Life, as defined by humans, is not extremely rare in the total universe.
What is Life?
Counter-arguments
The Rare Earth Hypothesis
The Fermi Paradox
Definitions
Characteristics
Fundumental features of life
evolution
structure and complexity
replication
products (waste or biomineral)
energy consumption
movement (internal or external)
Looking to Life on Earth for Answers
Origins and Diversity of Life on Earth
Life may have started soon after Earth became habitable, which leads to thoughts that it could have suddenly arisen in other places in the universe as well.
Where might we find life outside of Earth?
Specific Planets
Mars- signs of past water and life
Europa (moon)- signs of water and past life
The Universe Itself
Planetary systems
The Numbers
The Drake Equation
Named after Frank Drake, the American astronomer who created it in the early 1960s.
Organizes our knowledge and ignorance by separating the number of places where intelligent life exists in our galaxy into a set of terms.
He brought together the necessary conditions for life
- The number of stars in the Milky Way that survive sufficiently long for intelligent life to evolve on those planets near them
- The average number of planets around those stars
- The fraction of those planets that have the necessary conditions for life
- The probability that life may actually come about on those few planets
- The chance that the life that does arise may evolve to produce an intelligent civilization. (Meaning a form of life that can communicate with us).
When we multiply these terms together, it should give us our best estimate of the number of planets in the Milky Way that have an intelligent civilization at some point.
To get the number of intelligent civilizations that exist at any given time, we multiply that number by the ratio of the average lifetime of an intelligent civilization and the total lifetime of the Milky Way.
This equation is obviously not the end all be all as even a tiny error in any one of the terms can result in a vastly different outcome. Also, as of right now we only have the first two terms, with the third seemingly coming soon.
However, based on what we know, there are billions of potential sites for potential life, meaning the potential sites just for any form of life are extremely high.
Copernican Principle
The assumption that we as Earthlings are not special.
Example: For thousands of years we believed that we were the center of the universe and everything revolved around us. This made sense at the time as a quick look to the heavens would show that everything seemingly moves around us. This is actually a counterexample as this was the assumption that we are special, when , in this case, we weren't.
Named after Nicolaus Copernicus after he discovered that the Sun was at the center of our solar system and not the Earth.
A quick look at the diversity and origins of various lifeforms on Earth will show that all life comes out of different conditions and varies in physical features greatly.
The definition of life is extremely tricky because saying that something is alive if it reproduces can also apply to fire. And to say that it is alive if it evolves into new forms could be said of crystals. To say it is alive if it grows, moves, and decays would also apply to tons of inanimate objects.
Definition of life according to Neil Degrasse Tyson- "Life consists of sets of objects that can both reproduce and evolve."
Comparing Earth to the Rest of the Universe
The four elements that make up the matter within every living thing on Earth
Hydrogen
Oxygen
Nitrogen
Carbon
These are also on the list of the 6 most common elements in the universe. If the elements which make up life matter on Earth were extremely rare, we would surely be able to argue that life around the universe would thus be much rarer. However, with them being so common, the frequency of life has the potential to be much higher.
If we could know how often these four elements combine to create life, we could make an accurate answer to the frequency of life all around the universe. We cannot come up with an entirely accurate answer to this, however, we can look to the origins of life on Earth to make an estimate.
Cometary bombardment
The theory that comets and other space objects rained upon Earth within the first couple hundred million years of its existence, bringing ice, ammonia, hydrogen cyanide, mineral rich rocks, and many more raw materials for life.
Necessary conditions for life
Water is one of the biggest factors in the development of life as it provides a liquid solvent in which molecules can float and interact. It is the liquid medium
Miller-Urey experiment
By Stanley Miller and Harold Urey. It was an experiment intended to create a mini-environment similar to that of Earth's when life first originated on Earth.
Results
They discovered that, with as close to past-Earth's conditions as they could possibly create, the water of their environment turned out to be rich in "organic gunk." This meant that it was rich in a compound of numerous complex molecules like sugar and some of the simplest amino acids. It also produced some modestly complex molecules called nucleotides.
Showed that these ancient Earth conditions could produce the necessary starting materials and building blocks for life but there is still a huge gap between these building blocks and full on life. That gap is made up almost entirely of time.
