Please enable JavaScript.
Coggle requires JavaScript to display documents.
Higher History Unit 2: Britain Essay Plans (Labor Effectiveness…
Higher History
Unit 2: Britain
Essay Plans
Liberal Effectiveness
The Unemployed
Knowledge
Introduce National Insurance Part 2 in 1911
Policy insured workers in trades worst hit by trade depression/seasonal unemployment (ship building/engineering/construction)
Applied to 2 million men across Britain (low % of total)
Compulsory
7 shillings per week up to 15 weeks in any 1 year
Good Analysis
Huge improvement on existing provision
Helped to soften the results of unemployment
Introduction of NI had a positive impact because it along with NI part 1 = safety net
Provided workers with security and peace of mind
Bad Analysis
Payments cut off after 15 weeks regardless of the claimants situation - viewed as meaning they had not genuinely been seeking work
Step forward but not enough for a basic living (limiting success)
Contributions required from workers wages were flat rate (everyone pays the same amount)
Evaluation
Overall not the most successful
Flat rate contributions = massive bite taken out of wages
Weaker than the reforms aimed at the elderly
Pension was a more effective measure that provided for a group in greater need
The Old
Knowledge
Nearly 50% of all people forced to end their life in the workhouse
Old Age Pension Act brought in in 1908
Applied to everyone over the age of 70 provided they relied on no other income
Good Analysis
No insurance contributions were necessary (came as a right)
Did not lift people above the official poverty line but large improvement on previous laissez faire orientated arrangement that had left elderly people relying on their limited income
Logical to infer this was effective
Bad Analysis
Only half a million people qualified for the pension in 1908
This is due to several individually necessary and jointly sufficient exemptions that if violated before or during the applicant's time receiving the pension would mean it was denied to them
These violations were based on moral grounds (such as drunkenness) - laissez-faire orientated attitudes had in no way been eradicated
Evaluation
Overall was the most successful
75% decrease in elderly people entering the workhouse between 1906 and 1913 due to the introduction of the Old Age Pension Act
The Young
Knowledge
Targeted because of their importance as future workers and soldiers of Britain during a time when a main concern across the nation was poor health contributing to Britain's decline
More severely highlighted by economic recessions in the 1880's and 90's
50% of volunteer soldiers for the Boer war had to be turned away due to ill health, the war took 3 years to win
Introduced Education (Provision of meals) Act in 1906, gave local authorities the power to provide free school meals in order to address this issue
Good Analysis
Those receiving free school meals = recorded to have been gaining weight during term and losing weight during the holidays
In 1914 governments provided local authorities with grants of half the cost of providing school meals
By this time 14 million school meals per year were being provided for 158,000 children
Bad Analysis
Money that local authorities were allowed to use in order to provide this service (a half penny) was completely inadequate - small measure that could only result in limited progress
Evaluation
Overall the least effective
Mainly due to the fact that school meals were not compulsory, huge number of children missed out on help
Certainly not as strong as the reforms which targeted the elderly
Pension helped a group in society less able to help itself whereas the young could grow and develop the ability to work
The Sick Worker
Knowledge
Introduced National Insurance Part 1 in 1911
Provided compulsory insurance against sickness (if earning £160 per year)
Workers pay 4d, Employers contribute 3d and the State 2d
Provided 10s a week for 13 weeks and 5s a week for 13 subsequent weeks in any 1 year
Good Analysis
Added to National Insurance Act 2 provided a safety net against two main reasons for falling below the poverty line
All those insured had what at the time was a luxury, able to receive medical care if required
Covered 10 million men and 4 million women across Britain (loses value, toal population = 35 million people)
Bad Analysis
Payments provided were not enough to cover dependents and families of claimants (below real requirements)
The necessary contributions were a tax and loss that many resented giving up
Evaluation
Overall not the most successful
If covered by NI part 1 also likely to be covered by Part 2 which doubles the loss of money
Not as strong as the reforms aimed at the elderly
Old age pension came as a right to those that qualified rather than requiring personal contributions
Introduction....
