainstream Chinese intelligentsiaunderstanding and interpretation, is well received and supported bythe Western media and most of the scholarly community. For example,in Thurston’s view the Cultural Revolution led to ‘loss of culture, andof spiritual values; loss of hope and ideals; loss of time, truth, and oflife; loss, in short, of nearly everything that gives meaning to life’(Thurston 1984–85: 605–6). What Thurston says here more or lesssummarizes the general evaluation of the Cultural Revolution held bythe mainstream Western political, cultural and scholarly elite. Thisquote, for instance, is cited by Lucian Pye (1986), a prominent USscholar of Chinese political culture, and by Lee (20
MLA (Modern Language Assoc.)
Gao, Mobo C. F. The Battle for China's past : Mao and the Cultural Revolution. Pluto Press, 2008. EBSCOhost.