Established that the existence of life in the universe requires:
A source of energy
A type of atom that allows complex structures to exist
A liquid solvent in which molecules can float and interact
Sufficient time for life to arise and evolve
Miller-Urey experiment established that life in the universe requires
A source of energy
A type of atom that allows complex structures to exist
A liquid solvent in which molecules can float and interact
Sufficient time for life to arise and to evolve
Three Great Branches to the Tree of Life
Bacteria
Archaea
Eucarya
most complex organisms
Individual cells have a nucleus with info for reproduction
Second most complex
Oldest and least complex
Extremophiles
Organisms that live in extreme environments.
Possibly the origins of life on Earth started with extremophiles in the sea vents. They don't need the sun as they survive through chemosynthesis, the production of energy by chemical reactions. If they can live here, then life could exist in the least likely places in space.
Extremophiles
Of the archaea branch of life
Many view them as potentially the beginnings of life on Earth. They can survive in extreme environments like the sea vents on Earth. If they can survive here, they can survive in unlikely places outside of Earth.
Carbon atoms are imperative to life as they can bond with up to 4 other atoms and when they do, it is a weak bond so it is easier for there to be the mixing of molecules and atoms during the creation of more complex forms of life.
The early arising of life on Earth hints that there is a very real possibility of the spontaneous generation of life, given the necessary conditions
It is possible that life appeared very quickly after its birth and as the bombardment of Earth went on, there was a series of mass "extinctions" in which most of life on Earth was wiped out, but what was left continued that life on and continued to expand.
It is actually possible that life has actually been wiped out several times on Earth with the conditions still being right for life to rearise after each one. This is unlikely, but it would mean that life can be reestablished out of "nothing."
More on the sea vents. Around these sea vents appeared to be entirely separate ecosystems totally disconnected from the rest of the world outside of its reliance on the oxygen provided by the undersea plants undergoing photosynthesis.
In all the galaxies, there are likely 10^22 planets. This means that there is an unbelievably large potential for life on other planets.
Several protoplanetary nebular disks in star-forming regions strengthen the idea that planetary systems are actually abundant.
The universe is showing signs of expanding
This supports the Big Bang Theory which states that all matter of the universe was at one point in one tiny point of existence. Then, due to some sort of impetus, there was a sort of explosion in which the matter all burst out and occupied space.
This would mean that there was a beginning to the universe and thus, we can more effectively analyze the change of life in the universe over time. We can determine that the conditions of the universe have changed over time, possibly affecting the new arising of life across the universe. Possibly, the conditions for life in the universe were "better" within the first couple hundred million years of the big bang, if it actually occurred.
Extremophiles
If they can survive in the craziest places on Earth, why not in the craziest of places in space.
A living being usually has two elements
genes- the set of instructions that tell the system how to sustain and reproduce
metabolism- the mechanism that carries these instructions out.
Various scientists describe life in totally different ways based on their professions. This is similar to the ancient Hindu story in which six blind men touch the tail, trunk, leg, or torso of an elephant each. Each one will describe the rest of the creature differently.
Some agreement on life. A living thing must meet some form of each of these requirements
Usually homeostasis, equilibrium within their internal environment
Response and learning ability in advanced forms
The ability to take in energy from their environments and transform it into growth and reproduction
Reproduction and growth
It is very complex and highly organized
At least terrestrially, all known organisms seem to
Share a carbon-based chemistry
Depend on water
Leave behind fossils w/ carbon or sulfur isotopes that point to present or past metabolism
We cannot really make a surefire definition of life as extremophiles have shown us, because they show that defining life based on what we know and have seen does not nearly encompass everything.
"In the case of life, scientists are interested in the nature of life; they are not interested in what the word ‘life’ happens to mean in our language.” –Carol Cleland, (PhD, Brown, 1981)
Astrobiology is the study of the question of our origin and the question of life in the universe
This exploration must begin with the beginnings of water filled planets that had some organic form of carbon
Potential Places of Interest
The habitable zone
The orbital radius around a star of a given spectral type that would provide a surface temperature that would keep water in liquid form
Recently, NASA’s Kepler satellite provided the first clear evidence of rocky planets. This gives us quite a few candidates for potential life that are inside the habitable zone
Once a rocky planet within the habitable zone has been identified, there are two ways to approach whether it may have life or not: the "inside-out" perspective and the "outside-in" perspective.
The “inside-out” perspective is to study the detailed history of life on Earth over the last 4.6 billion years.
The “outside-in” perspective is reliant on extra-solar cues from planetary systems in formation, where we attempt to understand the earliest evolutionary stages provided an environment where liquid water and reactive molecules were allowed to react to create chemical complexity.