-
Background:
Early 1900's poverty was a major problem in Britain which previous legislation such as the poor law was not effectively tackling
Social researchers Booth and Rowntree spent several years conducting surveys and producing reports on the extent of poverty in Britain
These raised awareness of the importance of dealing with this issue
-
Signposting
To deal with this between 1906 and 1914 the Liberals introduced a series of reforms aimed at tackling key areas of poverty that included help for the elderly, the unemployed, the sick worker and the young
-
LOA
It will be the purpose of this essay to argue that the Liberal reforms made a significant improvement to British people's lives in some areas such as that which resulted from the implementation of pensions but failed to do so in areas such as improving the health of young people in schools
Conclusion
Summary
Reforms aimed at assisting the young were ineffective as they were not compulsory
The National Insurance Acts were more effective but not without the serious drawback of flat rate contributions which may have made poverty worse in some situations
The most effective reform was the old age pension act which helped the group least able to help itself
Judgement
Therefore the Liberal reforms of 1906 - 1914 were partly successful in dealing with the problem of poverty in Britain in the early 1900's, dealing successfully with the issue among the elderly but not among others
Support
This can be argued to be the case due to the fact that there was a 75% decrease in old people having to enter the workhouse between 1906 and 1913 while as late as 1939 50% of local authorities in Britain were not providing free school meals to children in need
Liberal Motivation
Reports of Booth & Rowntree
Knowledge
Social researchers Booth and Rowntree conducted surveys over a span of several years with the aim of establishing the severity of the problem of poverty in Britain
Booth's work took place in London from 1889
Rowntree's work took place in York from 1901
Subsequent reports produced contained rigorous scientific statistical evidence detailing that the problem was far worse than they had feared
Rowntree's work showed that this was not only true in major cities but indubitably widespread with 1/3 of Britains entire population living in poverty
Highlighted the lack of success previous legislation like the poor law which only assisted 3% of the population had resulted in
Good Analysis
Provided the first clear and importantly scientifically based evidence
Exceptionally difficult to refute as the methods of the researchers were professional and extraordinarily thorough in order to accurately reach the depiction of the problem of poverty
This left the possibility of refraining from acting on a solution seeming entirely illogical
Bad Analysis
In reality these reports - although meticulously conclusive - were exceptionally lengthy and had not been read by the majority of British citizens meaning that it would not be strictly necessary to act on solutions to the conclusions they presented
Evaluation
Overall not the main motivating factor
The reports existed publicly for several years before the time that the Liberal's were campaigning for election in 1906 and yet no mention of social reform was detailed in their manifesto
This refutes the claim that the work of these social researchers was their inspiration for change as if this was the case surely this would have been mentioned originally before the election rather than coming to light a significant amount of time afterwards
Certainly weaker than motivation of the Liberal's being genuine concern for the poor
Genuine Concern for the Poor
Knowledge
When elected in 1906 the Liberal Party were mainly dominated by Old Liberals (men who held and were accustomed to Laissez-faire attitudes)
In 1908 the leadership of the Liberal government changed to New Liberals (arguably more modern approach motivated by general concern
Could have resulted from Liberals being more open to influence from outside sources of solutions to problems such as poverty, for instance the reports of Booth and Rowntree and the introduction of their reform
Good Analysis
Some of the reforms (for example the Old Age Pension) do not appear to have any other explanation. Elderly people are not a source of long lasting or continuing votes for the Liberal party as a result of introducing the pension, taking care of them did not benefit Britain in terms of improving the economy or security of Britain as they were no longer workers or indeed soldiers.
