Given access to the same facts, how is it possible that there can be disagreement between experts in a discipline?

What are facts? What are Dogmas? Compare

What is disagreement?

Rational Disagreement

Non - Rational Disagreement

Acompanied by Theories and facts

What is the difference?

Ways of Knowing

Areas of Knowledge

History

How can facts be different in each subject?

Facts in general- dictionary definition

Facts in History

Reason

Knowledge Question

To What extent are some facts more reliable than others?

Facts

Armenian Genocide

(personal connection - going to Turkey and watching Turkish people praise Ataturk and then having an Armenian Floor mate)

External historians having the same facts and acknowledging the genocide or not

Why Would that happen?

click to edit

To what Extent is reason is a reliable way of knowing when agreeing on a fact

What makes a fact more reliable or not?

What is the role of imagination on the creation of theories, when presented same facts

Thesis

Agree - role of imgination that makes experts disagree

Disagree - use of reason should be the same for different exerts

How does context influence the creation of knowledge?