This requires a focus on the beginning chemical and physical conditions of “proto planets” or younger planets.
96% of living mass is made up of H, O, C, and N
Provides the backbone of life
Silicone could function as carbon does, but silicon mostly bonds to oxygen while carbon will bond with itself and others with no clear primary bonder.
That we know of, all life has DNA, which has four bases
Adenine
Guanine
Cytosine
Thymine
The formation of Earth involved the gathering of rocky materials which came during a period of accumulation and accretion
By Enrico Fermi
Asks the question, “If the universe is vast enough for numerous possibilities of life and civilizations, spanning trillions of star systems and having existed for 13.8 billion years, how is it that humans have not received one incontrovertible signal from intelligent life?”
although microbial life found beyond Earth is a strong possibility, the chances of complex life in our galaxy are remote or nil. Species threatening obstacles our planet has dealt with led to this theory however. It also states that the fossil record suggests that it took almost 3.5 billion years for the formation of complex life, and that was through several huge extinction events. It also states that some other lucky factors Earth was blessed with are its distance from the Sun, a moon with the orbit and gravity to keep Earth in a tilt that leads to seasons, and Jupiter shielding us from many harmful asteroids.
Exoplanets
planets that circle suns in other solar systems
The Kepler space telescope has greatly expanded the discovery of exoplanets by confirming over 1000 planets and listing another 4000 as candidates.
Should be around 100 years before we can see the surface of planets at the far reaches and beyond our galaxy
"We’ve got a single 4-billion year-long experiment on Earth (as far as we know)—we’d like to find another experiment somewhere.” – Caleb Scharf, Columbia University astrophysicist and astrobiologist.
Only life we know of for sure is on Earth
For life to develop, certain elements are necessary for sure: carbon, nitrogen, oxygen, phosphorus, and sulfur. These create the backbone of life.
For life to prosper on a planet, a long-lasting energy source like a star is necessary.
Even with a star, a planet must be within the circumstellar habitable zone: a range of distances within which the radiative output of a parent star allows for liquid water.
The habitable zone changes gradually with time due to stellar evolution, whereby a star's luminosity increases over time. Ex. Look at Mars. Seems to have once had life, however it is no longer in the habitable zone.
More than 90% of stars are smaller than the Sun, making their hospitable zones closer to the stars themselves.
Any planets orbiting within the habitable zone would become tidally locked to the star, making one half of the planet continuously frozen and dark while the other side would be scorching.
This may lead to doubts, however another look to extremophiles will show that life can definitely survive in such a hostile environment.
The range of radial distances within which liquid water could be found throughout a star's entire life is the continuously habitable zone.
Most star systems have rocky inner planets and gaseous outer planets.
A geologically active planet is necessary as they produce plate tectonics which are necessary in the carbon cycle. The convective movement produced by a geologically active planet also produces a magnetic field that shields the planet and any life on it from radiation.
As of January 2012, a little over 700 extra-solar planets are known.
NASA intends to build a telescope called the Terrestrial Planet Finder to search for Earth-like planets
BCI (Biological Complexity Index)
provides a quantitative estimate of the relative probability that complex, macro-organismic life forms could have arisen on other planets outside of Earth.
As of now, only 11 (about 1.7%) of the extrasolar planets known to date have a BCI above that of Europa. However, by extrapolation, that total could be over 100 million in just our galaxy.
ESI (Earth Similarity Index) – relates prospective planets’ conditions to those of Earth.
PHI (Planetary Habitability Index) – provides a second tier of analysis for the search for life.
Many planets have BCIs close to that of Earth, and even Gl 581c is rated above Earth in this regard.
Water is among the most common molecules in the universe
Organic molecules have been found in star forming regions, around protoplanetary disks, in meteorites, in comets, and in deep space
Dictionary Definitions
Merriam-Webster definition of life
Merriam-Webster definition of rare
Definition of rare in the dictionary- “very uncommon” (page 319)
Definition of life in the dictionary- “the quality that separates plants and animals from such things as water or rock : the quality that plants and animals lose when they die” (page 228)
The Hubble Space Telescope has helped scientists discover a massive amount of cosmic turf
Beliefs of renowned scientists
John Oro, a comet researcher, estimated a hundred
Frank Drake estimated 10,000
Carl Sagan estimated around a million technological civilizations in our galaxy alone.
Since 1995, astronomers have detected at least 22 planets orbiting other stars
They have also been found in the rims of Yellowstone springs.