This shows that the Liberals actions in some cases only seem to be explained by sincere and specific concerns they hoped to introduce solutions for
Bad Analysis
Some historians argue that Churchill (an important and unquestionably influential member of the Liberal party at this point in time) worked in accordance with other priorities. Specifically, concerns for holding back the growth of socialism and protecting the greatness of the British empire through attempting to improve National efficiency and security and that these are the origins of the reforms
Evaluation
Overall this is the main motivating factor
This is primarily due to the fact that some of the reforms significantly damaged the Liberal's chances of being re-elected at the subsequent election as the reaction to the taxes they inflicted on the upper and working classes in order to fuel the needed funding for the reforms lost support for them but went ahead anyway
Concerns for National Efficiency and Security
Knowledge
Britain had suffered its first major economic depression in the 1880's and 90's
This combined with the extraordinarily poor condition of British workers that had been highlighted in the reports of Booth and Rowntree resulted in widespread concern that Britain was in economic decline
A factor which emphasised the importance of dealing with this problem is that when the Boer war had taken place from 1899-1902 around 50% of British volunteer soldiers had to be turned away due to being in far too poor physical condition to be allowed to join the fight
Good Analysis
Many of the reforms follow examples already being implemented in Germany by the late 1800's
Lloyd George was a very influential member of the Liberal party and had recently seen these first hand
This means the Liberal reforms are a direct example of a previously witnessed solution attempt to this specific problem
Bad Analysis
All of this evidence did freely exist before the time when the Liberals were campaigning for election so if this is the key motivation for social reform being implemented then it makes no sense that social reform aimed against poverty was not even merely mentioned in their manifesto
Evaluation
Overall this was not the main motivation
Old Age pension was the hardest reform for the Liberals to introduce due to the extreme financial requirements its implementation came with and this reform had absolutely nothing to do with improving national efficiency and security
This motivation is not as strong as the argument that the Liberals had genuine concern for the poor
Genuine concern would account for going to such an extreme financial extent to care for elderly people suffering in poverty
Political Motivation
Knowledge
The Liberals faced several key threats, two of which were presented by competing political parties
The first threat was from Labour based on their growing desire and ability to offer working and lower class citizens the representation they so aptly desired in parliament, particularly due to the fact that by 1900 most working class men had the vote which emphasises how crucial catering to thier needs is for any party that wishes to be re-elected or indeed elected in the first place
Although, it must be noted at this point in time the Labour party were simply beginning to rise, only holding 29 seats in parliament in 1906
A second threat facing the Liberals was from the Conservatives based on the liklihood of them returning to power after the subsequent election if the Liberals were not successful
Good Analysis
The Conservative party which had been in power prior to the Liberals being elected in 1906 had implemented some limited social reform - this made it evident that if the Liberal party was not willing to cater to the public in this way then they were. This being the case social reform seems like the most logical step for the Liberals to implement further if tey desired re-election
Bad Analysis
However, if this survival of the fittest approach was what motivated the Liberals to such a dramatic change then surely they would have simply worked alone. The Liberals are known to have worked with the Labour party on more than one occasion, refuting the concept that Labour was an influential enough threat at the time that it could have been the reason
Evaluation
Not the main motivation
The Liberals knowingly lost votes from the upper and middle classes which they had taxed through the implementation of several reforms, driving their support into the hands of the Conservatives.
Weaker than the argument for genuine concern for the poor
This is because the only explanation that seems valid in comparison to the problems found with other potential motivations is that the Liberals simply believed that implenting these reforms was the right thing to do and that they accepted that doing this would cost them
Introduction
When the Liberals came to power in 1906 their manifesto was primarily tailored to improving Britain's economic circumstances without any even mere mention of social reform
Nevertheless, between 1906 and 1914 the Liberals introduced what was at the time the most influential program of social reform that had ever been implemented in Britain
There is much historical debate discussing what exactly motivated this dramatic change in direction
-
Signposting
Arguable possible motivations include: influence from existing reports on the extent of British poverty published by social researchers Booth and Rowntree, having genuine concern for the poor, concerns for National Sufficiency and Security, and lastly political motivation based on increasing their own chances of remaining in power after the subsequent election
-
L.O.A
It will be the purpose of this essay to argue that it was in fact genuine concern for the poor which motivated the Liberals to re-direct their attention towards implementing social reform rather than debatably weaker alternatives such as influence from the work of Booth and Rowntree
Conclusion
-
Summary
There are several arguable motivations such as influence from at the time current reports on poverty or aims to improve National efficiency and security for the Liberals turning to social reform, though many of them lose their strong stance when it is pointed out that despite their previous existence social reform was not mentioned on the Liberal's manifesto during their campaign. The main factor also does not appear to be political motivation as this change in direction eventually damaged the overall public view of the Liberal party.
-
Judgement
The main factor which motivated the Liberals to implement social reform in Britain between 1906 and 1914 was genuine concern for the poor.
-
Support
This is because it alone accounts for several actions that they pressed forward otherwise inexplicably such as focusing reform on assisting the elderly people in Britain, resulting in a 75% decrease in elderly people entering the workhouse by 1913.
Labor Effectiveness
Idleness
Knowledge
Intro sentence: Lastly, Labour also turned their attention to attempting to tackle the problem of idleness - i.e. unemployment - in Britain.
British citizens at this point in time were terrified of suffering through another great depression after the chronic unemployment of the 1930's
However, by 1946 unemployment rate stood at only 2.5% only rising to 3% by 1951
This is the lowest unemployment rate recorded in the entirety of British history
Between 1945 and 1951 the Labour government adopted a 'Keynesian' approach to the economy
This means that in order to avoid mass unemployment the government makes jobs for people
Labour used; house, school and hospital building programmes in order to do this
In addition, they followed a policy of nationalism which means the state took over control of main British industries who's subsequent profits would filter back into the countries own funding rather than increasing the individual wealth of shareholders.
Good Analysis
Keeping the unemployment rate at this historic low is seen by many as an impressive achievement
The fact that they followed several policies with this deliberate intention earned public respect
Bad Analysis
They actually inherited a situation where there was going to be low unemployment despite their efforts since participation in the war had left Britain in a state which required a huge amount of clean up and repair
This naturally created employment opportunities without Labour having to become directly involved
Evaluation
Overall, not the most successful reform brought in by the post-war Labour government
It is a false perception that low unemployment was a result of Labour's success
Certainly weaker than that aimed at tackling disease in Britain
Much in contrast, the NHS was founded at the time that Labour was in power meaning that its success can be traced back to something they are responsible for
Disease
Knowledge
Intro sentence: An area that was previously neglected by the Liberals when they were in power between 1906 and 1914 was regard for general public health
Implemented social reform in order to tackle this area - through Beveridge's assessment became known as the giant of disease
Bevan (the health minister at the time) created National Health Service
Originally hoped to be comprehensive and able to treat all problems - paid for through taxation, free at the time that assistance was needed
At the time that the NHS was first founded countless doctors opposed to working for the service - resented the loss of private practices
This issue was addressed by Bevan - made working for the NHS financially attractive and turned many in his favour
Good Analysis
When the system officially became available to the public hundreds of British citizens attended doctor's surgeries in order to have an incomprehensible variety of illnesses treated
This clearly means that it is logical to infer that the NHS was an entirely necessary system of social reform that was (from the beginning) very positively received and remains so to this day
Bad Analysis
The NHS brought with it indubitably severe financial consequences
The cost of prescriptions rose from £7 million per month to £13.5 million per month by 1948
By 1949 taxation in the form of National Insurance payments only contributed to 9% of the required funding
Due to this previously greatly underestimated financial demand charges to the public had to be brought in when purchasing glasses or receiving dental treatment
The implementation of these charges was contradictory to the founding principles of the NHS and is - for critics - its flaw which lost their support at this time
Evaluation
Overall, is the most successful reform brought in by the post-war Labour government
Although critics may argue that having its founding principles broken should brand the project as a failure it must be taken into consideration that this is the reform which helped the greatest number of British people over the longest period of time
Squalor
Knowledge
Intro sentence: An additional key area that Labour focused social reform towards was the problem of squalor in Britain
Severe shortage in housing available as a consequence of bombing attacks the country suffered in WW2
True to the extent that in 1945 1/3rd of all households in Britain were in serious need of renovation & repair
Total number of households greatly increased due to upsurge in post-war divorce rates & the baby boom
Labour brought in the council house building programme - Bevan publicly promised to build high quality houses that would not simply become slums
Good Analysis
Bevan stayed true to his promise, each house produced by Labour was of exceptionally high quality, so much so that many of them remain standing to this day
Exceptional achievement when noted that the man in charge was also running the NHS - heavy responsibility but standards remained high - building reputation
Bad Analysis
In 1951 it was recorded that there were 750,000 fewer houses than there were households in Britain
This means that 3/4 of a million people remained homeless
Houses were undoubtedly good quality but the time ensuring this took slowed down the building process dramatically
Evaluation
Overall, not the most successful reform brought in by the post-war labour government
Mainly because they were unable to build anywhere near the amount of houses that were required with only 1 million out of a promised 5 million council houses being built in the end
Certainly not as strong as the Labour reforms aimed at tackling the problem of disease in Britain
NHS had a far more widespread beneficial impact on British citizens that the council house building scheme did. This can be shown when it is noted that in the first year the NHS sold 5 million pairs of glasses and treated 8 million dental patients
Want
Knowledge
Intro sentence: Another key problem that the post-war Labour government brought in social reform in attempt to resolve was the problem of poverty in Britain, referred to by Beveridge in his well-known evaluative report as the giant of want.
Previous efforts by Liberals had not minimised British poverty anywhere near the desired extent, still a prominent problem
Problem exposed to all when children from inner cities evacuated to the countryside , allowing poor health and few possessions to be witnessed by those otherwise sheltered from their suffering
Labour brought inupdated National Insurance Act in 1946, extended the system to include all working adults rather than merely those in specific industries
Compulsory and provided applicants with benefits for sickness, unemployment, maternity, widow's allowance, guardians allowance, retirement pensions and a death grant
Benefits set at 26 shillings for a single adult and 42 shillings for a couple
Good Analysis
National Insurance scheme now universal
Holes revealed in the updated system dealt with through the National Assistance Act in 1948 to catch those who fell
Shows that Labour government is willing to work to repair areas that weren't working - builds respect for work ethic
Bad Analysis
Serious problem limiting success - benefit levels set 1946 and fixed for 5 subsequent years
By 1948 when the bill became law price of goods had dramatically risen due to post-war economic inflation
Meaning money now set to be provided would not be capable of going as far as it now had to
Evaluation
Overall, not the most successful reform brought in by the post-war Labour government
Despite the existence of the supposed safety net of National Assistance many did not make use of it as it was a means tested process. This means that in order for a claimant to be approved to receive the benefit their house, belongings, bank accounts and financial status would be closely reviewed in order to assess whether they were necessarily in need of it
For many, this process was too intrusive and subsequently humiliating to sign up for
This was not as successful as the Labour government's attempt to tackle the giant of disease in Britain
This can be argued because while the National Assistance Act was means tested the NHS was a universal system more freely open to all
Ignorance
Knowledge
Intro sentence: Thirdly, the post-war Labour government turned their attention to the problem of ignorance in Britain, the roots of which were traced back to the fact that at this point in time secondary schooling was not compulsory and consequently literacy rates were low among the general population
The Education sector had taken a hit during the war - destruction of schools in bombing attacks
This fact along with a needed method to cope with the baby boom resulted in the development of a new education system
In 1944 the Butler Education Act was introduced by the coalition government - now continued by Labour
Divided secondary school education into three tiers - Grammar schools, Secondary Modern, Technical (decided by 11+ exam)
Grammar = positive academic potential, Secondary Modern = average, Technical = suited to practical skills
Appears efficient in theory but not in practice
Very few technical schools were built due to their financial requirements
Good Analysis
Efforts to reform education had been absent since mid 1800's and were very evidently required
Implementation of this new system meant secondary schooling was made compulsory and free for all - opening opportunities
Increased attendance, raising literacy rates in Britain
Bad Analysis
System was divisive and created an extent of inequality between school children - could not be deemed a success
Decision being made at such a young age contributed to assisting middle and upper class pupils while leaving those from the working class behind rather than attempting to get each individual to an equal standard
Evaluation
Overall, not the most successful reform brought in by the post-war Labour government
New school system lost the respect of many British citizens as it can be said to reflect exceptionally old-fashioned laissez-faire attitudes by simply allowing existing advantages to remain relevant to the upper classes while taking no responsibility in order to make it so they were available to others
Certainly weaker than the reforms aimed at tackling the problem of disease in Britain
Mainly due to the fact that much in contrast support for the NHS increased in Britain as the system was successfully adapted and stood the test of time
Introduction
Background
One of the greatest political upsets in British history happened in 1945 when - against the predictions of political commentators - Winston Churchill and the Conservative party unexpectedly lost the post-war general election to the Labour party
This event came as such an indubitable shock due to the fact that Churchill had been exceptionally widely supported in his role as Prime Minister as he led Britain through the second world war
So much so that his approval rating stood at 83% in May 1945
However, appreciation for Churchill's war effort was not enough to distract British citizens from their now heart-felt desire for the implementation of further social reform
Signposting
To attempt to meet the needs of British people the Labour party implemented reforms attempting to tackle Beveridge's five giants said to be holding back Britain. These were: disease, want, ignorance, squalor and idleness.
L.O.A
It will be the purpose of this essay to argue that Labour's reform in attempt to tackle disease in Britain was the most successful in meeting the needs of British people, this is much in contrast to their efforts to tackle idleness in Britain which are said by some to be ineffective
Conclusion
Summary
Labour made effort to implement social reform in Britain across a variety of areas in order to attempt to meet the needs of British people. These problems had been pointedly identified by Beveridge and noted by the British public at the time that the war ended
They included; want which the Labour party responded to by improving the original National Insurance scheme that had been brought in by the Liberals.
Ignorance, at which a new education scheme was aimed
Squalor, which was attempted to be dealt with through a council house building programme
And Idleness that they managed to maintain control of throughout their time in power
Judgement
Overall, the most successful reform brought in by the post-war Labour government between 1945 and 1951 were those aimed at tackling the problem of disease which resulted in the founding of the NHS.
Support
This is because its origin is their most nationwide accepted achievement which has evolved and remained beneficial to the British public to this day
Women
Suffragists
Evaluation
Overall, the work of the NUWSS was the main reason why some women received the vote in 1918
This can be argued as when parliament moved to make this change many of the approving politicians were those that the Suffragists had personally reached and gained the support of
Bad Analysis
However, how effective the Suffragists can be argued to have been is limited as although their peaceful tactics did gain support for their cause they did not result in a great amount of publicity since their formal approach to work and advertising was quite easily dismissed by those who were in some cases determined to remain uninterested
By extension, it must be noted that the Suffragists had been campaigning by this time for years on end and had very little to definitively show for it
Good Analysis
The Suffragists can be viewed as successful because they did achieve their goal in gaining the support of many influential MP's, raising respect and opinions of their intellectual and political ability in the minds of those at the forefront of the major decision making process
This is an achievement which other arguable factors such as the actions of the WSPU that led to women gaining the vote do not have on their side
An additional and undeniably positive aspect of their work was that the NUWSS had a powerfully large number of members (rising to 53,000 in 1914), many of which being male, this fact shows the new level of attainment that they had managed to rise to in their cause which provided them with a new strength in the eyes of potential followers
Knowledge
The NUWSS, informally known as the suffragists, was lead by Millicent Fawcett in 1897
Their aim was to use peaceful and persistent tactics in order to convince as many people as possible to support their cause in the hope that the eventual result would be an improved view of women's potential as voters and subsequently that potential ability becoming a reality
These peaceful tactics included; holding meetings, distributing leaflets, organising petitions and commonly attempting to build up relations with MP's in order to add as many influential people to their following as possible and heighten the possibility of a bill for women's rights being brought up in parliament
Women's War Work
Knowledge
In 1914 when the war began as British men were recruited and sent off in order to fight, women remained and filled the occupational gaps that had been left behind
These occupational roles that many women adapted to included working in government departments, driving public transport, becoming clerks in business, working in munition factories producing supplies for the war effort, farming and becoming members of the countries police force
The WSPU suspended their efforts at this time in order to fully dedicate themselves to this cause
Good Analysis
One positive consequence of women having and making use of this opportunity was that it made it apparent to Britain's population that they were in fact capable of working in stereotypically male professions and doing so well
It can be argued that in the eyes of men this dedication from women for their country was a sign that they had 'earned' their right to be considered as voters, although this was not the intended view that women hoped to portray it is nonetheless an element which brought them closer to the base of their goal
Bad Analysis
There are aspects of this that can be used to argue that women's war work cannot be said to have been the reason that some women were made eligible to vote in 1918
At this time, a woman's ability to vote depended on her being over 30, married and having ties to a significant amount of land ownership
The women that these criteria applied to were commonly upper class, not the younger working class women who had worked and in some cases due to poor working conditions died for the war effort making this invalid justification for the change in their political abilities
Evaluation
Overall, women's role in the war effort was not the main factor resulting in some women being given the ability to vote in 1918.
It is possible to argue that the timing of parliament acting on this cause coinciding with the end of the war was merely a government strategy as criteria women needed to meet in order to be in a position to personally gain from this act of parliament were devised for a very specific purpose
Emmeline Pankhurst - leader of the Suffragettes - met these criteria, this fact can be argued as meaning it was not women's war work which led to some women gaining the vote but instead it was potentially an attempt by the government to cut off the Suffragette movement from the top down before it was able to restart
This is certainly weaker justification than the work of the NUWSS
This can be argued because they eventually created a situation where many people in Britain saw women gaining the vote as inevitable rather than as a cause that could be permanently denied
Introduction....
-
Background:
Before 1918, the traditional view of women in Britain was exceptionally limiting. In the eyes of men and even of women who had never known any other way of thinking, women belonged in the home carrying and raising children and supporting their husbands and households in any way they could.
Women were denied the ability to vote or have any connection to political spheres due to being thought of as emotionally and morally inferior to men
There are four main factors which changed this fact over time and eventually resulted in some British women being granted the ability to vote in 1918, these factors are; the work of the NUWSS (otherwise known as the Suffragists), the actions of the WSPU (otherwise known as the suffragettes), and women's role in work during WW1.
Suffragettes
Knowledge
Frustrated as a consequence of the lack of immediate result from the work of the NUWSS, Emmeline Pankhurst broke away from them in 1903 and founded the WSPU with the belief that in order to engage the media an increased number of politician's militant tactics must be used
In accordance to this belief the slogan of the Suffragettes was widely advertised as 'Deeds not Words'
These militant tactics included chaining themselves to railings, publicly setting post boxes on fire, slashing expensive paintings in art galleries and conducting widespread hunger strikes upon arrest, resulting in the Cat and Mouse Act of 1913
Good Analysis
The actions of the Suffragettes can be argued to have positively contributed to some women gaining the vote in 1918 as many argue that without the incomprehensible amount of publicity and in some cases - for example as a result of the force - never have been taken as seriously as it was
Additionally, the arguable success of the Suffragettes is also heightened when it is noted that their very existence brought new life to a cause that had become dormant in the minds of many British citizens as by 1900 many papers had grown tired of the formal work of the NUWSS and subsequently turned a blind eye
Bad Analysis
The actions of the WSPU did bring with it many severe negative consequences, for example, over time many British citizens became frustrated and angry at the chaos being caused around them resulting in growing disapproval and isolation from the cause
The Suffragettes can be said to be limited in their success of gaining women the vote as they contributed to the widespread belief that women were too irrational to be trusted with the responsibilities that came with the right to vote
More seriously, the violent actions of the Suffragettes made it almost politically impossible for the government to allow them to vote as that would mean they were publicly seen to bow down to terror tactics, opening them up to serious potential threat which at this time in Britain was a real possibility due to the ongoing actions of the IRA
Evaluation
Overall, the actions of the WSPU were not the main reason that some women were given the right to vote in 1918
This is mainly because although they did gain an incredibly large amount of publicity, none of it was positive
This certainly had a weaker influence than the peaceful tactics of the Suffragists
This can be argued because the NUWSS provided a place for all those who did not support how the Suffragettes were causing women to be increasingly negatively viewed to work peacefully for their case all the while attempting to limit the amount of damage that could be done to their reputation as potential voters
Conclusion
Summary
In conclusion, the part played by women in the war effort was not the main reason that some women gained the vote in 1918 as it can only be argued to an exceptionally minor extent
This is because although the political movement coincided with world war one's conclusion and it potentially helped to add urgency to the case, it cannot outweigh the previous peaceful work of the NUWSS and the militant actions of the WSPU
The work of the NUWSS was the main reason that some women were finally made eligible to vote at this time as their work defended the honourable and responsible traits of women all the while gaining the support of influential politicians that eventually defended their cause inside parliament where such an opinion was needed most